Change in a Romance Series--Good, Bad, or Thrilling?



What happens when the series you are writing or reading changes in unexpected ways? As a reader, do you stop reading that series or author because it no longer meets your expectations of what should have happened? Or perhaps you continue to follow the stories of the author a little longer to see if perhaps you are being nudged in a new direction that isn't as bad as you once thought, only different than what you thought you wanted?

Authors, do you stick to telling the stories the way the characters bring them to you, or do you try to force them to conform to the plot or style of the way things used to be? Do you wrap up the series abruptly and start a new one in the style you want to write in and hope to find a new audience?

I know these questions are worded to my particular bias, although I would welcome other responses to the initial question about change in a series of books you've enjoyed reading--up until the author surprises you in ways you didn't want to be surprised.

Yes, you know where I'm going to come out on this debate because I've written five books to date, none of which is the same as any other one in the series. Hell, I write about very different characters period, so how can any two stories be expected to be the same? That's the greatest beauty of being an independent (self-published) author. My stories don't have to conform to the dictates of a publishing house. For instance, I can have vastly different levels of heat in them. Nobody's Hero is probably my highest heat level overall--Adam was humping like a teenager most of the book. But that doesn't mean every other couple in the series will be that sexually active (and given the direction that couple's story has taken in this saga, maybe Adam knew something I didn't back then).


Sex and even BDSM won't take place in every chapter in a Kallypso Masters epic-length novel. In one of my books, the main couple doesn't have a sexual encounter (not intercourse even) until the last chapter. In the latest, Somebody's Angel, there are a number of sex and BDSM scenes (some of them kinkier than anything I've written before--Marc and Angelina are my more sexually adventure couple), but reviewers looking for erotic reads seem not to have even noticed there was sex in the book.


In the beginning when I wrote Nobody's Angel, I planned to make this a BDSM series with lots of sex--heck, I even tried for menage, but then I wrote Masters at Arms and realized that just isn't what this series was going to be about. It's about wounded characters seeking a familial connection that was missing in their lives, whether because of combat, abuse, or some emotional disconnect. I've since stopped referring to it strictly as a BDSM series, although each book does have some degree of BDSM in it. But each couple approaches BDSM in a vastly different way from the other couples. They're all very individualistic and realistic--human, if you will. (They're certainly real to me!)

I love my readers dearly. I will go out of my way to spend time with them virtually or in person, but I can't compromise my writing to please them. Even though my last book sold far fewer copies than the one before, which sold fewer than the one before that, I'm never going to be a hack. I can't spit out formulaic books in rapid succession because my writing process isn't linear and I don't plot. I have to wait for inspiration and for the characters to tell me their stories.

And the story Luke and Cassie are telling me for the next installment in my saga borders on a sweet romance at the point I am in the writing. I'm sure that will change, but what if it didn't? What if Cassie just isn't ready to have an intimate relationship with Luke yet? I suppose I could postpone the book until they were ready, but I absolutely love where they are going with this relationship and plan to see it through to the end--which, of course, isn't the end at all in a Kallypso Masters book. You all know they will be back in other books because all of my characters are family and they just have to have that connection. I can't write a one-couple romance and leave everyone else at arm's length, even if they'd let me.

I used to be the Queen of Tease, but I think I'm becoming the Queen of the Slow Burn since Nobody's Perfect and Somebody's Angel were written. I don't write the wildly dramatic openings and then drift off. Masters at Arms's opening should have made that very evident. (While listening to the first 15 minutes of audio, I thanked God Phil Gigante was narrating, otherwise, I'd put you to sleep with all of Adam's introspection and backstory in the opening pages of that book in the bus station.)

I'm working on having new covers designed for when I hit the convention circuit this summer and am rebranding myself to be more than a pigeon-holed author who writes only one type of story. The heat level will be more realistic on the covers--altho I have no intension of changing the previous stories. I write about Marines and when they have sex, they're going to use erotic terms, not romantic fluffery.

