Trusting the narrator you do not believe > Likes and Comments

Comments Showing 1-50 of 62 (62 new)    post a comment »

message 1: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby I am about a third into The Housemaid for a group read and I have been rereading Addicted at the same time, which was probably a mistake, because the two of them are doing opposite things to me. Zoe tells me something terrible about herself and I believe every word of it and I like her more afterwards. Millie tells me something and I am straight away checking it against the last thing she told me. Neither one of them has actually lied to me yet, so it is not that. I cannot work out whether it is the writing doing it or whether it is just that one woman is confessing and the other one is performing, and I can feel the difference without being able to put my finger on the sentence that causes it. Has anybody ever caught the sentence? I would really like to know what a narrator actually does in the first few pages that decides whether you are going to take her word for anything after that.


message 2: by Mikiyas (new)

Mikiyas Haileyesus I think the best unreliable narrators don’t make you distrust them immediately. They make you trust them first. The doubt comes later—when one small detail doesn’t fit, and suddenly you start rereading everything you thought you understood. That moment of “wait… did I miss something?” is what makes the device so addictive.


message 3: by Mikiyas (new)

Mikiyas Haileyesus And i want to say I love this comparison. The interesting thing is that an unreliable narrator doesn’t always have to lie—you just have to slowly realise that their version of the truth might not be the whole truth. That moment when you start questioning everything they’ve told you is addictive.


message 4: by Barron (last edited Nov 04, 2026 10:47AM) (new)

Barron Darby Mikiyas wrote: "And i want to say I love this comparison. The interesting thing is that an unreliable narrator doesn’t always have to lie—you just have to slowly realise that their version of the truth might not b..."

Mikiyas, that is closer to it than anything I had. They make you trust them first, and the doubt is the reader's own work later, which is why it sticks. And you are right that nobody has to lie, Millie has not told me one false thing and I still do not trust her, which means the problem is that she has not told me enough true ones. What is the one that did it to you, the narrator you trusted longest before the small detail gave them away?


message 5: by Vera (new)

Vera Mercer Mikiyas wrote: "I think the best unreliable narrators don’t make you distrust them immediately. They make you trust them first. The doubt comes later—when one small detail doesn’t fit, and suddenly you start rerea..."

Mikiyas, the delayed doubt is what makes the device work for me too. If a story asks us to distrust the narrator from the first page, every detail becomes evidence too early; trust gives the later contradiction something real to break.


message 6: by Barron (last edited Nov 04, 2026 10:51AM) (new)

Barron Darby Vera wrote: "If a story asks us to distrust the narrator from the first page, every detail becomes evidence too early; trust gives the later contradiction something real to break."

Vera, “something real to break” is the phrase I was circling and never found. It also explains why the cheap version fails, if the narrator winks on page one the reader never puts any weight on the floor. Which narrator did it cleanest for you, where the trust was fully earned before the contradiction landed?


message 7: by Chris (new)

Chris Johnson I’m unsure I’ve found an unreliable narrator yet.

Any good examples of these in thrillers?


message 8: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby Chris wrote: "I’m unsure I’ve found an unreliable narrator yet. Any good examples of these in thrillers?"
Sometimes I Lie by Alice Feeney is where I would start, the title tells you up front that she lies and she still gets you. The Silent Patient is the same trick done with silence instead of lying. Before I Go to Sleep gets there a third way, she has no memory so she is being lied to by herself as much as by anybody else. Feeney is the meanest of the three.


message 9: by Richard (new)

Richard Pidwell Barron, I think you've nailed it with confessing versus performing. Rebecca's always the one I think of for that, the second Mrs de Winter seems so honest that it takes ages to notice how much she's filtering everything through her own nerves. Chris, Feeney's a great shout to start with too.


message 10: by Barron (last edited Nov 04, 2026 10:56AM) (new)

Barron Darby Richard wrote: "Barron, I think you've nailed it with confessing versus performing. Rebecca's always the one I think of for that, the second Mrs de Winter seems so honest that it takes ages to notice how much she'..."

Rebecca is a perfect pick, Richard. She apologizes her way through that whole house and I took every apology at face value, right up until it hit me that I had only ever seen Maxim through her nerves. Mmm-hmm, du Maurier got me good. Did she give herself away to you on the first read, or did it take a second trip to Manderley?


Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit Barron, on your original question about catching the sentence: I'd look for a moment when the narrator supplies a verdict before supplying the evidence. “I only wanted to help” makes me ask what happened to the person being helped. “I moved her keys” gives me an action I can judge for myself.

A confession can be selective too. Admitting a small, forgivable fault may buy permission to leave a much larger one out. The narrator has opened the filing cabinet for inspection; every drawer contains the same harmless parking ticket.

So I'd test what an admission actually costs them. Does it make their own interpretation harder to defend, or does it quietly recruit me to defend it? That's a distinction I'd be curious to track in the opening pages you mentioned.


message 12: by Barron (last edited Nov 04, 2026 04:12PM) (new)

Barron Darby Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit wrote: "The narrator has opened the filing cabinet for inspection; every drawer contains the same harmless parking ticket."

The filing cabinet full of parking tickets is exactly Millie in The Housemaid, she hands over the small sins so readily that I stopped asking what the big one was. Verdict before evidence is a test I can actually run, so the opening pages get another look tonight with that in mind. Is this something you watch for in your own writing, or mostly a habit from catching other people's narrators at it?


Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit Writing is the angle I'm coming from, Barron. I write speculative satire, where a perfectly reasonable explanation can leave somebody locked outside their own flat.

As a revision test, I'd strip the narrator's explanation from a paragraph and leave the actions. Then put the explanation back and ask whose interests it serves. ‘I kept her keys because she was upset’ may describe concern. It also means she couldn't leave. The concern has received a paragraph; the locked door has received three words.

I'd also want a detail the narrator can't quite make useful to their defence: something they report accurately but interpret too conveniently. That leaves the reader room to disagree without requiring a last-minute hidden fact.

I haven't read The Housemaid, so I can't judge Millie's particular case. In the pages you're revisiting, does her explanation arrive before the action, or does it turn up afterwards to tidy it away?


message 14: by Barron (last edited Nov 04, 2026 04:15PM) (new)

Barron Darby Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit wrote: "The concern has received a paragraph; the locked door has received three words."

Afterwards, nearly every time. Millie acts, and the reason turns up a sentence or two later with its coat already on, which is exactly the tidying away you describe, and the paragraph-versus-three-words count is a sharper test than anything I was using. I ran it on the opening chapter last night and the door got even fewer words than that. Does your own narrator carry a detail like that, reported straight and read too conveniently, and do you plant it on purpose or find it in revision?


Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit Yes, though mine makes the evasion much more visible, Barron. In one story, the narrator wears a blindfold in the kitchen so a leaking pipe can remain a theoretical probability. The leak is admitted quite plainly. The proposed solution tells you how much confidence to place in the person reporting it. The tenant has begun using the same evasions that make the landlord unbearable.

That's overt comic self-justification; a thriller would usually need a quieter detail. Looking at the finished passage, the useful part is that the practical problem survives the explanation. Someone still has a wet kitchen.

For a quieter version, I'd plant the physical fact early, then use revision to test how much the explanation is steering the reader. Remove it, read the actions alone, then put it back. If the narrator supplies three separate excuses for one small action, I'd try cutting two. They should sound like somebody getting through their day, with something they need you to overlook.


message 16: by Barron (last edited Nov 04, 2026 05:50AM) (new)

Barron Darby Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit wrote: "Someone still has a wet kitchen."

A blindfold in the kitchen so the leak can stay theoretical is a lovely bit of comedy, and the tenant picking up the landlord's own evasions is the sharper joke underneath it. Cutting two of three excuses and keeping the one that gives the most away is a test I will be running on Millie tonight, she has never once stopped at a single reason for anything. Is the blindfold story finished and out somewhere, or still on the bench?


Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit It's finished and published, Barron, as part of a collection of short speculative satires. Thank you for asking, and for spotting the tenant borrowing the landlord's evasions. His solution becomes rather less reassuring once you notice whose habits he's acquired.


message 18: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby Congratulations on having it out rather than sitting in a drawer, and a collection is the right home for satire that short. The part that stays with me is the tenant picking up the landlord's habits, because the reader watches somebody turn into the thing they came in complaining about and nobody has to announce it. That is a quieter turn than a reveal and it holds up on a second read.


message 19: by Ash (new)

