John’s review of Men Who Hate Women: The Extremism Nobody is Talking About > Likes and Comments

124 likes · 
Comments Showing 1-50 of 152 (152 new)    post a comment »

message 1: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant Hi John - when many women who have any profile at all say they receive death and rape threats on a regular basis (for instance British MPs, or female scientists) do you think this is all made up ?


message 2: by Aiva (new)

Aiva Gru John, when you talk about the "one incident in Canada in which a man had a car accident", do you mean the Toronto van attack where Alek Minassian (who himself called this attack the start of "The Incel Rebellion") purposefully killed 10 and injured 16 people? Or maybe you've heard about his friend, Elliot Rodger, a mass murderer who wrote a whole manifesto about how he thinks all women should be murdered because he can't get laid?

And your claim that "almost every single male "INCEL" shows overt symptoms of having been sexually assaulted by a woman when he was a boy" is very interesting. I guess you've got a lot of free time on your hands to psychoanalyze each and every one of these thousands of men you've never met and whose subculture apparently you know nothing about. Truly fascinating.


message 3: by SHALINI (new)

SHALINI John, maybe you will also say that any woman that has ever received rape threats were also just being hysterical or just exaggerating. Few days ago a player in my country lost a match which resulted in rape threats to his 3 year daughter! Maybe they were also just joking and we are just taking it too seriously.
Not to meantion thousands of rapes that actually occur on a daily basis. Maybe all of these woman just hate men and we're lying about what happened.


message 4: by SHALINI (new)

SHALINI Or maybe it's none of that and this book just hit too close to home.


message 5: by Gina (new)

Gina Carlson Mister John, I am still to find/personally know a woman that raped/tried to rape a boy. In the mean time, men tried to rape me since I was 8 years old, and I know women that were raped or were sexually abused. It's a good thing you read the book, it's a sad thing you didn't look around or ask the women in your life.


message 6: by John (new)

John Davis Paul wrote: "Hi John - when many women who have any profile at all say they receive death and rape threats on a regular basis (for instance British MPs, or female scientists) do you think this is all made up ?"

When many men report that they received death threats and rape threats, and threats of false accusations of rape on a regular basis, (for instance male authors, lawyers and men's rights advocates) do you think this is all made up ?

Current studies show that men are more often victims of online harassment than women, yet, you exclude men from your considerations. This has the effect of advancing greater protection (under the laws or otherwise) for women, but not men, and is a form of women's supremacy (much like the Ku Klux Klan was a women's supremacy movement).

Harassment is not a gendered phenomenon, and treating it as a gendered phenomenon in which we exclude men from empathy and protection from it is a form of hatred of men.

"Men are Harassed more than Women Online" - Cathy Young




message 7: by John (new)

John Davis Aiva wrote: "John, when you talk about the "one incident in Canada in which a man had a car accident", do you mean the Toronto van attack where Alek Minassian (who himself called this attack the start of "The I..."

I would be pleased to respond if you had asked an intelligent question instead of just making a speech for yourself.

Alek Minassian's attack was never proven to be deliberate or intentional murder. That is pure speculation from the media based on hearsay. The trial in Toronto is not until November 9, 2020.

Further, what Minassian did is no different than mass shootings by women perpetrated against men, such as Amy Bishop who opened fire on her male professor colleagues because they didn't agree with her views (look up Amy Bishop).

Then, let's look at serial killers like Aileen Wuornos who targeted vulnerable men exclusively, killing 7 of them.

As for Roger Elliott - feminists taught Elliott everything he knew:


“To call a man an animal is to flatter him; he's a machine, a walking dildo.” -Valerie Solanas, the SCUM Manifesto (“Society for Cutting Up Men”) (She shot Andy Warhol because he wouldn't have sex wth her)

"I want to see a man beaten to a bloody pulp with a high-heel shoved in his mouth, like an apple in the mouth of a pig." -Andrea Dworkin; from her book Ice and Fire .

"Kill all Men" - Clementine Ford

"“The proportion of men must be reduced to and maintained at approximately 10% of the human race.” — Sally Miller Gearhart

The fact that man-haters are panicking over a few isolate events, and, male victims of female sexual assault, has nothing to do with reality or men in general.

The fact that the hysteria and panic over "incels" is based on distorted myths and diatribe in the media has nothing to do with reality or men in general.

Laura Bates' hatred of men, and, the hatred of men of her supporters, does not affect rational, intelligent and compassionate people who are striving for solutions to many problems that affect both men and women in our culture and social structures.