Perhaps so many other authors (especially traditional ones) write separate series in multiple genres, so they don't trounce on reader expectations. Well, readers of indie authors need to be aware that we don't play by the rules. We don't have a marketing department telling us they can't publish our awesome story because they don't know where to shelve it. Maybe some authors want to be "shelved," but I'd much rather be read--and by readers who appreciate indie voices.

As much as I love my readers and hate the thought of any of them refusing to read further in this series, I can't compromise my writing to please readers. I write for myself and to tell the stories my characters demand. Some of the complaints I've heard about Somebody's Angel make it clear that a number of readers aren't going to have their expectations met with Nobody's Dream either. I hopeI will be able to attract an audience of readers that is open-minded (in more than just BDSM and sex) and willing to see where this saga will go as it progresses. I know I have tens of thousands of fans who will be there with me for every book I release and that they will welcome the detours and surprises--and I just want you to know I love you for letting me explore my talent as a writer and to try new things rather than become stale by giving you what you THINK you want. You are the audience I have sought from the very beginning.

One of the things I love about the way I've chosen to share these stories is that you don't lose the other characters just because they reached their happy ending. They come back--some of them come back with a vengeance, like Marc and Angelina, and need an entire new book. Lately it's become clear to me that Adam is harboring all kinds of things from his past that I didn't even know about until that scene in Somebody's Angel made it clear to me that I need to dig deeper. So I'm planning to follow Nobody's Dream with Somebody's Hero so that I can explore the depths of that man's soul. (Of course, I knew at the ending of Nobody's Hero that he hadn't really dealt with the issues of his childhood. I knew he'd have to deal with that and expected to do it in a subplot. But I've learned that when there are issues as deep as Adam's--and the man was in the Marine Corps for 25 years and in many areas of Marine responsibility, so you can bet there are things he's experienced that have only been hinted at in the past books. As his life evolves, triggers we never even imagined before are going to explode and he's going to have a hard time keeping it together for himself and Karla, much less his extended family. But he's not the only one who will have to face the past in that book. Marc, Damian, probably even Luke and Savannah all have similar issues that need to be looked at more closely. So, like Somebody's Angel, I see Somebody's Hero being a bit of a roundup of the usual characters--but taking them to places you will find anything but unusual. Readers only wanting to explore new couples in every book are going to be left in the dust, I'm afraid, because that's not where this saga is going.

I also want to point out that I am writing the "Rescue Me" series (although many readers refer to it as the "Masters at Arms" series). The series is first and foremost about wounded people in need of emotional, physical, or psychological rescue--and sometimes all three. I refuse to put bandaids on their issues and pronounce them cured before their happily ever after. I prefer to write from a realistic approach to past traumas and I speak from experience when I tell you that the romances you've read where that happens are fairy tales--and not like the realistic fairy tale I told in Nobody's Perfect, either.


Some of my characters will choose to find answers and healing in BDSM, but I'm not longer even calling it a BDSM series, because I don't see that as the major focus of this saga. I have chosen to tell the stories that fit my characters. Luke, for instance, is dabbling in rope work and throwing butterfly kisses with a single-tail whip--but Cassie is far from being where she would let him anywhere near her with rope or a whip. I refuse to force her go there just to meet reader expectations for a hot BDSM scene. Of course, Luke can be patient and powerfully persuasive at the same time, so he may break down those defenses and they might very well have a light BDSM relationship. The thing is, at only 48,005 words into the manuscript, I have not effing clue where their relationship will go. I get surprised just the same as you do--and just ask my editors how I agonized over Somebody's Angel and where it took readers. Not what any of us expected, I assure you! But they told me to listen to my characters and that they would lead me where the story needs to go. I did just that, even knowing some readers wouldn't be happy about it.

I write about a "family" of imperfect, human characters. Never a dull moment, I assure you! If you'd like to read something a little different now and then, I invite you to take a chance on my books and see what you think. Just keep your expectations out of the equation and see where the Rescue Me saga takes us both!


If you are new to my books, you can download Masters at Arms, the introduction, for FREE or splurge and get the combo with the introduction and first book for only 99 cents. Buy links are on this page of my blog.