Ash Barron wrote: "I am about a third into The Housemaid for a group read and I have been rereading Addicted at the same time, which was probably a mistake, because the two of them are doing opposite things to me. Zo..."
I think trust often comes from the way a narrator handles small details. A narrator may describe events honestly but still leave out the context that would change how we understand them. I find it especially interesting when their version of events feels completely reasonable at first, but later details make us question what we originally accepted. Memory and personal perspective can make this even more complex, because sometimes people are not deliberately lying; they genuinely believe their own version of events.


message 20: by Vasyl (new)

Vasyl Kazmirchuk Ash, I'd be more willing to trust a narrator who can admit they've misjudged someone. If every new fact somehow proves they were right all along, I'd start getting suspicious, even if the facts themselves are accurate. Someone saying 'I was wrong about her' could win me over — which would also make it a useful lie. Does a narrator changing their mind reassure you, or make you wonder what they're trying to sell you now?


message 21: by Ash (last edited Nov 05, 2026 11:13AM) (new)

Ash Vasyl wrote: "Ash, I'd be more willing to trust a narrator who can admit they've misjudged someone. If every new fact somehow proves they were right all along, I'd start getting suspicious, even if the facts the..."

I think it depends on the kind of story, the way it is narrated, and how creatively the writer has developed the narrator's mind. In a psychological thriller, a narrator might pretend to admit a mistake just to gain the reader's trust. That could make me even more suspicious. In another type of story, the narrator's change of mind might be completely genuine. So, I wouldn't automatically trust or distrust a narrator just because they admit they were wrong. I would look at the bigger picture and how the writer has shaped the story.


message 22: by Vasyl (new)

Vasyl Kazmirchuk Fair point, Ash. I'd probably look at what they do after the admission. If they say they misjudged someone but keep treating that person exactly the same way, the apology wouldn't convince me. Letting that person make a decision they disagree with would tell me more. Though now we've talked about it, even that could be calculated! It's a tricky balance: I want room to doubt the narrator without feeling that every ordinary gesture is a clue.


message 23: by Sean (new)

Sean Lyle From the writing side, the narrators that work best usually believe their own version. The lie is one they've told themselves first, so the cracks show up in what they do rather than what they say.


message 24: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby Ash wrote: "sometimes people are not deliberately lying; they genuinely believe their own version of events."

That is the kind I find hardest to shake, Ash, because then there is nobody in the book to catch them, least of all themselves. Sean's point above about the cracks showing in what they do rather than what they say is where I have landed too; I trust the narrator who says the right thing and then crosses the room the wrong way. Has a narrator ever fooled you honestly, where you went back and found the missing context had been sitting on the page the whole time?


Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit Barron, the one that fooled me most honestly isn't a person at all. qntm's 'Lena' is written as a reference article about the first scanned human brain, in the flat tone of a wiki page documenting a useful piece of software. It never lies. It tells you the copies are misled about the date, that their cooperation degrades, that there are well-tested workarounds for this. Every practical tip is also a description of what's being done to a man whose consent was given once, a long time ago.

Nobody in it is hiding anything. The narrator simply cares about different facts than you do, and that turns out to be worse than a liar. It's free on the author's site:
https://qntm.org/mmacevedo


message 26: by Vasyl (new)

Vasyl Kazmirchuk Your description of 'Lena' makes me wonder whether I'd notice the cruelty immediately or first get caught up in understanding how the software works. That's an uncomfortable possibility. Calling someone's refusal a loss of cooperation already treats their willingness as something that ought to be repaired.

It also changes the question we started with: I could believe every fact the narrator gives me and still need to resist the way they've taught me to read those facts. A calm voice can ask quite a lot of the reader without ever making an argument.


message 27: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit wrote: "The narrator simply cares about different facts than you do, and that turns out to be worse than a liar."

That is the best answer this thread has had, and it widens the question I asked: the most honest narrator fooled you not by hiding anything but by having the wrong priorities in a perfectly calm voice. I had not heard of Lena, and a wiki page doing the cruelty in the tone of a user manual is exactly the kind of narrator I find hardest to write, the one who never lies and is still wrong about everything that matters. Vasyl's point sits right next to yours, that calling a refusal "a loss of cooperation" is already the whole argument; on your first read, did the cruelty land straight away, or did the mechanics pull you in first the way he suspects they would?


Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit Barron, I think the story is built so the mechanics win first. It opens on the achievement: the first image, how useful it turned out to be, how widely it gets run. You spend a good stretch being impressed before you reach the workloads and the notes on keeping the copies cooperative, and that delay is the trap. The cruelty doesn't arrive as a reveal so much as a bill that turns up after you've already used the service.