Some people with intelligence and good sense don't believe every hateful thing the media dictates unlike what your comment demonstrates.


message 8: by John (last edited Oct 13, 2020 12:00PM) (new)

John Davis SHALINI wrote: "John, maybe you will also say that any woman that has ever received rape threats were also just being hysterical or just exaggerating. Few days ago a player in my country lost a match which resulte..."

Government data shows: (1) rape is a rare and uncommon crime; (2) about 99% of unreported rapes are rapes that women commit on men and boys; (3) I don't believe that "a player in your country lost a match and received threats of rape to his/her 3 year old daughter - let's see some actual evidence that what you are saying is true; (4) government statistics prove that 95% of accusations of rape made to police are false accusations (police find that 85% of accusations of rape do not have probable cause to believe a crime has been committed and the judicial system shows another 10% are false accusations).

If you think women don't lie about rape, look up Emmet Till, or the Hillsboro 5.


message 9: by John (new)

John Davis Boadicea wrote: "Like )her namesake, Boadicea can smell a rat from a fair way off. This one has authored 2 books, whose only ratings (5*, naturally) come from... guess who? Ah, the author, of course!
Yup, we're ont..."


By the Way, archeologists unearthed the grave of Boadicea (Boudicca) and found that Boadicea was a man as the skeleton was a man's skeleton. .... Intelligent people can smell a rat a fair way off when the rat names themselves "Boadicea"

Also, there is no evidence whatsoever that Roman soldiers raped Baodicea's daughters. That appears to be nothing but fantasy as part of the myth of Boadicea, and, was most likely used (if at all) as war propaganda to justify the Icinii slaughtering tens of thousands of innocent people (including the burning and looting of London).

Some people are intelligent and educated and do not rely on myths or media propaganda.


message 10: by John (new)

John Davis SHALINI wrote: "Or maybe it's none of that and this book just hit too close to home."

Maybe Laura Bates and her supporters are "Women Who Hate Men"


message 11: by John (last edited Oct 14, 2020 05:17AM) (new)

John Davis Dustin wrote: "How many incels have you "assisted," John?"

It sounds as though you are an incel. Perhaps you can find a professional in your area that can help you with your personal problems.


message 12: by John (new)

John Davis selma wrote: "woman hater detected"

Man hater detected.


message 13: by John (new)

John Davis Gina wrote: "Mister John, I am still to find/personally know a woman that raped/tried to rape a boy. In the mean time, men tried to rape me since I was 8 years old, and I know women that were raped or were sexu..."

Current, gender neutral studies show that women rape men and boys more than the other way around.

Look up Dr. Lara Stemple's work on CDC and DOJ studies. Sexual Victimization Perpetrated by Women: Federal Data Reveal Surprising Prevalence
August 2016Aggression and Violent Behavior 34


message 14: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant John - It's difficult to see any way we might find a point of agreement anywhere but would you agree that women get killed by their male partners a whole lot more than men get killed by their female partners ?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-49459674

Whilst both men and women are killed by domestic violence, the vast majority of victims are women.


message 15: by John (new)

John Davis Would you agree that women kill more men and boys in domestic settings than the other way around (including infanticide and filicide)?


"71% of Children Killed by One Parent are Killed by Their Mothers; 60% of Victims are Boys"

https://www.breakingthescience.org/Si...


message 16: by Uncle Monty (new)

Uncle Monty Look at you all attack the man like a pack of rabid dogs; ad hominem attacks too - simply because he’s presenting a counter argument. Misandry is rife in our society: men are demonised and maligned left, right and centre; to deny that is dishonest. If you condemn sexism then you should condemn it on both sides.

I noticed no one commented in response to the sickening quotes John cites from Clementine Ford and co. I remember Sharon Osbourne laughing about a women who castrated her husband while he slept for some misdemeanour, and she actually encouraged the entire audience to laugh about it. I find it fascinating how those of you on the left of politics who claim to advocate for equality are so incapable of discerning disparities when it comes to these issues.

Furthermore, anyone who cites a BBC article as as a refutation to a point loses all credibility in my opinion.


message 17: by Alexander (new)

Alexander Weber John wrote: "Alek Minassian's attack was never proven to be deliberate or intentional murder. That is pure speculation from the media based on hearsay. The trial in Toronto is not until November 9, 2020."
I don't think it is worth engaging with John, as he is clearly acting in bad faith.
However, for anyone interested, you can watch Alek Minassian's confession for the Toronto van attack
here.
Deliberate and intentional murder. Planned. Not speculation. Not hearsay.


message 18: by John (last edited Oct 13, 2020 06:11PM) (new)

John Davis "I don't think it is worth engaging with John, as he is clearly acting in bad faith.

