Sherlock and Doctor Who discussion

34 views
Sherlock Debates > Johnlock?

Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jamie, oh my timelord! HOMLES MY JAWNNNNNN (new)

Jamie (Leafycantplaygames) | 18 comments Mod
What do you think of Johnlock? (Meaning John and Sherlock as a couple) There are a lot of things hinting in the show that they like each other. Do you like this couple? And what do you think of it?


message 2: by Jamie, oh my timelord! HOMLES MY JAWNNNNNN (new)

Jamie (Leafycantplaygames) | 18 comments Mod
HOLY SHIT IT'S MARY! HAI!

XD


message 3: by Joanna (new)

Joanna (foxwrapped) Hell yes is what I think of it


message 4: by Liv (new)

Liv (osf1998) | 8 comments I love Johnlock, but I also love Sherlock with Irene.


message 5: by Em (new)

Em  (rache-rache-reichenbach) | 1 comments It's the ship that sails itself.


message 6: by Anna (new)

Anna (SylviaGrant) Oddly enough it sounds rather gay in a way. You know, I like John so much better than Sherlock because he's more understanding, kind-hearted and friendly.


message 7: by Jamie, oh my timelord! HOMLES MY JAWNNNNNN (new)

Jamie (Leafycantplaygames) | 18 comments Mod
Sylvia I don't understand your comment. o.o


message 8: by Silver (new)

Silver -attacks you and kidnaps you-


message 9: by Jamie, oh my timelord! HOMLES MY JAWNNNNNN (new)

Jamie (Leafycantplaygames) | 18 comments Mod
Silver wrote: "-attacks you and kidnaps you-"

WAHHHHHH XD


message 10: by Silver (new)

Silver talktomeeeeeeeeeeeeee


message 11: by Jamie, oh my timelord! HOMLES MY JAWNNNNNN (new)

Jamie (Leafycantplaygames) | 18 comments Mod
Silver wrote: "talktomeeeeeeeeeeeeee"

XD I'm going to get something to eat then I message you on fb. brb


message 12: by Anna (new)

Anna (SylviaGrant) It sounds like you mean they are like a gay couple.


message 13: by Silver (new)

Silver A vast majority of the Sherlock fandom believes that John and Sherlock are a gay couple, though they may not realize it yet.


message 14: by Jamie, oh my timelord! HOMLES MY JAWNNNNNN (new)

Jamie (Leafycantplaygames) | 18 comments Mod
It's a couple that people "ship" when you ship it it means you support it. The point of this topic is to see your opinion on it.


message 15: by Anna (new)

Anna (SylviaGrant) Okay! That's sounds way too weird and a little creepy!! What's next? Jim and Sherlock being the perfect couple??


message 16: by Anna (new)

Anna (SylviaGrant) I think that it is a terrible idea.


message 17: by Jamie, oh my timelord! HOMLES MY JAWNNNNNN (new)

Jamie (Leafycantplaygames) | 18 comments Mod
Why? Just stating it's terrible isn't very interesting.


message 18: by Silver (new)

Silver Don't worry, it gets less weird and creepy the longer you think about it until it becomes so normal that you don't understand how anyone else could think otherwise.


message 19: by Silver (new)

Silver Like "Mollock" ...??


message 20: by Anna (new)

Anna (SylviaGrant) It sounds way too weird for my tastes.


message 21: by Silver (new)

Silver Well do you have a different combination that you ship? cuz Titan and I both ship Johnlock :p


message 22: by Jamie, oh my timelord! HOMLES MY JAWNNNNNN (new)

Jamie (Leafycantplaygames) | 18 comments Mod
Please elaborate on why it's weird. This is very boring because you seem to be lacking the ability to EXPLAIN, EXPLAIN, EXXXPLLLLAINNNN.

HA! I GOT A SHERLOCK AND DOCTOR WHO JOKE IN THERE! WOOT! (boring and being kinda a jerk. And the explain. LIKE A DALEK!!!)

Imagine Sherlock acting like a Dalek... XD That would never happen. XD


message 23: by Silver (new)

Silver Oh. -sat here for a minute or two trying to figure out the sherlock reference-


message 24: by Fi (new)

Fi (jebbyjr) Yessss johnlock all the way


message 25: by Monica (new)

Monica They were made for each other <3 <3


message 26: by Ellie (new)

Ellie | 1 comments i like it, then i dont...
aaaararararrrnnhhhhhhgggggg i dont know, if they were together would it be weird? like:
Sherlock: i know whats going on
*John and Sherlock kiss*
i think i would be to weird there but really good in other places, really sweet.
i dont KNOW!


message 27: by Laura (last edited Apr 13, 2012 05:17PM) (new)

Laura  | 2 comments Silver wrote: "Like "Mollock" ...??"

