Continuing my catch-up on Star Trek reading, I began the Rebel series by Dafydd ab Hugh. I haven't finished the series yet, so this is only a review of the first book.
The main premise is that the Bajorans take over the running of Deep Space Nine (the intent all along was for them to take over eventually) on a trial basis, while Sisko and crew take the Defiant to investigate the Cardassian's sudden interest in an inhabited planet. Kai Winn is assigned to run Deep Space Nine, which irritates Kira to no end. This part of the plot is light in this book and I expect it to be expanded in the follow-ups. Most of the book focuses on Sisko's investigation, where he discovers that the Cardassians and another race are trying to take over the planet from the inhabitants. The planet is rich in minerals and latinum and technology, while the inhabitants are weak and don't appear to be able to fight back. They seem to be a degenerative society--meaning that they were once at a high technological level, but something happened and now they barely know how to use the technology that surrounds them at even a fundamental level. This is why it's so easy for the Cardassians to take control.
I find the situation at Deep Space Nine more interesting than what's happening with Sisko on the planet. Unfortunately, that plot isn't developed much in this book, merely set up. The main focus is on Sisko and the inhabitants of the planet . . . which is unfortunate because I just don't buy into this society at all. Their first encounter with the inhabitants has the Federation crew rescuing a girl who's fallen down a well. They do so by using a rope and a board, which the local inhabitants find astounding. It turns out they put the girl down the well themselves (and could have rescued her easily with their own technology), but as a rite of passage, the girl was supposed to use the technology around her in some new way to save herself. What I couldn't stand was their reaction to the rope and board. They treated like some god and descended from heaven and given them fire. I just couldn't accept the fact that there would be a society with advanced technology (even if they hadn't developed it themselves) that wouldn't also have rudimentary skills and logic enough to use a rope and board. This basic problem persists throughout the whole book. So I had major problems with the foundation of this particular society and their problems.
But setting that aside, Sisko and crew them set out to teach the society essentially how to rebel against the Cardassian invasion. The first book is about shifting their perspective enough that they are goaded into fighting for their own planet. The whole thing violates the Prime Directive in so many ways that I just shake my head. The excuse seems to be that the Cardassians invaded, so the Federation is there to simply make them stop, but that shouldn't require that Sisko and crew interact with the locals and alter their society to such an extent. They should be focused on the Cardassians and how to get them off the planet.
There are some other issues, such as why Quark is even part of the group at all. He should never have been allowed on the mission. And a few other things along those lines.
So, I essentially have a problem with the entire set-up of the book--with the society, and with how the crew is acting to solve the problem. It's entertaining, but I've basically had to turn my brain off and just read for fun. I'm hoping the next two books focus more on Kai Winn, Kira, and the station and less on this planet.