best jane austen love interest? > Likes and Comments

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Grayce (new)

Grayce I'm partial to Henry Tilney, since he's the closest to my actual type in real life, but I also love Mr. Darcy and Mr. Knightly.

Who are your favorite Jane Austen love interests, and why?


message 2: by Abigail (new)

Abigail Bok Henry Tilney, hands down!


message 3: by Jan (new)

Jan Z 1. Henry Tilney because he seems like a normal and real person. I think he and Catherine will be fine.

2. Mr Darcy. He was willing to put in self-reflection and became a better person. His treatment of Lydia was a great grand romantic gesture.

3. Captain Wentworth for the letter.

4. Mr Knightley because he is kind to others, though I do not always love the relationship between him and Emma.

5. Edward Ferrars and Colonel Brandon more or less tie for me. They are not unlikable, but for me, they are not interesting or important. The relationship between Elinor and Marianne is the important couple for me.

6. Edmund Bertram. He is judgemental and wanted to dictate his attitudes to Fanny. Although I never cared for Fanny, I think she deserved better than being his second best.


message 4: by Abigail (new)

Abigail Bok I’ll defend Edward Ferrars and Edmund Bertram for their consciences (though Edmund is less successful in that regard). Fortunately, I don’t think the romantic outcome is the point of Mansfield Park, so it remains my favorite book to read.

I have come to actively dislike Captain Wentworth over multiple rereadings of Persuasion. I roll my eyes at the letter and prefer the original ending.

And I don’t love the power dynamics between Elizabeth and Darcy (I think he’ll revert as he ages) and especially between Emma and Mr. Knightley—his hectoring and judging have become too much of a habit, and she doesn’t have the character to alter the pattern.


message 5: by Jan (new)

Jan Z I know the romantic outcome is not the point of MP, Fanny had romantic feelings for Edmund. That is why I think she deserves more.


message 6: by Virginia (new)

Virginia McCoy Mr. Knightly! :-)


message 7: by Sue (new)

Sue There's an interesting internet quiz that includes Jane Austen (as well as many, many other) characters that tries to determine which you are most like. https://openpsychometrics.org/tests/c... To my surprise, the Jane Austen character I am most like is Mr. Darcy. So I'd have to vote for him (my second closest character is Elinor Dashwood -- go figure).

This isn't entirely on point, but I thought the group might find it interesting.


message 8: by Rachel (new)

Rachel I was sure I was going to have to defend my love for Tilney (I feel he gets criticism for being more on the sarcastic side) so I'm happy to see him at the top of so many lists! He and Wentworth are my top 2.


message 9: by Abigail (new)

Abigail Bok Rachel wrote: "I was sure I was going to have to defend my love for Tilney (I feel he gets criticism for being more on the sarcastic side) so I'm happy to see him at the top of so many lists! He and Wentworth are..."

That’s an interesting pair! Wentworth is my least-liked love interest, Tilney my favorite. I’ve read some of the “Tilney’s teasing is abusive” arguments, but to me it’s very good-natured teasing and he has a generous spirit. Wentworth, by contrast, is cold to Anne even when he sees her in tears; I feel his years in the navy have brutalized his sensibilities, giving him a cruel streak. And his jealousy makes him petty.


message 10: by Jan (new)

Jan Z I got Elizabeth (Hustlers) I do not know Hustlers. I am not Elizabeth P&P. I am an Elinor.


message 11: by Grayce (new)

Grayce Sue wrote: "There's an interesting internet quiz that includes Jane Austen (as well as many, many other) characters that tries to determine which you are most like. https://openpsychometrics.org/tests/c......"

I took that test a few times for school!! Last I took it I got Sherlock Holmes, but I'll have to check it out again and see if my results have changed!!


message 12: by Grayce (new)

Grayce Rachel wrote: "I was sure I was going to have to defend my love for Tilney (I feel he gets criticism for being more on the sarcastic side) so I'm happy to see him at the top of so many lists! He and Wentworth are..."

Ugh, I love those two <3


message 13: by Grayce (last edited Sep 17, 2026 05:32PM) (new)

Grayce Abigail wrote: "Rachel wrote: "I was sure I was going to have to defend my love for Tilney (I feel he gets criticism for being more on the sarcastic side) so I'm happy to see him at the top of so many lists! He an..."

His jealousy absolutely made him act wrongly towards Anne, but he begins to thaw post-Louisa incident. In a second-chance romance, I'd be surprised if neither love interest was angry/hurt over how they left things, especially in Anne and Captain Wentworth's situation. I can see why you wouldn't like it, but I like when men change over the course of a story; it makes the romantic finale more satisfying, when you have to work for it ✨


message 14: by Jan (new)

Jan Z Your link did not work for me Grayce


message 15: by Grayce (new)

Grayce Jan wrote: "Your link did not work for me Grayce"

Go to the original comment left by Sue :)


message 16: by Grayce (new)

Grayce Update on the Open Psychometrics test: I got Penelope Garcia from Criminal Minds. I have not seen Criminal Minds :D

If anyone has a good Jane Austen specific personality quiz they think is accurate, feel free to drop it here as well!!


message 17: by Maria (new)

Maria Ellis I’ve always been partial to Captain Wentworth. Tall, dark, and mysterious? Check, Check, and Check.

I have always enjoyed how he changes throughout the book—from bitter ex to hopeful romancer.

He knows what he wants and after he gets over his hurt feelings, he takes action to get back the woman he loves.


message 18: by Jan (new)

Jan Z I agree Maria


message 19: by Virginia (new)

Virginia McCoy Oh, yes. Captain Wentworth... Swoon... 🥰


message 20: by J. (new)

J. Rubino I think there is something to be said for Wentworth - despite all of the experiences and temptations of the wider world he was exposed to, he is still true to Anne. His flirtation with Louisa does make him see how you can be wrongly "persuaded" by trusting too much in the opinion of others or allowing yourself to act out of resentment or jealousy. We tend to focus on Anne's emotional growth, but Wentworth matures too.


message 21: by Jen (new)

Jen B Maria wrote: "I’ve always been partial to Captain Wentworth. Tall, dark, and mysterious? Check, Check, and Check.

I have always enjoyed how he changes throughout the book—from bitter ex to hopeful romancer.

..."

I agree - I have always had a soft spot for Wentworth. And second chances. I've said it before and will say it again: Persuasion is my favourite JA.


back to top