I will go down with that ship. Always. Forever. MOLLOCK.

Edit: Well anyway on the Johnlock topic

I ship John and Sherlock, but not sexually. I think having a relationship with Sherlock can't be confined to terminologies...
But you remember Katniss and Peeta's relationship in Catching Fire? I would think John and Sherlock are kind of-ish like that. They'll sleep together and comfort each other. It's a more emotional relationship than physical relationship, which is what I love most about the John/Sherlock dynamic. It's so much more deep than lust, it's TRUE FRIENDSHIP AND TRUE UNDERSTANDING AND IDEK
THE FEELINGS MAN.
okay
bye
This post explains it a lot better


message 28: by Silver (new)

Silver -like-


message 29: by Liv (last edited Apr 13, 2012 06:00PM) (new)

Liv (osf1998) | 8 comments Anna wrote: "It sounds like you mean they are like a gay couple."

Why yes, yes that's exactly what they mean


message 30: by Liv (new)

Liv (osf1998) | 8 comments Anna wrote: "It sounds way too weird for my tastes."

I'm sorry for you


message 31: by Liv (new)

Liv (osf1998) | 8 comments Do any of you guys have a fanfiction.net account? Because I have a Johnlock story, if you guys wanna read it...

http://www.fanfiction.net/s/8013677/1...


message 32: by [deleted user] (new)

Laura wrote: "Silver wrote: "Like "Mollock" ...??"

I will go down with that ship. Always. Forever. MOLLOCK.

Edit: Well anyway on the Johnlock topic

I ship John and Sherlock, but not sexually. I think having ..."


Exactly.


message 33: by Silver (new)

Silver not yet XD I have a fictionpress account but I barely use it...


message 34: by Liv (new)

Liv (osf1998) | 8 comments Laura wrote: "Silver wrote: "Like "Mollock" ...??"

I will go down with that ship. Always. Forever. MOLLOCK.

Edit: Well anyway on the Johnlock topic

I ship John and Sherlock, but not sexually. I think having ..."


Yeah exactly!!


message 35: by Liv (new)

Liv (osf1998) | 8 comments I totally agree with Laura, I feel like John and Sherlock are meant for eachother--but not necessarily in sexual terms.


message 36: by Silver (new)

Silver Yeahh I kinda agree with that too...


message 37: by Laura (new)

Laura  | 2 comments They just have to be together
now kiss
jk but seriously their friendship is the best thing ever


message 38: by Liv (new)

Liv (osf1998) | 8 comments The show in general is the best thing in general XD


message 39: by Silver (new)

Silver I need to read that fanfiction but don't have time right now DX


message 40: by Liv (new)

Liv (osf1998) | 8 comments Hhahah. You shhoouulldd:)


message 41: by Mutantgirl36 (new)

Mutantgirl36 | 1 comments *looks down and coughs shyly* I think they make a great couple... *blushes and keeps looking down*


message 42: by Tiffany (last edited Mar 10, 2013 07:47AM) (new)

Tiffany | 10 comments I think making Sherlock and Watson a couple would ruin the dynamic of the relationship. They have a very powerful connection and each makes the other a better person. I'm not sure why deep friendship between two men must necessarily be sexual. It's such a narrow view of the endless possibilities. I prefer to think of them as "brothers in arms" -- men who develop an intense relationship based on shared experiences and struggles. As Watson is a veteran of war, this type of comradeship with men would be quite commonplace and something he'd miss.


message 43: by Natalie (new)

Natalie Laura wrote: "Silver wrote: "Like "Mollock" ...??"

I will go down with that ship. Always. Forever. MOLLOCK.

Edit: Well anyway on the Johnlock topic

I ship John and Sherlock, but not sexually. I think having ..."


I definitely agree. Although I don't have a problem with John and Sherlock becoming a couple, I can also see their emotional relationship being strong.

It shows stable relationships between two men that rely on each other and are willing to put up with each other's flaws because they care for each other that deeply.

Of course, there's nothing wrong with seeing them as a couple. The fans (specifically the shippers) are just having fun with their fantasies and are not hurting anybody.

It doesn't matter to me and I'm perfectly fine with seeing them as either a couple or strong friends.


back to top