Play Book Tag discussion

I don't know what to say about this book, and I'm not sure of my rating either.

On one hand, I can't claim this book was bad. The writing, the words, fit the era described while still appealing for a young, modern reader. There were twists and turns on every page, surprising ways the events went. The characters were complex and deep.

However, I can't claim I liked it. I didn't care what happened to the characters, and I wasn't engaged in reading about them. The main character I even disliked - he is the type that is as bad as someone can be only to be redeemed later (and he was, plenty, but the first impression ruined it for me). It might be only that I read this book at a time that wasn't right. Due to other things happening in my life right now, I wasn't open to enjoy this book. Maybe. I don't know.

The story is more an adventure than a romance (although the romance is there), and it seems that the two that follow in this series leave the romance out entirely. I'm only saying this so potential readers can decide if they want to pick it up or not. On the whole, I think this book is a good fit for a young adult - because of the adventure element. Maybe I was simply too old for it.

I did this on audio and I found it delightful. Yes, it is more of a YA book, and the plot is farfetched. But I quite liked Monty. I seem to like unpleasant characters when they are unabashed in their behavior. But I can definitely see your viewpoint as well.