date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Debbie
(new)
Jul 17, 2012 05:13PM
What an interesting premise! I hadn't heard of the Page 99 test either. In some respects, it does seem a reasonable litmus test, although as you suggest in relation to 'What Binds Us', it may prove to be a somewhat unrepresentative sample of the work as a whole. This, along with the potential spoilers, does lead me to wonder whether this approach does readers (or authors) any good.
reply
|
flag
yes, Debbie I agree with you. I remain on the fence. I don't quite believe that one page can tell you anything about a book. That's one reason why when I was submitting to publishers I ruled out any who wanted a sample rather than the whole manuscript. And I did try to avoid spoilers as much as I could.But I should point out that I heard from one reader who said he appreciated learning what was in my mind when I wrote the scene.


