Beth’s review of The Wife Upstairs > Likes and Comments
321 likes · Like
This book was started 5 years prior to Verity being published
Omg I’m so glad that someone else saw the comparison with last Mrs Parrish.. when I started this one I thought it was very odd that this was so similar to verity.
And on Reddit there’s lots of other people who tell you what all her other books are knock offs of. Wild that she can’t come up with her own ideas because she’d be good at it. She’s an entertaining writer for sure, but I can’t get down with the copy cat style she has.
This is WILD!!! And that she’s still super popular and loved and nobody is really calling her out for it.
I'm in the process of reading Verity, about halfway through. I kept saying this is so similar to one of Frieda's books. Went back to my read books to figure out which one and to check publish dates. I'm glad I'm not the only one to think about this.
If it was a true copy cat, she'd have been sued by now due to copy right. Given that the authors, or their relatives, of the claimed rip offs havn't done so, or even shown an interest in it, speaks volumes.
A lot of thrillers are just like these. There’s only so many plots that can be used in this genre. Publishing isn’t exactly a push of a button so she could have a very valid reason to why her book wasn’t exactly first. People are just pressed because Freida’s was written better. More important things to complain about.
This is not the first time I heard this. Her book "Do you remember?" is the same premise as the movie "Secret Obsession" that came out before the book. I am actually really sad that I am reading it's exactly like Verity... since I have that on my physical TBR! Ugh
I hate that she's turned out to be a copycat. I've enjoyed a lot of her books, but this has taken away my desire to read other books of hers.
I get thrillers can be similar but she took the bones of the stories and changed the names. Some she even kept the same initials of the names just switched the characters rolls. She’s a fraud. The gas station sushi of thrillers.
I’m glad someone said it!! lol. I don’t get the Freida hype. Her books are rip offs of already published books. And the other ones are always better.
I saw the similarities, but the stories to me were different enough to enjoy both. There are actually lots of similar stories to Verity. Verity had a very Rebecca feel to me. Other similar novels have a Jane Eyre feel. Ruth Ware basically just takes classics and tries to make them modern stories. In my opinion, it depends on the execution. I understand the annoyance, but I also really liked this book.
Yes! I reviewed this on my IG book page a few months ago and said almost exactly the same thing - minus the epic sushi line 🤣
I mean, in my opinion, Verity was absolutely horrible. Freida’s is 1000x better. It doesn’t make plagiarism or stealing others ideas ok, but I don’t get how so many people like Verity. Frieda’s books are so much better.
But housemate was much better than the last Mrs Parrish. And verity was garbage. I think Freida is a better writer. Maybe unoriginal, but better
Definitely don’t agree also a book being released first means nothing. The book was probably finished before verity was out. And it also seems to be verity came second.
Maybe you guys should look at the dates, this book came out BEFORE verity. So no, Colleen copied Freida.
This was published March 23rd, 2020. Verity was published December 7th, 2018. I haven't read Verity and this is my first time reading one of Frieda's books, but the people being snarky without fact-checking bothers me so here are the dates.
In my opinion, every story, movie, song, etc. is born from inspiration of others, and there’s nothing wrong with that. How many versions of Romeo and Juliet are there out there, but told in a different way? Novels can be born from inspiration of other novels as a sign of respect or admiration for the original author. Nothing wrong with that. 😊
I’m so confused..verity came out in 2021 and this came out in 2020..you can literally see the dates on this app
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jenny
(new)
Feb 23, 2023 08:40PM
This book was started 5 years prior to Verity being published
reply
|
flag
Omg I’m so glad that someone else saw the comparison with last Mrs Parrish.. when I started this one I thought it was very odd that this was so similar to verity.
And on Reddit there’s lots of other people who tell you what all her other books are knock offs of. Wild that she can’t come up with her own ideas because she’d be good at it. She’s an entertaining writer for sure, but I can’t get down with the copy cat style she has.
message 5:
by
Bec (becbingesbooks) - sorry, behind with lots of catching up to do
(new)
This is WILD!!! And that she’s still super popular and loved and nobody is really calling her out for it.
I'm in the process of reading Verity, about halfway through. I kept saying this is so similar to one of Frieda's books. Went back to my read books to figure out which one and to check publish dates. I'm glad I'm not the only one to think about this.
If it was a true copy cat, she'd have been sued by now due to copy right. Given that the authors, or their relatives, of the claimed rip offs havn't done so, or even shown an interest in it, speaks volumes.
A lot of thrillers are just like these. There’s only so many plots that can be used in this genre. Publishing isn’t exactly a push of a button so she could have a very valid reason to why her book wasn’t exactly first. People are just pressed because Freida’s was written better. More important things to complain about.
This is not the first time I heard this. Her book "Do you remember?" is the same premise as the movie "Secret Obsession" that came out before the book. I am actually really sad that I am reading it's exactly like Verity... since I have that on my physical TBR! Ugh
I hate that she's turned out to be a copycat. I've enjoyed a lot of her books, but this has taken away my desire to read other books of hers.
I get thrillers can be similar but she took the bones of the stories and changed the names. Some she even kept the same initials of the names just switched the characters rolls. She’s a fraud. The gas station sushi of thrillers.
I’m glad someone said it!! lol. I don’t get the Freida hype. Her books are rip offs of already published books. And the other ones are always better.
I saw the similarities, but the stories to me were different enough to enjoy both. There are actually lots of similar stories to Verity. Verity had a very Rebecca feel to me. Other similar novels have a Jane Eyre feel. Ruth Ware basically just takes classics and tries to make them modern stories. In my opinion, it depends on the execution. I understand the annoyance, but I also really liked this book.
Yes! I reviewed this on my IG book page a few months ago and said almost exactly the same thing - minus the epic sushi line 🤣
I mean, in my opinion, Verity was absolutely horrible. Freida’s is 1000x better. It doesn’t make plagiarism or stealing others ideas ok, but I don’t get how so many people like Verity. Frieda’s books are so much better.
But housemate was much better than the last Mrs Parrish. And verity was garbage. I think Freida is a better writer. Maybe unoriginal, but better
Definitely don’t agree also a book being released first means nothing. The book was probably finished before verity was out. And it also seems to be verity came second.
Maybe you guys should look at the dates, this book came out BEFORE verity. So no, Colleen copied Freida.
This was published March 23rd, 2020. Verity was published December 7th, 2018. I haven't read Verity and this is my first time reading one of Frieda's books, but the people being snarky without fact-checking bothers me so here are the dates.
In my opinion, every story, movie, song, etc. is born from inspiration of others, and there’s nothing wrong with that. How many versions of Romeo and Juliet are there out there, but told in a different way? Novels can be born from inspiration of other novels as a sign of respect or admiration for the original author. Nothing wrong with that. 😊
I’m so confused..verity came out in 2021 and this came out in 2020..you can literally see the dates on this app