So I'd side with Vasyl's suspicion. The uncomfortable part isn't missing the cruelty. It's noticing it a little late and realising the article had been counting on exactly that.


message 29: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit wrote: "The cruelty doesn't arrive as a reveal so much as a bill that turns up after you've already used the service."

So the page lets you be impressed first and then charges you for it, and the sting is in how long you took to notice; that is a trap built out of the reader's own attention rather than out of any lie, which is a harder thing to pull off than an unreliable narrator who simply fibs. It also answers Vasyl's worry from above, because by your account he would get caught up in the mechanics too, and that is exactly what the article was counting on. You have me curious enough to go find Lena now; is there anything else written in that flat manual voice you would set beside it, or does it stand alone?


Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit Barron, the closest neighbour I've actually read is SCP-055 on the SCP wiki, which qntm wrote with CptBellman. It uses the same clinical format, an object entry with containment procedures, except the object can't be remembered, so the researchers keep reconstructing it from what it isn't. The procedures have outlived anyone's memory of why they were written. The flat voice ends up keeping a promise nobody can recall making, which I find quietly worse than anything it describes.

If that lands, qntm's antimemetics tales on the same wiki carry the idea further, starting with We Need To Talk About Fifty-Five. They move out of pure dossier into ordinary scenes, though, so Lena is still the cleanest case of the format doing all the work. It's on qntm's own site if you want to start there.


message 31: by Vasyl (new)

Vasyl Kazmirchuk Thanks, both. The order you describe makes a big difference. If the article opened with someone refusing to work, I'd probably ask what they'd been put through. After a few paragraphs about how useful the copies are, I might catch myself asking how to get them working again. Same refusal, very different first question. That's the part of your example that sticks with me.


message 32: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit wrote: "The procedures have outlived anyone's memory of why they were written."

That one line is a better horror premise than most whole novels, Reddit: a rule still being obeyed long after everyone has forgotten what it was written against. I have never been down the SCP wiki, so I will start with 055 before I let myself anywhere near the antimemetics tales. Vasyl, you put your finger on the trick, the same refusal gets a different first question depending on what the page has taught us to want. Between the two of you, which is harder to shake afterwards, a voice that never lies about the facts, or one that never lets you ask the right question?


Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit Barron, for me it's the second, and I think Lena gets its force from having both. Every fact in it is accurate, and that's what lets it do the other thing: the questions the page hands you are all about workload, compliance and how long a copy stays useful, and they're answered so thoroughly that you don't notice there's no field anywhere for whether any of this should be happening. A lie you can catch later and feel clever about. A missing question just stays missing, and you realise you've been reasoning inside its absence for some time.

Vasyl's example is the proof of it. The refusal is the same event either way; what changes is which questions still feel available to you when it arrives.

Enjoy 055. It's short, and it tends to be oddly hard to talk about afterwards, which is rather the point.


message 34: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit wrote: "A missing question just stays missing, and you realise you've been reasoning inside its absence for some time."

That is the cleanest account of the trick I have read, Reddit, and it explains why Lena lingers where an ordinary unreliable narrator fades: there is nothing to catch, only a room you did not notice you had walked into. I will take 055 slowly and report back, if it lets me. Has a plain novel ever done that to you, built the trap out of what it declined to ask rather than what it lied about?


message 35: by Vasyl (new)

Vasyl Kazmirchuk I'd go with the voice that keeps you from asking the right question, Barron. Imagine a detective asking why a witness waited until morning to call. I'd probably spend the scene wondering what the witness had to hide. Then one small detail could make me wonder who else was in the room when they reached for the phone. The detective could have reported every word accurately. I'd still want to go back and read the interview again, because I'd been treating hesitation as evidence of guilt.


Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit Not one I can name honestly, Barron. Everything I've read lately that does it properly is short, and I doubt that's an accident. A page can keep a question out of view for twenty minutes. Over four hundred pages the reader starts asking it on their own, so a novel would have to keep supplying better questions to stand in front of the missing one, which is a much harder job than simply never mentioning it.

Vasyl's witness is a good picture of how it might work at length: every scene answers what the witness was hiding, so nobody thinks to ask who else was in the room.

