“weren’t for Alan’s request for him to pass the ketchup bottle, he would have thought they didn’t realize he was there at all. Erin continued to complain about how Jonathan, for the third time that week, had said he needed to leave the afternoon class early, and that this time, he claimed he needed to go back to Lawrence Hall to talk to LaDonda. Nathan was puzzled to hear this. Even if Jonathan made a mistake and meant that he was meeting LaDonda at Schmidt Hall, he knew that he wasn’t telling the truth because LaDonda was waiting for Nathan in the lobby after they had returned to Lawrence Hall. Malick was waiting with her. She wanted to remind them both about meeting with Argus after dinner to prepare for the evening’s bonfire. Unless LaDonda is skilled at being at two places at once, Jonathan was definitely hiding something. Nathan noticed Jonathan”