The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner discussion

I really like Bree by the end of the book and I actually cried when she died... But in the movie Eclipse, she screams, in the book she doesn't and I am really sad that she falls for the fact that she thinks Diego is going to fight, too... What did you think about the book???

I quite liked bree too. She had a vulnerable depth to her and I found that refreshing and it cleared up a lot from Eclipse. I also like the sort of exploration and everything too.

I liked Bree a lot. I wouldn;t have been mad if they kept her alive in the movie. She is probably my favorite character out of all of them.

Marisa wrote: "I liked Bree a lot. I wouldn;t have been mad if they kept her alive in the movie. She is probably my favorite character out of all of them."

i very much agree!!!!

I loved Bree! I really wish that the Volturi would have left her alone and let the Cullens raise her. She was pretty young when she was turned, about 15, so she was pretty naieve when it comes to the ways of the world. So it didn't surprise me that she bought into all that was going on.

i loved the book! i was going to read it again.