#45 Hero or anti-hero > Likes and Comments
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Natalie
(new)
Nov 09, 2026 05:51AM
Do you enjoy cheering on a hero or like better an anti-hero in the books you read?
reply
|
flag
It really depends on their personalities. If the hero is an annoying character, I prefer the anti-hero if he's not a horrible person.
I think complex characters are usually more interesting than a plain hero or villain. At the same time, usually I enjoy empathic rapport with a protagonist, therefore disgusting characters with no redeeming qualities can negatively affect my reading
Even a pure hero or pure villain can be complex. I think of a Jean-Luc Picard, a pure hero painted with a broad brush, many aspects to his personality. Maybe it's just Patrick Stewart's acting that projects a complex character, but the writing was really good too.But as Stan Lee always tried to portray, heroes and villains are rarely pure. We all have flaws & less savory aspects to our character, and building on those can create real drama in a story. It can be carried to extreme, even to the extent of parody, and then it can become less interesting. I found that in Shadow Over Mars, Warbound & the most recent season of Reacher.
I never cheer on either one. I just read the story. It has never occurred to me to cheer. I tend to find the Anti-hero a more complex character, but that is not always the case. I usually end up asking this question when this type of question is brought up: "If someone does the right thing for the wrong reason, does that count?" The reason I ask is due to the visceral reaction to Thomas Covenant the character. I was shocked how bad so many reacted to the character and hated the entire series when I thought the series was excellent.Fort those of you that do not know what I am talking about, here is a link.
https://www.goodreads.com/series/4952...
I read that series many years ago when it was recently published. It's an intense series with a hero who did the best that he could in such difficult circumstances.
A question: Who are the great well-written female anti-heroes in books or movies? The ones I think of are almost always male. My friends and I were trying to come up with some, but really couldn't. Maybe Lady from Glen Cook's Black Company novels? Anyone have recommendations?
E. wrote: "A question: Who are the great well-written female anti-heroes in books or movies? ...."There's a list of anti-heroines here, though I don't agree with all:
https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/4...
I really enjoyed Servalan in Blake's 7, played by Jacqueline Pearce.
And Missy in Doctor Who (especially as played by Michelle Gomez).
Maybe Wednesday Addams and Catwoman and Harley Quinn.
E. wrote: "A question: Who are the great well-written female anti-heroes in books or movies? The ones I think of are almost always male. My friends and I were trying to come up with some, but really couldn't...."Becky Sharp from Vanity Fair by William Makepeace Thackeray
I wish I'd thought of Catwoman and Wednesday. They're awesome.The list is interesting. It's been a hundred years since I read Ursula K Leguin's Earthsea series and I don't remember the character in #2 that qualifies. I've been thinking of revisiting the series for a while now.
I get Mortal Engines. Hester Shaw is a great character.


