Andrew’s review of Beyond the Wall: East Germany, 1949-1990 > Likes and Comments
94 likes · Like
I agree with your review, however I don’t see where Hoyer got Angela Merkel’s age wrong in the first sentence. It reads „67-year old woman“ which (dated for the 3rd of October 2021) is correct.
Yes, I’m reading the book in german! Maybe someone noticed during translation, but in that case I absolutely agree, a mistake like that shouldn’t be made in any edition.
I agree with the basic gist of this review, but I wouldn't be so negative as you. Since the ideological climates in both Britain and Germany rarely allow for anything at all to be published about the DDR that isn't some variation on 'Stasiland', this intervention serves an important purpose. In an intellectual climate which, as you say, even obscures the fact that East Germans went on holiday and got married, Beyond the Wall sets itself a task and achieves it, the endless name dropping on individual people and their individual lives serves an important purpose within that. My take: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
This book is a fantastic work of history, & it shouldn't be criticised for what it never claims to be.
Little is written in the UK (& elsewhere?) about what life was actually like in the GDR. This isn't meant to be a political or sweeping history either. Perhaps those well versed in the topic will know more, but this is written for a new audience.
Moreover, the book's focus is on life for ordinary people, their experiences, hobbies, jobs, how they lived their lives. That's massively new for a state often reduced to the Stasi & the Wall.
Hoyer's other innovative work is early on where she discusses the origins of the GDR & how it came into being by accident.
Oughtn’t a blistering review complaining of a book’s lack of groundbreaking scholarship to include relevant works of groundbreaking scholarship?
Andrew, what books would you suggest as an alternative? I'm looking for a good introductory summary of this topic.
Even the most ardent anticommunists understand that East Germans went on vacation and had birthdays and dinner parties. One can acknowledge aspects of ordinary life and even the rare achievements while still understanding the overarching truth that the DDR is a case study in communist oppression. These sympathetic takes on the DDR complain of the DDR being caricatured as "Stasiland," but the DDR earned that reputation by being an authoritarian police state.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Lena
(new)
Jun 10, 2023 02:20PM
I agree with your review, however I don’t see where Hoyer got Angela Merkel’s age wrong in the first sentence. It reads „67-year old woman“ which (dated for the 3rd of October 2021) is correct.
reply
|
flag
Yes, I’m reading the book in german! Maybe someone noticed during translation, but in that case I absolutely agree, a mistake like that shouldn’t be made in any edition.
I agree with the basic gist of this review, but I wouldn't be so negative as you. Since the ideological climates in both Britain and Germany rarely allow for anything at all to be published about the DDR that isn't some variation on 'Stasiland', this intervention serves an important purpose. In an intellectual climate which, as you say, even obscures the fact that East Germans went on holiday and got married, Beyond the Wall sets itself a task and achieves it, the endless name dropping on individual people and their individual lives serves an important purpose within that. My take: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
This book is a fantastic work of history, & it shouldn't be criticised for what it never claims to be.Little is written in the UK (& elsewhere?) about what life was actually like in the GDR. This isn't meant to be a political or sweeping history either. Perhaps those well versed in the topic will know more, but this is written for a new audience.
Moreover, the book's focus is on life for ordinary people, their experiences, hobbies, jobs, how they lived their lives. That's massively new for a state often reduced to the Stasi & the Wall.
Hoyer's other innovative work is early on where she discusses the origins of the GDR & how it came into being by accident.
Oughtn’t a blistering review complaining of a book’s lack of groundbreaking scholarship to include relevant works of groundbreaking scholarship?
Andrew, what books would you suggest as an alternative? I'm looking for a good introductory summary of this topic.
Even the most ardent anticommunists understand that East Germans went on vacation and had birthdays and dinner parties. One can acknowledge aspects of ordinary life and even the rare achievements while still understanding the overarching truth that the DDR is a case study in communist oppression. These sympathetic takes on the DDR complain of the DDR being caricatured as "Stasiland," but the DDR earned that reputation by being an authoritarian police state.