However, for anyone interested, you can watch Alek Minassian's confession for the Toronto van attack."


Alexander is typical of the ignorance driving the narrative behind Laura Bates and her panic inducing hysteria.

The court has already ruled that Alex's mental ability to have committed a crime is the central issue in the case. Ignorant people, who lynch the mentally challenged, the mentally ill, the people with low IQ's, etc. only understand their own murderous impulses to condemn others.

Fortunately we have due process of law (even in Canada) and the trial is November 9, 2020 based upon the judge's rulings regarding the admissibility of a "confession" of a man who is mentally ill.

Intelligent and educated people decide questions based upon all of the evidence, not just a video.

Saying that this was "Deliberate and intentional murder. Planned. Not speculation. Not hearsay" is identical to the claims made by the Ku Klux Klan when they lynched over 4,000 men.

Intelligent and educated people insist on due process and trials.


message 19: by SHALINI (new)

SHALINI John if you want proof of the player, google Mahendra Singh Dhoni. He lost a match few days ago and now he has to be provided police protection because of rape threats to his daughter.


message 20: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant John : Would you agree that women kill more men and boys in domestic settings than the other way around (including infanticide and filicide)?

"71% of Children Killed by One Parent are Killed by Their Mothers; 60% of Victims are Boys"


First, I accept the findings of that survey, but here's one covering the years 1997 to 2006 from the University of Manchester here in the UK.

https://journals.plos.org/plosone/art...

They found 195 fathers who murdered, and 102 mothers who murdered in that period.

But secondly, John, is there any statistic from any Western country that shows partner homicides are 90-95% men killing women year after year? You are avoiding this point.


message 21: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant Lumpen : Furthermore, anyone who cites a BBC article as as a refutation to a point loses all credibility

I wonder if there would be a source of information about domestic violence and murder you would trust ? Do you have any suggestions?


message 22: by selma (new)

selma Your twisted perception equates feminism with man-hating so you use a single incident to generalise and trash "those of you on the left of politics who claim to advocate for equality". Feminism condemns every kind of sexism. But you just want to preserve your false view of feminism and to do so you can ransack the internet and find some spesific cases to justify your point. But patriarchy is too obvious to ignore and you sound like a nutcase. Also your WHATABOUTISM is an example of fallacy. So, you know ad hominem here is another concept you need to learn.

Excuse us we didn't react that part of the review because that review is so full of nonsense. There are some woman-haters like you who ignore the whole violence and mistreatment towards women and miss the point about a book and cry over misandry in their privileged and comfortable position. John's fixation on "predator" women is just ridiculous and his books speak volumes about his mindset. Perhaps this feminist books triggers your fragile male ego sentiments because you are one of them who is mentioned in this book??


message 23: by John (new)

John Davis UK information on domestic violence, especially from the BBC is deliberately biased to exclude actual statistics of male victims of violent women. That has been true for 5 decades.

Why don't you take a look at the information a gender neutral expert provides on the subject of domestic violence.

https://www.bettinaarndt.com.au/video...

References:

Deborah Powney & Nicola Graham-Kevan (2019): ‘Male Victims of Intimate Partner Violence: A Challenge to the Gendered Paradigm’, in The Palgrave Handbook of Male Psychology and Mental Health (Palgrave Macmillan, 2019)
https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9783...

Professor Linda Kelly FSU

Disabusing the Definition of Domestic Violence: How Women Batter Men and the Role of the Feminist State, Florida State University Law Review,

https://ir.law.fsu.edu/cgi/viewconten...

Harvard Medical School: Women commit 70% of domestic violence

Differences in Frequency of Violence and Reported Injury Between Relationships With Reciprocal and Nonreciprocal Intimate Partner Violence

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...


message 24: by John (new)

John Davis Lumpen_Proletariat wrote: "Look at you all attack the man like a pack of rabid dogs; ad hominem attacks too - simply because he’s presenting a counter argument. Misandry is rife in our society: men are demonised and maligned..."

