Moonrise discussion

im confused in the first book starclan chose feathertail but didn't say anything about there being another prophercy how did starclan chose the exact cat to fufill the other prophecy made by the tribe of endless hunting without knowing it would be a very low chance that that would happen

Remember that starclan cannot stop major things from happening. Starclan Didn't know about the other phrophecy at that time, and they cannot follow them. Thew would be trespassing on the tribe of endless hunting's hunting grounds/territory.

Mackenzie wrote: "Remember that starclan cannot stop major things from happening. Starclan Didn't know about the other phrophecy at that time, and they cannot follow them. Thew would be trespassing on the tribe of e..."

yes but what was the chance of starclan choosing the right cat for there prochercy but not realising that she was also needed for the other prophecy

Mackenzie wrote: "Remember that starclan cannot stop major things from happening. Starclan Didn't know about the other phrophecy at that time, and they cannot follow them. Thew would be trespassing on the tribe of e..."
unless the prophecy made by the tribe of endless hunting was made after the propchercy from starclan

Bridget wrote: "Mackenzie wrote: "Remember that starclan cannot stop major things from happening. Starclan Didn't know about the other phrophecy at that time, and they cannot follow them. Thew would be trespassing..."

Or maybe the Tribe of Endless Hunting overheard StarClan's prophecy. I bet that they really had thought that Stormfur would succeed in what he thought was right. But their plan back-fired and instead of Stormfur killing Sharptooth, Feathertail thought that it was her destiny to help the Tribe of Endless Hunting as well as her Clan.

I believe that it was because they didn't want to be too predictable. I mean, the Tribe just keeps saying, oh it's Stromfur when it turned out to be Feathertail and she saved Crowfeather's life.

Yes, Yes, and YES! They are all true. StarClan didn't know that Feathertail would be needed in another prophecy.

I think that the tribe of endless hunting made the prophercy after starlcan made theirs, so the tribe of endless... would of heard starclans prophercy maybe by midnight or someone so they might of thought "these cats are brave maybe one might be able to kill sharptooth"

And Feathertail was chosen in the first place because she was Half-Clan: ThunderClan and RiverClan, and StarClan knew that the Clans had to unite in order to survive the journey to the lake.

CabinSixGryffindorEOW wrote: "And Feathertail was chosen in the first place because she was Half-Clan: ThunderClan and RiverClan, and StarClan knew that the Clans had to unite in order to survive the journey to the lake."

I hadn't even thought of that, but it's true!!

is it me or are all the chosen cats from thunderclan?

They are all from different Clans, although 3/4 of them are half ThunderClan. Brambleclaw and Tawnypelt were both half ThunderClan, half ShadowClan, and Feathertail was half ThunderClan, half RiverClan. Crowpaw was completely WindClan, I believe.