Ben’s review of The Fellowship of the Ring (The Lord of the Rings, #1) > Likes and Comments
1 like · Like
Amazing. Every word of what you just said was wrong.
Frankly, the movie could have used more walking and talking scenes. It felt a little “busy”, you know?
Even when I posted this, I was like, I would much rather get together with *exactly these friends* and discuss it. Because on some level I know I’m wrong, but I need you all to tell me why!
I’d love it if the four of us could take our shirts off and discuss how Rings of Power is the most faithful adaptation of Tolkien’s vision.
Don't take the bait. Don't take the bait. He *knows* how I feel about shirtless adaptation discussions.
The Two Towers is a lot better, Ben! I have always maintained that Fellowship is the weakest of the 3, both movie and book, for basically this very reason. My main gripe is that it is just a group of people heading from one fantasy place to the next fantasy place, as what feels like a contrived linear sequence to dabble in some fun fantasy biomes, like a dark mine, and an enchanted forest, etc.
But Two Towers is where the full scale of the regional, and then global, conflict becomes known. In Fellowship, it is essentially "you group of misfits and miscreants must complete this relatively mundane quest of walking really far and tossing a metal object into a fire, and if you don't, the whole world will end!!! 111" But by Two Towers, we begin to see how Sauron's armies are threatening the lives of people all over the world in real time and see how the war has already begun and has already started displacing people from their homes, not to mention the existential threat to their, um, existence (I worded that very redundantly. It's still early for me)
Anyway, if you do choose to continue, I think two towers is a lot better, same with return of the king.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Micah
(new)
Nov 06, 2026 06:54PM
Amazing. Every word of what you just said was wrong.
reply
|
flag
Frankly, the movie could have used more walking and talking scenes. It felt a little “busy”, you know?
Even when I posted this, I was like, I would much rather get together with *exactly these friends* and discuss it. Because on some level I know I’m wrong, but I need you all to tell me why!
I’d love it if the four of us could take our shirts off and discuss how Rings of Power is the most faithful adaptation of Tolkien’s vision.
Don't take the bait. Don't take the bait. He *knows* how I feel about shirtless adaptation discussions.
The Two Towers is a lot better, Ben! I have always maintained that Fellowship is the weakest of the 3, both movie and book, for basically this very reason. My main gripe is that it is just a group of people heading from one fantasy place to the next fantasy place, as what feels like a contrived linear sequence to dabble in some fun fantasy biomes, like a dark mine, and an enchanted forest, etc. But Two Towers is where the full scale of the regional, and then global, conflict becomes known. In Fellowship, it is essentially "you group of misfits and miscreants must complete this relatively mundane quest of walking really far and tossing a metal object into a fire, and if you don't, the whole world will end!!! 111" But by Two Towers, we begin to see how Sauron's armies are threatening the lives of people all over the world in real time and see how the war has already begun and has already started displacing people from their homes, not to mention the existential threat to their, um, existence (I worded that very redundantly. It's still early for me)
Anyway, if you do choose to continue, I think two towers is a lot better, same with return of the king.

