Aleesha’s review of Black Willow Witch > Likes and Comments
2 likes · Like
Aleesha, I enjoyed your insightful analysis. Sounds like you were feeling in a benevolent mood by giving this book 4 stars. From your description it sounds more like 2 or 2.5 stars at most?
Kate wrote: "Aleesha, I enjoyed your insightful analysis. Sounds like you were feeling in a benevolent mood by giving this book 4 stars. From your description it sounds more like 2 or 2.5 stars at most?"
I rated it based on the enjoyment I had while reading - it's definitely not top tier writing. But if you go in knowing that? It's an enjoyable read. Emberlyn is what REALLY earned this book it's rating. She's one of the only FMCs I've come across in recent memory that's not annoying or idiotic in the extreme. She felt very mature and level-headed, even when silly things were going on around her. And she knew how to communicate! I just... enjoy the way Wrights writes women.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Kate
(new)
Nov 14, 2026 06:32PM
Aleesha, I enjoyed your insightful analysis. Sounds like you were feeling in a benevolent mood by giving this book 4 stars. From your description it sounds more like 2 or 2.5 stars at most?
reply
|
flag
Kate wrote: "Aleesha, I enjoyed your insightful analysis. Sounds like you were feeling in a benevolent mood by giving this book 4 stars. From your description it sounds more like 2 or 2.5 stars at most?"I rated it based on the enjoyment I had while reading - it's definitely not top tier writing. But if you go in knowing that? It's an enjoyable read. Emberlyn is what REALLY earned this book it's rating. She's one of the only FMCs I've come across in recent memory that's not annoying or idiotic in the extreme. She felt very mature and level-headed, even when silly things were going on around her. And she knew how to communicate! I just... enjoy the way Wrights writes women.
