Amy’s review of The Inn at Thistledown Hollow > Likes and Comments
24 likes · Like
I'm glad I read other reviews, you listed all my criticism. I can only assume that this is some sort of editing glitch? It started so strong.
Thank you so much for your honest review! It means a lot to me, and moving forward, I will absolutely try to get this editing thing down :D. I truly appreciate the feedback.
Racysteed wrote: "I'm glad I read other reviews, you listed all my criticism. I can only assume that this is some sort of editing glitch? It started so strong."
It did start strong and I still really enjoy the story, but I do hope that it gets a re-release with editing issues corrected. I think there's still value in reading it if someone wants a cosy read and knows it's not a perfect piece.
Devon wrote: "Thank you so much for your honest review! It means a lot to me, and moving forward, I will absolutely try to get this editing thing down :D. I truly appreciate the feedback."
Oh my gosh! You read it! Thank you for taking the time!!
I really did love this story and I'm looking forward to reading your next work too. The heart of this was definitely warm like a healing fiction. An no worries - if editing were easy we'd all be published authors :)
I’m so glad I read this, I went back to the beginning of the book to try and figure out where Milo came from.
I also scanned through trying to figure out where Lisa went. Where the grandmother came from. I was very confused by the people. Also for an inn for everyone to just stay for months and months.
One big question for me – if it’s an inn, where’s the beer? The mead? The alcohol? I don’t know how many travellers would stay there if all it serves his tea! There isn’t even a coffee option!
Ty I thought I was going crazy with some of these errors in the book, especially with the people introduced the same way in multiple areas, especially in the beginning of the both of guys that come in with their wives or introduce the exact same way. I literally thought on my Kindle that I accidentally skipped back a few pages and was reading the same thing over and over and the fact that people like pop in and pop out and just disappear is really annoying. It kind of like hurts the immersion when you're already really into the book.... I really want to like this book but some of the stuff makes me kind of not want to finish reading it which things cuz like one minute I'm getting into it and then stuff like this happens and then it like like I said it breaks the immersion.... Sigh ... I feel bad saying it but I might have to give it like a three-star
Thank you! I thought I was going crazy I just said the same thing in my review. This could have been a 5 star read. If the author could clear up the inconsistencies and re release it I would read it again. I gave it a 3 because I loved the whimsy. And I loved Orla and Kip.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Racysteed
(new)
Dec 16, 2025 03:58PM
I'm glad I read other reviews, you listed all my criticism. I can only assume that this is some sort of editing glitch? It started so strong.
reply
|
flag
Thank you so much for your honest review! It means a lot to me, and moving forward, I will absolutely try to get this editing thing down :D. I truly appreciate the feedback.
Racysteed wrote: "I'm glad I read other reviews, you listed all my criticism. I can only assume that this is some sort of editing glitch? It started so strong."It did start strong and I still really enjoy the story, but I do hope that it gets a re-release with editing issues corrected. I think there's still value in reading it if someone wants a cosy read and knows it's not a perfect piece.
Devon wrote: "Thank you so much for your honest review! It means a lot to me, and moving forward, I will absolutely try to get this editing thing down :D. I truly appreciate the feedback."Oh my gosh! You read it! Thank you for taking the time!!
I really did love this story and I'm looking forward to reading your next work too. The heart of this was definitely warm like a healing fiction. An no worries - if editing were easy we'd all be published authors :)
I’m so glad I read this, I went back to the beginning of the book to try and figure out where Milo came from.
I also scanned through trying to figure out where Lisa went. Where the grandmother came from. I was very confused by the people. Also for an inn for everyone to just stay for months and months.
One big question for me – if it’s an inn, where’s the beer? The mead? The alcohol? I don’t know how many travellers would stay there if all it serves his tea! There isn’t even a coffee option!
Ty I thought I was going crazy with some of these errors in the book, especially with the people introduced the same way in multiple areas, especially in the beginning of the both of guys that come in with their wives or introduce the exact same way. I literally thought on my Kindle that I accidentally skipped back a few pages and was reading the same thing over and over and the fact that people like pop in and pop out and just disappear is really annoying. It kind of like hurts the immersion when you're already really into the book.... I really want to like this book but some of the stuff makes me kind of not want to finish reading it which things cuz like one minute I'm getting into it and then stuff like this happens and then it like like I said it breaks the immersion.... Sigh ... I feel bad saying it but I might have to give it like a three-star
Thank you! I thought I was going crazy I just said the same thing in my review. This could have been a 5 star read. If the author could clear up the inconsistencies and re release it I would read it again. I gave it a 3 because I loved the whimsy. And I loved Orla and Kip.