HEART OF STONE
Really not the best story written at all and whilst I've read worse Doctor Who novels I have read many more that are of a higher standard than this one. Being part of a 2in1 omnibus, at 200 pages long and being aimed at children I really didn't expect too much from this book. But there are alot of childrens books out there that are just as appealing to adults. Okay I didn't really expect the next "Harry Potter" but this was just lazy writting. The plot must have taken all of two minutes to concieve and then I think the writter just went where the story took him rather than developing some plotlines before hand, which resulted in a couple of plot holes and continuity errors throughout the book. The story did finally get going about 30 pages from the end and started to get a little interesting even. But then the climax to the story was so flat that it ruined the small part of this book I did quite like. Okay the book was so short I didn't really expect an indepth and insightful ending, but the writter adopted a case of Deus Ex Machina for the ending of this book, which again required very little thought and foresight on the writters part. As for the characters, well there were a couple of chapters that had some very good dialogue with the Doctor where it was quite easy to imagine the characters from the TV show in the scenario. But for the most parts The Doctor, Amy and Rory seemed largely unrelated to their TV counterparts. As for the throwaway charcaters that don't appear in the show but are in this book purely to set the storyline. Well they are just that, throwaway. One dimensional cardboard cut out characters with no personalities, I couldn't even remember their names an hour after finishing the book. To sumarise a quick read to fill a few hours but that's about it.
DEATH RIDERS
This book was alot better than the other in this omnibus. Which granted isn't really saying much. But for a story of under 200 pages long this one was very well written unlike the lazy sloppy writting of "Heart Of Stone". The throwaway characters in this book actually had something of a personality about them. Or atleast one of them did and even had a half decent back story. The three main characters were pretty spot on in respect of the personality traits of the charcaters in the TV show, so atleast the author watched a few episodes of Doctor Who before penning this, which it would seem is not always the case when reading a Who novel (or atleast that's the impresssion I get sometimes). Like the other story in this book this one took a while to get going. But rather than being boring and mundane it was actually setting the story up nicely this time. Some of the plot was far fetched but you get accustomed to suspending belief when reading or watching Doctor Who. It's not that the scenarios that the characters found themsleves in were unbelivable, it's just that some of the artistic licence applied to some of the aspects of these scenarios was a little sketchy. Especially when it came to the aspect of safety concerning a roller coaster ride that features quite heavily in this book. But I suppose in terms of the storyline certain elements had to be overlooked and also as this book is so short and aimed at children I could see why the author wouldn't want to bulk the book out with all that red tape. The book is a very quick read because as I've already said it is less than 200 pages long, but also has short chapters, large font and big spaces to bulk it out a little more. The main twist in the book was very predicatble, but again being a story for children I suppose the plot couldn't be too complex. There were a high number of spelling and grammar mistakes in the book though, which annoyed me slightly. But on the whole this was a nice quick enjoyable read and in my opinion deserves an extra star just for using the phrase "What Would The Doctor Do". I'm glad I read this story after I read the very poor excuse of a story that the other story in this omnibus was. I give this story 3.5 stars and just because I'm feeling genourous I give "Heart Of Stone" 2 stars. So as a whole I've awarded the book 3 stars.