The reading order for the rest of the saga to date is:

1. Masters at Arms & Nobody's Angel (these are permanently combined for only 99 cents)
2. Nobody's Hero
3. Nobody's Perfect
4. Somebody's Angel

And with luck and inspiration, Nobody's Dream will be the next book in the saga and (with even more hope) released later this year. (I told you I don't rush the books!)
5 likes ·   •  14 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on March 26, 2014 14:14
Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jean (new)

Jean I love your books Kallypso and I love that each one is different based on the characters. Take your time and do what you need to do. If it takes a different path or becomes something I wasn't expecting, I know that you, as the author, have your reasons for doing it and I will read ANYTHING by you. This is a favorite series of mine and so different than all the rest. I don't really consider them BDSM books....they are all based on healing and therapy for broken people. Do what you need to do...I will TRY to be patient waiting for Luke and Cassie's story!


message 2: by Heather (new)

Heather For me as a reader it depends on the change. I'm usually one to stick it through to the end of a series no matter what but there have been some that I've stopped reading because my taste changed.
so the jist...it depends...sorry that doesn't help.
However you are one of the authors I have liked and enjoyed your books, so keep up the good work. :)


message 3: by Can (last edited Mar 27, 2014 03:04PM) (new)

Can Sahin Hey there Kally, long time no see. I missed our e-mail chats.

I'm glad you are still writing. Although i haven't read anything after Nobody's Perfect, world needs talented authors like you.

Why haven't i picked up your new book(books?)? Well, you actually answered this question in your post.

AS much as i respect authors who doesn't bend under reader/critic pressure, humans are creatures of habits.

For example i like reading fantasy/sci-fi. No matter how good a self-improvement writer you are, if your books aren't fantasy, i won't read them .

I also happen to like BDSM/erotica themed books. So you got me hooked up with First three books of Rescue Me. When the Nobody's Perfect came, i went and picked it up just because i loved the previous books.

When i finished it, i was like "Ok, this is a really good book but it is not even the same genre as the previous ones". I thought "OK, this book is clearly an experiment, she will surely go back to the tested and true formula with the next book" . That's when i learned about one of the upcoming books would be a "femdom" oriented book. That was also not what i wanted to read. So i just gave up on the series.

Another thing is, I felt like the series was quickly becoming a big soap opera. I like endings in my stories. Whether happy or sad. I know it's not realistic. I know in real life people don't just live "happily ever after". But isn't that the reason we escape from our realities and take refuge in books in the first place? If i wanted realism i would just watch National Geographic.

As for the last book selling less then previous ones; were you really expecting anything else? Look at all the big name authors (especially romance/erotica authors). Most of them practically write the same story over and over again with just the different names and locales. As i stated earlier, we are creatures of habit. We all want "more of the same". If you step out of those rules, you'll surely have to pay a price.

That being said, i really hope you won't stop writing as however you want. Sure, that way, you probably won't get as many sales as traditional authors. But the fans that stuck with you will be loyal. And i imagine, you'll feel better knowing that you did what your hearth was telling you to do.

I hope, in ten years, when you turn back and look at how you spent a decade of your life, you will feel proud. None of us should want anything more then that really.

Regards
Can.


message 4: by Sharon (last edited Mar 27, 2014 02:59PM) (new)

Sharon Kallenberger Marzola First let me say that I love your books. I recommend them all the time and have several friends hooked and waiting for the next book.

As far as series go, I get bored when the first few books in a series are interesting and unexpected and then, my guess is because they are so popular, all the remaining books in a series are exactly the same. Why read the books if I know what is going to happen and/or I can write the story myself. There are a couple writers that I've followed for 20+ books and the last couple were a little disappointing but I'll get the next one hoping that it will return to what I love.

I like that your books have characters that are damaged and finding their way that is personal and unique to each couple. In life everyone is different and work through their personal trauma differently. I never lose interest in your books. From the first paragraph I continue to read until the end. Your stories hold my attention and I can't put them down.

