William’s review of The Little Sister (Philip Marlowe #5) > Likes and Comments
48 likes · Like
William wrote: "https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/22/bo...
A newly-discovered short story by Chandler (c. 1957) slams the for-profit US health system."
Hey William,
That's one fine review of this noir classic. I started reading. About 7 chapters in, I'm finding the story packing a real punch. The men and women surrounding Marlowe give off some very negative vibes. I have to take a break for the moment but will get back to it in the not so distant future.
Thank you so much, Glenn. I really enjoyed the book. Chandler was definitely at his peak here, and with The Lady in the Lake.
William, this is my favorite Chandler novel. I've read all 7: this one has the best plot, and good investigation that makes sense, and a resolution that MAY have a girl return to Kansas, but you know she isn't staying.
Thank you, Greg.
Yes, Chandler's wit and prose is terrific here. I think my favourite is The Lady in the Lake. Or maybe this one 😉
Just did yet another reread of the novel. Who really killed Orrin? Was it truly Steelgrave? Or, was it perhaps Orfamay or even Dolores? Your thought most appreciated.
Glenn wrote: "Just did yet another reread of the novel. Who really killed Orrin? Was it truly Steelgrave? Or, was it perhaps Orfamay or even Dolores? Your thought most appreciated."
Whoops. I would have to re-read this as well, Glenn. And I'm terrible with names, which makes it even more difficult.
Glenn wrote: "Just did yet another reread of the novel. Who really killed Orrin? Was it truly Steelgrave? Or, was it perhaps Orfamay or even Dolores? Your thought most appreciated."
Hi Glenn, this is my favorite Chandler novel: the one which is most accessible, the story that flows nicely, and it's one of my favorite novels about Hollywood. I read this about a year ago, though, and I don't remember exactly who killed Orrin. But I also remember feeling that this was the most satisfying Chandler novel, all in all, so I must have been fine with the resolution. And, if the resolution is that we never really know who did it, isn't that a truthful statement about many crimes? I'll reread it eventually.
William wrote: "Glenn wrote: "Just did yet another reread of the novel. Who really killed Orrin? Was it truly Steelgrave? Or, was it perhaps Orfamay or even Dolores? Your thought most appreciated."
Whoops. I woul..."
Me too, terrible at names.
William, I'm pleased to see that you agree with me about CH 13! I was gobsmacked (for lack of a better Chandler-worthy verb) by it's brilliance. Read it twice, then a third time, slowly, admiring the rhythm, the depth of description, so many perfect words and phrases. That chapter should be required study in all creative writing programs. Thanks for mentioning it in your review.
William wrote: "Chandler wasn’t the very best, but he was so good you can't tell the difference."
It's about impossible to up Hammett's first three novels.
Have you read the "lost" noir classics?
The Last Good Kiss by James Crumley, or
Black Wings Has My Angel by Elliot Chaze
Or the new debut trilogy, the finest noir trilogy of all time Sirens by Joseph Knox?
All 10-stars extraordinary, all at the level of Chandler's best-ever noir, The Lady in the Lake.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
William wrote: "https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/22/bo...A newly-discovered short story by Chandler (c. 1957) slams the for-profit US health system."
Hey William,
That's one fine review of this noir classic. I started reading. About 7 chapters in, I'm finding the story packing a real punch. The men and women surrounding Marlowe give off some very negative vibes. I have to take a break for the moment but will get back to it in the not so distant future.
Thank you so much, Glenn. I really enjoyed the book. Chandler was definitely at his peak here, and with The Lady in the Lake.
William, this is my favorite Chandler novel. I've read all 7: this one has the best plot, and good investigation that makes sense, and a resolution that MAY have a girl return to Kansas, but you know she isn't staying.
Thank you, Greg. Yes, Chandler's wit and prose is terrific here. I think my favourite is The Lady in the Lake. Or maybe this one 😉
Just did yet another reread of the novel. Who really killed Orrin? Was it truly Steelgrave? Or, was it perhaps Orfamay or even Dolores? Your thought most appreciated.
Glenn wrote: "Just did yet another reread of the novel. Who really killed Orrin? Was it truly Steelgrave? Or, was it perhaps Orfamay or even Dolores? Your thought most appreciated."Whoops. I would have to re-read this as well, Glenn. And I'm terrible with names, which makes it even more difficult.
Glenn wrote: "Just did yet another reread of the novel. Who really killed Orrin? Was it truly Steelgrave? Or, was it perhaps Orfamay or even Dolores? Your thought most appreciated."Hi Glenn, this is my favorite Chandler novel: the one which is most accessible, the story that flows nicely, and it's one of my favorite novels about Hollywood. I read this about a year ago, though, and I don't remember exactly who killed Orrin. But I also remember feeling that this was the most satisfying Chandler novel, all in all, so I must have been fine with the resolution. And, if the resolution is that we never really know who did it, isn't that a truthful statement about many crimes? I'll reread it eventually.
William wrote: "Glenn wrote: "Just did yet another reread of the novel. Who really killed Orrin? Was it truly Steelgrave? Or, was it perhaps Orfamay or even Dolores? Your thought most appreciated."Whoops. I woul..."
Me too, terrible at names.
William, I'm pleased to see that you agree with me about CH 13! I was gobsmacked (for lack of a better Chandler-worthy verb) by it's brilliance. Read it twice, then a third time, slowly, admiring the rhythm, the depth of description, so many perfect words and phrases. That chapter should be required study in all creative writing programs. Thanks for mentioning it in your review.
William wrote: "Chandler wasn’t the very best, but he was so good you can't tell the difference."It's about impossible to up Hammett's first three novels.
Have you read the "lost" noir classics?The Last Good Kiss by James Crumley, or
Black Wings Has My Angel by Elliot Chaze
Or the new debut trilogy, the finest noir trilogy of all time Sirens by Joseph Knox?
All 10-stars extraordinary, all at the level of Chandler's best-ever noir, The Lady in the Lake.


A newly-discovered short story by Chandler (c. 1957) slams the for-profit US health system.