2.5 stars
For some reason, I was under the impression that this was a memoir for young readers. It is for young readers, but not a memoir. It is possibly based on the author's experiences as one of the many Jewish-German children on the Kindertransports in 1938 or maybe other Kinder’s that the author knew. I admit, I felt this did take away from the story. Historical fiction based on real people always hits harder, and is usually more detailed.
Anything related to the Holocaust is difficult to make accessible to younger readers without completely traumatizing them, but I think Irene N. Watts handled it well. It also makes sense that Marianne wouldn’t know much about what was happening back home in Germany or even around Britain as Hitler began his attacks on the Island. For some things, such as what happened to her father, we are left to make our own conclusions based on the information given, and what we already know about the reality of that time and place.
I want to mention one part of this book that really stood out to me. As would be expected in a book of this topic, Marianne faces antisemitism, accusations of being a spy for Germany, and hostility for being from the ‘enemy nation’. I would be surprised if these weren’t included because they were an unfortunate, unfair reality for Jews and Germans during both world wars. I would have liked Irene N. Watts to make the cruelty of this behaviour more clear to readers. No one gets punished or reprimanded, no one expresses their disapproval for the unkind words and actions towards Marianne, and I think it’s important that young readers are made aware that this cruelty cannot go unpunished and ignored. The scene where two ladies start screaming at Marianne, calling her “Christ killer” was particularly horrifying, especially knowing that this still happens a lot to Jewish people. This time of year, Easter, is also when this occurs more frequently. I was very upset when the only thing anybody does about this is to move Marianne to another foster home (and one that isn’t much better) and say "That was a poor start." It wasn’t Marianne’s fault!
Just so I don’t end on that sad note, there is a lot of moving around and quick passing of time in this book, which made me feel a bit lost. I think more pages could have been spent on Marianne’s relationships with her friends Bridget and Lucy, and her cousin Ruth, and her lack of good relationships with many of the other characters in this book.
Overall, it wasn’t a bad read unworthy of my time. It told an important story about events I don’t know much about, and I was excited that part of the story was spent in Wales, even though the characters there weren't great.