Edward vs. Jacob discussion
The Cullens vs. The wolf pack
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Maddie
(new)
Feb 10, 2008 07:33PM
It's obvious that the cullens love her and that she would be happier as a part of her family!! :)
reply
|
flag
The cullen's are alot sweeter and nicer!
I love the Cullens so much. And I'm glad I fianlly understand why Rosalie was so mean to Bella. I really like Jacob's dad Billy, but I like the Cullens WAAAAY more. Especially Emmett and Alice. So yeah she definitly would be happier with the Cullens.
I do NOT like billy at all......even though he's just trying to protect bella........Edwards safer than jacob!
The Cullens are so awesome! they are the biggest reason that it would be so sad if Bella doesn't end up with Edward. But the wolf pack is cool in its own way, and who says Bella has to give up the Cullen family if she chooses Jacob?
Well, she kind of would have to give up the Cullens if she chose Jacob. How would she still be able to be around Edward and the Cullens knowing that she broke Edwards heart like that.
I totally agree w/ u sam! Goooo Edward!
If Edward is as perfect as you all say, Edward would forgive Bella.
Josh you are a smart person! sEE MADDIE HE ISN'T PERFECT he even mentions that in the books
Well, Edward might forgive Bella, because he loves her. But what about his family? After they saw all the pain that would cause him if she picked Jacob, why would they forgive her? Rosalie wouldnt for sure.
and even if edward forgave bella, it would still be hard for her to be around them knowing what she did to him. i mean, i probably wouldnt be able to handle it! plus, who says jacob would allow bella to see all of them?
Jacob and Billy did a lot for Bella too you know! Whose the one who told about Edward being a vampire in the first place. If Jacob never said anything than Bella could be still trying to figure out what Edward was or Edward could be in another state, city, country, etc. Without the wolf pack's help, Bella would be dead right now! Either by Victoria or by her trying to do a lot of crazy things like the motercycles or jumping off the cliff!
Edward's heart WOULD be broken but so would Jacob! Jacob's IS broken right NOW!!!! He thought Bella loved him! No one really thinks about Bella's feelings! It's all about EDWARD'S feelings! What if you were Jacob! How would you feel?
Ok well I see what u mean. In Eclipse Bella tells Jacob how she feels about him! So he knows that she loved him...he wasnt wrong about that! And I am thinking about Bella's feelings as well as Edwards becuase she picked Edward. He makes her happy. She loves him more than Jacob.
No Way! If he gets angry around her he could kill her
Same with edward...... dont you pay attention when you read at all?
HA! For Edward its not if he gets angry. And also, if she becomes a vampire, thats no longer a problem anyway. Dont YOU pay attention?
Seline, Don't lecture me one reading! Edward has never gotten angry with her! And besides, what sam said, when shes a vampire she'll be the closest thing to indestructible. And don't say she isn't going to becom e one because she's marrying him! Even Jacob accepted that! The invatations got sent out! She even has a wedding dress! It's too late for Jacob!
Fo rone thing, whether she chooses Edward or Jacob, she'd have to stay away from one of them; vampires and werewolves are mortal ememies, so someone's heart will end up broken. Unless, of course, she finds a way to break the rules. I don't doubt that she would.
Thats true, she usually does find a way to bend the rules a little bit.
She's probably going to come up with some plan tto make a truce or something
But didn't jacob disappear anyway, so there's nothing really to do?
Jacob didn't exactley run away. He just needed some peace & quiet. He needed to be away from everyone, let his emotions all come out without anyone watching him. He'll come back.
okay the book is horrible its embarrassing for steph. its like she had people vote it ruined the series for me
It was great!! You aaare just haveing a hard time finding something negative about it
Well, honestly I'm in the middle on this one. I liked the outcome of the book, but I think she should have made the ending WAY more interesting. I was soooo excited when it came out, but I think she could have made it better. Especially the very ending! Its supposed to be all exciting in the end and I thought it kinda sucked in the end!!! But overall, it was a pretty great book. But Eclipse is still my fave!
i know! i didnt really get a conclusion from that last one.
like it didnt feel like the right way to end the book i guess.
I thought that the ending was fine. She and Edward and renessme all live happily ever after and we can all get on with out lives.
Yea, but the ending was pretty pathetic still. She needed action or something in it but she said she didn't want any of her characters 2 die or anything but 2 me, having characters in books die or make choices that could leave them in pain or something, it makes the book seem so much more real and then it also brings out inner feelings. In Breaking Dawn, the end had no affect on me. They all just walked away. No excitement! Books = excitement & problems, otherwise it wouldn't be very interesting!
