Twilightinators! discussion

I would have to say that Twilight is still the best out of all three. But, Eclipse is about .1 percent away! I didn't enjoy New Moon as much, mostly because I despise Jake. The ending to the second book was amazing though! I knew Edward was lying! :).

What do you think?

Yeah, I dont have that much against Jacob...I just wish he could accept that him and Bella wont be anything more than friends.

Yes, I really think Breaking Dawn will beat them all! If she does marry edward and turn into a vampire, then it has to be the best! :)

Hmm, yeah, I thought that the whole sex thing was in the Eclipse book... New Moon is the one where Edward is barely in it at all. The whole sex thing happens when she realizes that Edward is going to let her become a vampire. Right? Maybe I'm wrong...I don't know.

I didn't like New Moon because Edward was barely in it.

i like new moon and eclipse cuz they both show that Stephenie Meyer has really progressed as a writer. i mean twilight blew me away and reading new moon and eclipse was about 5 times better. mostly i like them cuz jacob is in them a lot and he is probably my favorite guy along with edward, of course =]

i can't wait for midnight sun! i was so happy when i heard it was from edward's point of view.
although it could ruin it cuz he is suppose to b so mysterious and if we get a tour of his head he mite not b so myserious...

Yeah, I agree with you Laura. I have also read as much Midnight Sun as is posted, and I found it to be amazing. Seeing how hard it was for him will be really cool, in my opinion.

Yeah, New Moon was okay, I just didn't like that Edward was gone...I've said that a million times :). But, other than that, it was very well-written.

Wow, really? Does it say how soon it will be published after Breaking Dawn? When will it be released to the public? Hmm, I really want it before I leave! :O

twilight was my fav so far i have to admit though i do kinda feel bad for jacob even though it is his fault he wont let go but he was there for bella when she needed someone but i cant wait for edward and bella to get married...... what if she decides not to change? anyone think that will happen?

It better not!!! >:( haha,
I know it wont ;]

no probably not just a thought

my favorite is Twilight! its the best!

my fav is twilight 2! the other two didn't excite me as much but they arer still good. they would be on my topbook list if i had one!!

Twilight is my favorite...well until Midnight Sun comes out. Anything to do with Edward....

totally the same Tracie!! but right now Twilight rox!

I think twilight is my favorite so far... but the first chapter of midnight sun was...WOW!
I think Midnight sun is gonna be my fovorite out of the 5 books, but who knows...

i loved eclipse so fur!I am going to read breaking dawn!i going to do that next weekend!!

I still like eclipse even after reading breaking dawn

Twilight's still my favorite. I think it goes - 1,3,4,2 for me. I think it's mostly because 2 made me sad how Edward left, and 4 was kind of predictable after a certain point.

My favorite is Twilight,(I'd also put Midnight Sun if it ever gets finished cause I love hearing Edwards opinions) and then it would be Breaking Dawn( I'm a sucker for happy endings) then Eclipse and finally New Mood( I don't like that Edward left I cried)

Eclipse.... best suspends, best romance, best comedy (The tent scene with Jacob? HILARIOUS)

Twilightt and Eclipse are my favorites.

yeah i love twilight and eclipse!

whenever midnight sun comes out that one will probably be my favorite

2-1-4-2

TWILIGHT THEN ECLIPSE THEN BREAKING DAWN THEN NEW MOON!!! :D

sry for typing in all caps...but today i just feel like doing that.

1-3-4-2

heh. my last post was wrong.
3-1-4-2

I love them all!!!! from book one to four.. but if i where to rate them it goes like this

4-1-3-2

ummm.... whts midnight sun bout is it relatd to twilight???

My fav book is Twilight.

i enjoy new moon most.. the story is incredible.. so romantic.. adventure.. and nessie make the story more incredible!

Twilight is the best by far.

Mine is Eclipse!!! The newborn vampire thing was pretty cool!!(:

I think Eclipse was my favorite book.

I don't know why but I loved New Moon the most, I mean it goes to show you that she just really couldn't live without Edward, I mean she said she couldn't in the first one but it goes to show you in the 2nd one how deep her love really was for him. I loved it, and when he told her how much he loved her, omg it was awesome!

I like new moon also.
TEAM JACOB!

Stephenie's writing in New Moon is great, you feel the sense of Bella's loss of Edward right along with her, you read it but all the time you just want him back.

I actually cried in New Moon! I have never had that kind of reaction to a book, movie and rarely a natural human event including funerals. I went to see Twilight and my daughter talked me into reading the series...so I cheated. I seen the movie,so I just went right to New Moon. I wasn't even really thrilled with the movie (ok,but I was watching true blood).What caught my attention was the morality,self control, free will...OMG I had to catch my breath.I read Eclipse,Breaking Dawn and Yes I did go back and read Twilight. At 42 it is the story I'm drawn to. I wish I could have had these books as a youth,but I have them for my grown children and one day grandchildren.My daughters and I talk about reading them with my grandchildren one day already. To pick one book I would say Ms Meyers Midnight Sun will eclipse all of these four beautifully written books.I will treasure them all and hope she completes the series from Edwards pov and them continues with Jacob and Renesme story possibly.

BREAKING DAWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!