One more comment about the change in sales...people are fickle. It isn't necessarily that fans are dropping off I think they forget. My friends are always telling me that I have to read some new book that I will love. (Since I'm easily lead I do.) Then I forget to check on an author that I follow and don't get back to the books that I'm waiting for until a few months after it is released.

Anyway don't change the way you write. People who want a good story will come back to your books even if they fall away for a short time.


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

I CANNOT believe that you've had to ask these questions, for me personally, I love your books. When I downloaded the free intro, I honestly only wanted to know about Savannah and Damian and if I'm completely honest, I thought Adam and Karla was going to be creepy- as you're aware Kally, Adam and Karla are actually my favourite book couple, period.
I love how you said that Adam was humping like a teen, as I hadn't really noticed it, I just found it so bloody adorable that 'dependable, experienced Adam' just keeps messing up and losing control over Karla, it made their story very realistic and it just grew so organically- I fell a lot in love with Adam, and in my opinion, Karla is PERFECT for him, she really had no interest in BDSM, but the way she wanted to learn for Adam was just so... perfect. The way he tried to put her off, was also perfect. I found myself more interested in the couple than the sex, as I just loved experiencing them fight their feelings for one another, and when they finally accepted their inevitable relationship... WOW, LOVE THEM!

Marc and Angelina is next.
I loved both of these as people, and honestly I love them as a couple. However, in their first book I didn't really 'connect' with them, I enjoyed the story overall, but didn't feel that passion that I get with Adam and Karla, but that was ok, as they were their own characters in their own right and I was fine with that. When the second part of their story came out, I'll be honest and admit that I only purchased it to get an Adam and Karla fix... BUT, much to my elation, I got it this time round, and am now in love with Marc and Angelina. I thought a second book for them was more self indulgent on Kally's part (sorry) but can now say without any hesitation that is was exactly what I needed to form that relationship with a great couple. The lack of intimacy in this book was totally fine with me as it fit in with what they were going through, I mean, they were having real communication problems so constantly being all over each other wouldn't have been true to the situation that they found themselves in, right?

I did find the whole forced scenes very disturbing- I know they were necessary, but were just weird, as I'm sure they were intended to be.

I don't see these books as BDSM, per se, as although they are based around the club, none of the couples are rigid in the lifestyle. Adam is a very experienced dom, yet fecks thing up daily with Karla, and Savannah has been traumatised and abused in such a brutal way that she'd NEVER have turned to it on her own, but by finally embracing it, she was able to confront her demons, tell them to fuck off and kick them out of her life- for her it was a much needed cathartic treatment.
Luke and Cassie.
If Cassie jumps straight into any kind of sex, it would just be bizarre! After what she's been through Luke is going to have to be sooooo careful with her. I'm all for their relationship to be all sweet romance- lets face it, Kally, you can write hot, you can write kink, and you write it well, but can you write sweet? I'm so looking forward to finding out, (I already know the answer) I had a problem with 2 books from a series, where I was spellbound by the first books, then found them to be such a disappointment... the difference for me is that they were both based on the same couples, with the same stories, but things were so ridiculous in the last books. I was wondering if the books had gotten mixed up. I still purchased more books from one of the authors, (Abbi Glines) because although I didn't like how one thing turned out, she is an amazing writer and her books are always satisfying.
Kally, as long as your characters don't turn into aliens/vampires or some other type of supernatural entity, then you can count me in. I have so adored your books-ALL OF THEM- so follow your own conscience, as everything you have put out there has gotten me in a death grip and refuses to let me go. I'm a total Kally fangirl and couldn't be happier.
:P
P.S. If you need any arc readers I'd be more than happy to PAY for the privilege.


message 6: by Mary (new)

Mary Robbie If wanted a predicable, step one, step two, step three, and then the end type of book I can find thousands of them. BORING!!! Variety is the spice of more than just life. Keep on your own path and we will enjoy catching up with the twists and turns.


message 7: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Avila There is nothing I would change in your books. I've enjoyed every single books. I also feel that all the characters have their own unique stories. Yes the characters are related and have some things in common, but that is why they are part of the series. I can't wait to read Cassie and Luke's story.