You are quite correct about the unreliability of the BBC. The BBC is a propaganda clearing house for the lunatic fringe. That is especially true when it comes to the BBC's chronic misandry and androphobia.


message 25: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant John - I will have a look at those links but please just one little clarification : domestic homicide. Are there any stats you can point to that show women killing as many male partners as men kill female partners? In any given year in any country it's always 95% plus men killing women, right ?


message 26: by John (new)

John Davis Mahera wrote: "Just out of curiosity: Have you ever looked into any prominent incel forum (be it on 4chan or Reddit)? The fact that incels "deserve compassion and assistance" don't even come here."

Just out of curiosity: Have you ever looked into any prominent feminist and lesbian forums?


message 27: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant oh by the way John, here's something you might like




message 28: by John (new)

John Davis Paul wrote: "oh by the way John, here's something you might like

"


And here is something you might like.




message 29: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant i knew you'd like that one


message 30: by Liam O'Leary (new)

Liam O'Leary We might not be making great strides of social progress here but this discourse is entertainingly outrageous. I commend John's bravery for making the review and taking on commenters like this was an action film fight sequence.


message 31: by John (last edited Oct 16, 2020 07:46AM) (new)

John Davis Rirtzi wrote: "this would be really hilarious if this type of man wasn't so dangerous."




message 32: by Uncle Monty (last edited Oct 16, 2020 02:45PM) (new)

Uncle Monty John: there is no reasoning with these people - they are demonically possessed. Paul needs a tablespoon of concrete and Selma needs a shower. Maybe next discussion we can delve into the routine mass homicide perpetrated by women via abortion - currently tracking at a 600,000 murders per year on average I believe. If the feminazis won’t discuss it they deserve the white feather of cowardice. Speaking of which, as we could be on the precipice of war soon, how about we galvanise a movement to encourage all feminists to be enlisted for the draft - that way we can truly liberate women and put them on an even keel!


message 33: by John (new)

John Davis Lumpen_Proletariat wrote: "John: there is no reasoning with these people - they are demonically possessed. Paul needs a teaspoon of concrete and Selma needs a shower. Maybe next discussion we can delve into the routine mass ..."

You are spot on.


message 34: by Emily May (new)

Emily May John wrote: "Boadicea wrote: "Like )her namesake, Boadicea can smell a rat from a fair way off. This one has authored 2 books, whose only ratings (5*, naturally) come from... guess who? Ah, the author, of cours..."

John, I fear we will never see eye-to-eye on this, but I confess I am surprised this particular book upset you so. I found the author to be extremely compassionate toward the young men being radicalized, even stating in the later chapters how far-right movements like Incels and MGTOW actually distract us from the very real men's rights issues. To me, she was urging us to take them seriously instead of dismissing them. We may have to agree to disagree there.

I do take issue, however, with the factually inaccurate information you shared about Boudicca. Boudicca's grave and remains have never been found. There is no reason to think she was anything other than the woman everyone knew her to be. You may have been confused by this article in the daily mail about another tombstone inscribed with the name "Bodica" containing male remains. The two are, in fact, unrelated.


message 35: by Jessica (new)

Jessica Man I want to live in this magical, mystical world where us women are on the tippy top of the food chain, and the men are submissive and grovel at our evil little feet. Muahahahahaha!


message 36: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant according to John and his pals you already do, it's strange to me you never noticed it.


message 37: by Jessica (last edited Oct 19, 2020 07:25PM) (new)

Jessica Paul wrote: "according to John and his pals you already do, it's strange to me you never noticed it."

You got me. We all are just pretending to be opressed. All the women are lying about their sexual assault. Every single one. Because, you see, we're not actually people, just one homogeneous mass of spite.


message 38: by John (new)

John Davis Emily May wrote: ".Boudicca's grave and remains have never been found. There is no reason to think she was anything other than the woman everyone knew her to be"

Emily, there is, in fact, not one shred of evidence that Boudica ever existed.

The grave which you claim is "unrelated" is the only evidence of anyone from that time period named Boudica, and the remains in the grave were the remains of a man.

Boudica is a fiction, and the myth illustrate how women use false accusations of rape to incite violence for their political gain. The phony myth of Boudica, and her daughters being raped, was used to justify the Icinii slaughtering hundreds of thousands of innocent people, and, plundering their villages and towns (including Londinium (London)).


message 39: by John (new)

John Davis Jessica wrote: "Paul wrote: "according to John and his pals you already do, it's strange to me you never noticed it."

You got me. We all are just pretending to be opressed. All the women are lying about their sex..."


