Play Book Tag discussion

To Asmara
This topic is about To Asmara
8 views
December 2021: Other Books > To Asmara by Thomas Keneally - 3.5 stars

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Joy D | 10488 comments To Asmara: A Novel of Africa by Thomas Keneally - 3 stars - My Review

Set during the Eritrean War for Independence in the late 1980s, Australian Timothy Darcy is a journalist seeking an interview with a high-profile Ethiopian prisoner of war. He travels with a small group from Sudan to Eritrea. The group includes Henry, an American relief worker attempting to get his Ethiopian fiancé out of the region, Christine, a French woman searching for her father (a cameraman filming the war), and Dame Julia, a humanitarian seeking to educate local girls on health issues. Their journey takes them through the heart of the war zone.

“We climbed the last bends and entered, through a stone doorway in the mountainside, the tail end of the trench system. We were in a deep, cool sap. Beneath a roof of logs and earth to our right, a wide compartment was crowded with soldiers. As my eyes got used to the dimness, I could see that here yet another class was in progress! Third grade science, Moka said.”

Darcy is the narrator, so this book feels like following a journalist on his assignment. He goes into the historical background of the conflict, the famine that occurred simultaneously, the toll taken on the civilian population, and the factions involved. I do not think it is a stretch to say the typical western reader will learn a lot about this time and place in history. An unnamed editor breaks in occasionally to provide context.

A few of the storylines seem superfluous, such as the situation with Darcy's Australian wife, who has left him and is living with another man. I am unsure how this part is supposed to fit with the Eritrean-Ethiopian conflict. Otherwise, it is well-written historical fiction.

3.5


message 2: by Joanne (new)

Joanne (joabroda1) | 12846 comments I have only read Schindler's List by this author and have wanted to try others by him. Is this a good place to start or do you have others that you have read that you think might appeal to me?


message 3: by Joy D (last edited Dec 31, 2021 09:24PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Joy D | 10488 comments I do not think To Asmara is the best place to start, as it is a bit unusual for him and based on his travels in Sudan and Eritrea during the Eritrean War for Independence.

I have Confederates, The Chant of Jimmie Blacksmith, and The Daughters of Mars on my TBR, so maybe one of those?


Joy D | 10488 comments I just remembered I have read a book by Keneally that would make a great starting point:
The Widow and Her Hero by Thomas Keneally - 4 stars - My Review


back to top