When It Rains discussion

After months of contemplating... i finally decided to read this book and now i really regret reading it (not really) because it made me an emotional wreck.

I just need someone to talk to about this book. How did it make you feel, what are your favorite parts/line, at what point did you start really crying (if you did cry) and if this gut-wrenching throat clogging feeling is normal :(

Also Where you satisfied with the ending?

I know I should be but there's this void and all i can think about is 'imagine if Asher was still here, how would their relationship be now?' you know all the usual thinking after a character you so deeply love dies.... yeah that doesn't happen often.

I loved Asher, i really loved him and the fact that he helped open Kate up. They definitely had something. Don't get me wrong i loved Beau, and i wish i was happier with his ending with Kate, but i don't know. It's bittersweet i guess. i think it's the sadness and empty void that's taken over.

I cried from 50% into the book all of the way to the end. It was one of the most emotional books I have ever read. And it was sobbing crying! I liked the end. Of course I wanted him to live but I think that what makes us readers so emotionally involved is with a story with am ending like that. All in all, I loved it.

there's a second one....haven't read it yet though...

I loved this book and I loved the ending. The whole rain metaphor and the notes. Gah. It's one of the few books I've given 5 stars.

I loved that Kate needed to find happiness after all that she went through and she got that through knowing Asher and moving on with her life with Beau.

The second book is really Beau and Kate trying to move on. It made me cry too, but for different reasons.

Lisa DeJong is a great writer.

I absolutely loved the book it was written beautifully . It got really sad and I did some ugly crying . Asher was a piece of me I got so into the book I would love them so much together . I hate that he had to die and she had to watch it . And that they planned so much for a future and if it wasn't for Asher her in beau would never be together . I absolutely hated the ending oh my God . I cringed every time beau and Kate Were together . Without Asher that would've never happened . If Asher was still there they would still be together . Idontknow maybe it was just me but I couldn't stomach the ending I couldn't watch her be happy with the guy who she completely ignored or whatever the whole time she was with Asher .