Jennifer’s review of Nobody Told Me Dragons use Libraries (Nobody Told Me That...) > Likes and Comments

8 likes · 
Comments Showing 1-2 of 2 (2 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by RB (new)

RB I'm not skilled enough to be certain AI was used to write something. I can only guess. But I think that if an author or consortium of authors (?) want readers to believe they aren't using Ai, they need to state clearly that "AI wasn't used to research, design, develop, write, or create any part of this book." I haven't seen an author claim that yet, which i find suspect.


message 2: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer RB wrote: "I'm not skilled enough to be certain AI was used to write something. I can only guess. But I think that if an author or consortium of authors (?) want readers to believe they aren't using Ai, they ..."

I agree that a statement would be beneficial, but unfortunately, I have come across authors who did state their work was not generated by AI only to read it, see the typical signs of it, and run it through two AI-checkers with 100% AI-generated results. Also, your all-inclusive statement would prevent authors who used MS Word's spelling and grammar check from using it, since that is AI. Also, when I use Google to search for something, if I click on any links it offers in its own answer, I technically have used Google AI to do research--even if I did not read the text associated with AI's answer. Unfortunately, I haven't found a way to turn the AI answer off, and it is always at the top.

On the books I write, I do use AI to generate cover images and logos, and then I usually have to spend hours not only selecting the image but also editing it afterward. I would love to hire a real artist/photographer to do my covers, but I can't afford that at this time. At the same time, I openly declare that I use AI to create my covers on my copyright page as well as which generator I used.

I suspect that most of the authors who try to hide the fact that they use AI, especially ones who cut and paste without checking it, are not very well-trained authors and may read too much AI-generated text themselves. If they read what was being produced, they would soon see it's not good at all.

I think the best path is for Amazon to continue monitoring AI-generated work and restrict self-publishing authors as bad ratings come in. I also think traditional publishing companies should commit to keeping AI out of their work--especially by getting rid of real editors and putting people who rely solely on computer editing software to do their job. Computer editing software and screen software is not always going to pick AI correctly, but trained editors can.


back to top