September 2026 Results > Likes and Comments
date
newest »
newest »
Is this even a catholic book club???? Some of the books nominated don't sound faith based, they sound quite the opposite actually.
ACM, if you go to the nominations thread you can read the reason why each book was proposed. Some books are nonfiction, others are fiction written by Catholic authors.The nominations thread is here:
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Mariangel wrote: "ACM, if you go to the nominations thread you can read the reason why each book was proposed. Some books are nonfiction, others are fiction written by Catholic authors.The nominations thread is he..."
Alright, thank you
ACM wrote: "Is this even a catholic book club???? Some of the books nominated don't sound faith based, they sound quite the opposite actually."I would add, while the moderators would intervene if a book was clearly and obviously beyond the pale, we generally trust the membership of the group in their voting to select books that have a legitimate claim to being "Catholic."
I was just checking bc I don't want to be in the wrong group if you know what I mean. And my apologies if I came across as a bit of a Karen
ACM wrote: "I was just checking bc I don't want to be in the wrong group if you know what I mean. And my apologies if I came across as a bit of a Karen"No apology necessary. There have been times when I haven't read the book selected by the group because it wasn't my cup of tea.
Manuel wrote: "In the voting to select our September 2026 book of the month, we had a winner with 10 votes: With Two Eyes Into Gehenna by Jane Lebak.The rest of the voting was a..."
Manuel, can you please email me at janelebak@gmail.com?
The rest of the voting was as follows:
With 7 votes:
Viper's Tangle
With 4 votes:
The secret of the Holy Face
With 3 votes:
The rifle
With 2 votes:
Hope does not disappoint
With 1 vote (these books will be moved out of the voting list, to the end of the nominations list):
The book that made your world
Building a civilization of love
A cardiologist examines Jesus
Conversation with Christ
Exogenesis
Our Lady of the Sign
This Thing of Darkness
Why religion went obsolete
With 0 votes (these books are removed from both lists):
Eucharistic miracles
Saints vs Scoundrels
The eleven books at the top of the Nominations List will be added to the Voting List for the October 2026 voting, which will take place on August 15.