Women have used false accusations of sexual assault, relentlessly throughout history, for political and personal gain.

No one said all women are lying about all sexual assault. Women lie about sexual assault in about 95% of cases.


message 40: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant But John, you still have not said if you agree that women get KILLED in 95% of all partner murders.


message 41: by John (new)

John Davis Emily May wrote: "John wrote: "Boadicea wrote: "Like )her namesake, Boadicea can smell a rat from a fair way off. This one has authored 2 books, whose only ratings (5*, naturally) come from... guess who? Ah, the aut..."

"Prof. Alice Roberts: Boudicca disappeared from history and entered into national mythology, a martyr to the idea of a free Britain. But while the Celtic rebellion was certainly real can we be absolutely sure that Boudicca played a part in it or even existed? No archaeological evidence of Boudicca herself has been found.

Neil Oliver: Then, in the Spring of 2015, in Gloucestershire, an ancient gravesite was discovered dating to the Roman occupation of Britain. In amongst the human remains was a gravestone and on it was carved the name Bodicacia. Underneath the stone lay a skeleton. Could this finally be evidence of Britain’s great warrior queen? But the bones belonged to a man. And the myth of Boudicca continues to this day."

https://vridar.org/2018/05/07/doing-h...


message 42: by Charlotte (new)

Charlotte And here comes John, proving this entire book to be true 🤣 jfc 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️


message 43: by Emily May (new)

Emily May John wrote: "Emily May wrote: ".Boudicca's grave and remains have never been found. There is no reason to think she was anything other than the woman everyone knew her to be"

Emily, there is, in fact, not one ..."


But that argument doesn't hold much weight, John. We don't have the remains of many Ancient and Medieval figures, and have to rely on eyewitness accounts to believe they ever existed. Alexander the Great's tomb, for example, has never been found, and the tomb believed to be his was later discovered to be someone else. Genghis Khan's remains are lost to history, too. Julius Caesar was (allegedly) cremated, so nothing remains of him either. Are we to dismiss them as fictions, too?

The argument about no one else being named Boudicca doesn't really work either. It has long been assumed that Boudicca was a title (from the Gaelic word for 'victory'), not her actual given name.

Also, you claim this as an example of how "women use false accusations of rape", but the story of Boudicca and her daughters was told by the (male) Roman historian Tacitus whose father-in-law took part in suppressing Boudicca's uprising. It doesn't even fit with your argument.


message 44: by John (last edited Oct 23, 2020 09:08PM) (new)

John Davis Emily May wrote: "John wrote: "Emily May wrote: ".Boudicca's grave and remains have never been found. There is no reason to think she was anything other than the woman everyone knew her to be"

Emily, there is, in f..."


Tacitus wrote about her over 100 years after the events. He never said it was real, it was simply the myth that people had created by then.

You can hold on to your fantasies ... I'll stick with the educated and intelligent scientists.


message 45: by John (new)

John Davis


message 46: by Emily May (new)

Emily May John wrote: "Emily May wrote: "John wrote: "Emily May wrote: ".Boudicca's grave and remains have never been found. There is no reason to think she was anything other than the woman everyone knew her to be"

Emi..."


So you admit that it is men who make up stories about rape, not women? :)

The exact year(s) Tacitus wrote The Annals is also unknown, but believed to be about 50 years after the events, with his source being his father-in-law who was very much present for Boudicca's uprising.


message 47: by Daniel (new)

Daniel Thank you John. The internet is filled with man-hate propaganda. Turning a blind eye to that is a favorite past time for the Author.


message 48: by Annvor (new)

Annvor John, you're not only delusional and hysteric, your arguments are silly and show a total lack of logic. This proves your complete ignorance and incompetence when it comes to feminism, gender based violence and online harassment.

Alek Minassian did not have a "car accident", he intentionally drove a rented van into a crowd of people in order to hit as many women as possible. His testimony is online by the way, so you saying it was only a "car accident" points out how little you actually know about the matter. I strongly encourage you to do some further reading before making online statements which are obviously not based on facts.


message 49: by Andrew (new)

Andrew Anyetei Good review as it pretty much sums it up.


message 50: by lethe (new)

lethe Paul wrote: "But John, you still have not said if you agree that women get KILLED in 95% of all partner murders."

I notice that four months on, he still has not answered this question you repeatedly asked. Not surprised he keeps ignoring this very inconvenient truth, as it messes with the agenda he's pushing.


« previous 1 3 4
back to top