Happu Reading :-D


message 8: by Kim (new)

Kim  Brewing I've enjoyed your books for the romance. To be honest the BDSM didn't factor in my choice to read them. I really can't wait for Luke and Cassie's story. For them, I would be shocked if they had any kind of sex right away. Luke will have his work cut out for him, but I think their love could be epic


message 9: by Megan (new)

Megan If a man does not keep pace with his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a different drummer. Let him step to the music which he hears, however measured or far away.

Henry David Thoreau

I love all your books. Keep following your own beat.


message 10: by Joyce (new)

 Joyce I can't wait to read the next book, even without the kink! The character development is so much more important! But its nice to know we have a little love in in the last chapter to look forward to!


message 11: by Colleen Marie (new)

Colleen Marie Personally; I don't seek out BDSM as my reading preference. I go for characters, story-line, angst, and level of emotion. I first read MASTERS AT ARMS because I got it FREE (I'm a freebie whore). I was VERY surprised that I found the story appealing. I admit that many times when reading same genre type books, I simply 'tune-out' the BDSM scenes. I also admit to not really understanding BDSM and blame that mainly on so much of it being written gets mired-down with gratuitous sex scenes. They are there to make the book HOT but in many cases just don’t move the story along.

I'm always just seeking out what I call the humanity in a story, i.e. why are the characters doing or feeling a certain way. Why is a character reacting in a certain way. Is a character making me mad at them and why.........stuff like this is what usually peaks my interest in a story.

In MASTERS AT ARMS I felt a depth of characterization that isn't always found in same-type of books. Some just seem written for the sake of writing a hot book (there is definitely a market for hot books that don't tell much of a story and I do admit to reading many of them). Thing is: I don't remember them for long and cannot recall even reading the book – months later……

MASTERS AT ARMS, I can recall and in fact, I've read it twice. Each ensuing book in the series is a book that brought me exactly what I wanted to read: drama, angst, emotion, story, and 'ta-da' my favorite CHARACTERIZATION. I KNEW the characters because they were given enough depth for me to KNOW. They were human. They were imperfect. They were REAL.

Even the covers for the books were REAL - not perfect model-types.

So.....my point in this rambling post is that I came for the hot stuff (even when BDSM isn't my thing) and stayed for the story line, characters, emotions, AND how they made me feel. YES....I felt the story. I felt the emotions. I felt how the characters FELT. Best of all, I could recall the story months......later on (and this is dozens of stories down the road). Actually; I'm dismayed because I cannot remember what I read last week except to tell you that it was about a Motorcycle Club (I enjoyed it). Go me!!

So: to MS. MASTERS, I'd say take your time and get your 'take' on the characters so that YOU ARE HAPPY with what you publish. It's important to follow your muse with this story-line.

TO THINE OWN SELF BE TRUE........cliché, yes, and absolutely imperative because if each book doesn't work for you - the author - then it won't work for us readers.

May the MUSE be with you, Dear Authoress. Thank you for a wonderful series.


message 12: by [deleted user] (new)

Skeletor wrote: "Personally; I don't seek out BDSM as my reading preference. I go for characters, story-line, angst, and level of emotion. I first read MASTERS AT ARMS because I got it FREE (I'm a freebie whore)...."
I effing love your response! And couldn't agree with you more. :*


message 13: by Jean (new)

Jean Skeletor wrote: "Personally; I don't seek out BDSM as my reading preference. I go for characters, story-line, angst, and level of emotion. I first read MASTERS AT ARMS because I got it FREE (I'm a freebie whore)...."

You could not have said it better!


message 14: by Valerie (new)

Valerie Kally, let me begin by saying you are my favorite author. Your characters are wonderful. I wish you would come out with more than a novella, touching on all the past characters. Lets get back to Adams house and family and have a party with everyone.......then fracture into stories of each couple.......perhaps add a new couple? I don't know.....I long for the strength of Adam and the vulnerability of Mark.......and everyone else in between.....


back to top