Shannon’s review of The Wife Upstairs > Likes and Comments
1690 likes · Like
I was planning to read both....isn't there any difference between them?
Devarshi wrote: "I was planning to read both....isn't there any difference between them?"
Not alot. They were both good but I read Verity (amazing book!) first so the whole time I was reading a Wife Upstairs, I couldn't believe the similiarites.
Devarshi wrote: "Okay. Thanks! Just one more question ... should I read the wife upstairs first then?"
Personally, I would read Verity first.
I read Verity and I love it. The twist or ending so mind fuck. Should I read this one? There's a much difference?
Ann-Michael wrote: "It’s giving me major “Verity” vibes, too!!!!"
It's so similar that I wonder if Colleen Hoover knows about it!
I was gonna read this- but looked at reviews first. I read Verity and loved it. I feel reading this will disappoint/distract me. I’ll hold off on this one.
I saw this book this morning in an email and yep I thought I was crazy at first because it sounds exactly like Verity!!!!
I just finished and thought the same thing. It was really good with the way it built the suspense, but a little too similar.
Ha! I was looking for this, I just read this description and thought, ‘wait….this seems way too familiar.’
As I was reading the premise, I thought maybe I had read this already. And then I saw your comment and realized , that’s the one I read, because it sounded so familiar.
Funny, I’d read another book with the same title, and thought I’d mixed the two up. I read the description of McFaddens The wife upstairs and thought that it sounded familiar, so thank you for your mention of Verity :) It confirms that I haven’t actually read this book (it was indeed the Rachel Hawkins I’d read) but now I’m not sure that I want to bother with this one either lol. I didn’t hate verity but it wasn’t my favorite so unless this is significantly better… 🤷♀️
Is it really the same? I just started reading this one and the first chapter sounded familiar…then I remember Verity.
I agree! The similarities between this and Verity by Colleen Hoover is shocking. How does this happen?
That’s exactly what I was just thinking - I was wondering if it’s the same book written under a different name??
Ugh I came here to see if other people thought that too, I’m only a couple chapters in but I don’t wanna keep reading just to read verity again. I mean I loved it but I don’t enjoy re reading books.
Agreed. I felt like I was reading Verity again from the very beginning. That said, they aren’t identical and this one is certainly worth the read.
This book wasn't written 5 years before. It was written two years after Verity. This book was published in 2020 and Verity was 2018.
I didn't like Verity (probably because it was over hyped) but I did like this one even though they are so similar.
Yeah, I thought the same thing. Way too many similarities to Verity. It wasn’t a bad book…just too similar so the twists didn’t surprise me.
I thought the same thing! But I read this before Verity, and this one has a completely different ending than Verity, also less sex descriptions!
back to top
message 1:
by
Devarshi
(new)
Apr 29, 2020 07:39PM
I was planning to read both....isn't there any difference between them?
reply
|
flag
Devarshi wrote: "I was planning to read both....isn't there any difference between them?"Not alot. They were both good but I read Verity (amazing book!) first so the whole time I was reading a Wife Upstairs, I couldn't believe the similiarites.
Devarshi wrote: "Okay. Thanks! Just one more question ... should I read the wife upstairs first then?"Personally, I would read Verity first.
I read Verity and I love it. The twist or ending so mind fuck. Should I read this one? There's a much difference?
Ann-Michael wrote: "It’s giving me major “Verity” vibes, too!!!!"It's so similar that I wonder if Colleen Hoover knows about it!
I was gonna read this- but looked at reviews first. I read Verity and loved it. I feel reading this will disappoint/distract me. I’ll hold off on this one.
I saw this book this morning in an email and yep I thought I was crazy at first because it sounds exactly like Verity!!!!
I just finished and thought the same thing. It was really good with the way it built the suspense, but a little too similar.
Ha! I was looking for this, I just read this description and thought, ‘wait….this seems way too familiar.’
As I was reading the premise, I thought maybe I had read this already. And then I saw your comment and realized , that’s the one I read, because it sounded so familiar.
Funny, I’d read another book with the same title, and thought I’d mixed the two up. I read the description of McFaddens The wife upstairs and thought that it sounded familiar, so thank you for your mention of Verity :) It confirms that I haven’t actually read this book (it was indeed the Rachel Hawkins I’d read) but now I’m not sure that I want to bother with this one either lol. I didn’t hate verity but it wasn’t my favorite so unless this is significantly better… 🤷♀️
Is it really the same? I just started reading this one and the first chapter sounded familiar…then I remember Verity.
I agree! The similarities between this and Verity by Colleen Hoover is shocking. How does this happen?
That’s exactly what I was just thinking - I was wondering if it’s the same book written under a different name??
Ugh I came here to see if other people thought that too, I’m only a couple chapters in but I don’t wanna keep reading just to read verity again. I mean I loved it but I don’t enjoy re reading books.
Agreed. I felt like I was reading Verity again from the very beginning. That said, they aren’t identical and this one is certainly worth the read.
This book wasn't written 5 years before. It was written two years after Verity. This book was published in 2020 and Verity was 2018.
I didn't like Verity (probably because it was over hyped) but I did like this one even though they are so similar.
Yeah, I thought the same thing. Way too many similarities to Verity. It wasn’t a bad book…just too similar so the twists didn’t surprise me.
I thought the same thing! But I read this before Verity, and this one has a completely different ending than Verity, also less sex descriptions!




















