Wirral Libraries Bookbuzz discussion

This is the ninth book in the Vera series, but don't worry if you have never read any before as it is a solid stand alone book and a great first read.

Ann Cleeves doesn't once waiver in her writing of the character Vera, who is believable, likeable and unique, although with her shabby raincoat and ability to appear bumbling, there is something of Columbo about her. For those familiar with Brenda Blethyn in the TV role I defy you to read any of the books without visualising her and hearing her voice throughout.

The book is, on face value, a typical country house whodunnit. Disfunctional families, secrets galore, small community claustrophobia, class divides and a web of relationships, all intensified with the constraints of a winter in Northumbria.

At the centre is the odd "family" of Vera, the irascible Matriarch, and Joe and Holly the disgruntled teenage siblings. Her cruel to be kind treatment of them is mixed with obvious affection and in return they show her respect. It was nice to see more of Vera's background and her relationship with her father and his family, as well as insights into the lives and feelings of Holly and Joe.

The only negatives I could see were Vera being allowed to investigate a case that involved her family, and, although it is typical of Vera's character, her pursuing the killer without back up. I assume both against police procedure, but easily forgiven.

There was a clever plot twist, and strong characters as always in Ann Cleeves' books. The description of the surroundings are very atmospheric and well drawn. There was enough misdirection to present me with
several possible killers identities, keeping me guessing throughout.

The pace of the story was spot on, neither rushed, nor plodding, but reflecting the country house setting and the wintry surroundings.

An absolute winner. Deserving of five stars