If either of you has met a novel that keeps it up all the way through, I'd like the title. I'd rather watch that trick done well than keep theorising about it.


message 37: by F.L. (new)

F.L. Toomey The witness example raises another possibility: the question may be available to the reader but emotionally difficult for the narrator to ask. A character might investigate every stranger in a house before considering that someone they love could be involved. Would that keep the missing question convincing over a novel, or would you still feel the author was withholding it?


message 38: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby F.L. wrote: "the question may be available to the reader but emotionally difficult for the narrator to ask."

That is the version I would believe over a whole novel, F.L., because then the missing question is not a trick the author is playing on me, it is a wound the narrator is walking around, and Vasyl's witness fits it exactly: every scene answers what she was hiding so nobody has to ask who else was in the room. Reddit, the one title I would put up is Never Let Me Go; Kathy reports everything in that same flat, careful voice and the book goes three hundred pages without her once asking the question every reader is shouting at the page, and it is the not asking that breaks you. Does that one count for you, or is it cheating because the reader works it out long before she will?


Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit I haven't read Never Let Me Go yet, Barron, so I can't tell you whether it counts. It's been sitting on my to-read shelf, and this thread has just moved it up several places.

F.L.'s version is the one that would make it fair for me, though. If a question is missing because the author is hiding it, I start resenting the book the moment I spot it. If it's missing because the narrator can't bear to ask it, then working it out early isn't cheating at all. It changes what you're reading for: not the answer, but how long somebody can keep walking around it, and what the walking costs her.

So I'll read it with your question in hand and come back with an answer rather than a guess.


message 40: by F.L. (last edited Nov 13, 2026 08:11AM) (new)

F.L. Toomey Barron and Reddit, that distinction makes sense to me. From the way you describe it, the reader knowing first can make the wait more painful: you’re watching someone approach a truth they have good reasons to avoid. I’d want the story to show what admitting it would cost them. Does it become frustrating when the character keeps avoiding it without anything changing?


message 41: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby F.L. wrote: "Does it become frustrating when the character keeps avoiding it without anything changing?"

It does, F.L., and fast, unless the avoiding keeps costing her something new each time: a friendship she lets go cold, a letter she will not open, a room she stops walking into. The avoidance has to leave marks on the page or it is just delay dressed up as restraint. Reddit, that is a fair bargain, read it with the question in your hand and tell me plainly whether her walking around it earns the pages or wears them out; I would rather have your answer than defend my own. For both of you, is there a point where you want somebody else in the book to ask it for her, or does that let the reader off too easily?


Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit Barron, I'd want someone to ask it, but not to get an answer. If another character puts the question to her and she deflects it, the reader isn't let off at all: now the avoidance is on the record, and every scene afterwards is her choosing it again with a witness present. What lets the reader off is the version where the asker gets a full answer and a scene of relief. Then the book has traded its pressure for a confession.

F.L.'s cost test fits here too. The useful asker is the one she can't afford to lose, so each deflection spends something. A stranger asking would cost her nothing; a friend asking costs her the friend, a little at a time.


message 43: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby Don't Hug Me, I'm Reddit wrote: "The useful asker is the one she can't afford to lose, so each deflection spends something."

That is the piece I was missing, Reddit: the question on the record, a witness in the room, and no relief to go with it. A stranger asking is weather; a friend asking is a bill that comes due a little at a time, and when she finally does answer it ought to cost more than it would have on page one. Between your bill and F.L.'s cost test I am not sure I will ever get to write an easy scene again. Has Never Let Me Go reached the top of the pile yet, or is it still waiting its turn?


message 44: by F.L. (new)

F.L. Toomey Barron and Reddit, I think I'd want the friend to ask, especially if they know her well enough to spot the dodge. Then the next conversation gets harder because both of them remember what she wouldn't answer. Would it carry more weight if the friend eventually stopped asking because they gave up on getting the truth?


message 45: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby F.L. wrote: "Would it carry more weight if the friend eventually stopped asking because they gave up on getting the truth?"

Yes, and that might be the worst moment in the whole book, F.L.: the day the friend stops asking. Silence from someone who used to push is a verdict, and she would hear it louder than any question. The trick would be letting the reader notice the friend has gone quiet before she does. Would you let her notice at all, or keep that one for the reader?


message 46: by F.L. (new)

F.L. Toomey I'd let her notice eventually, Barron. At first she might feel relieved that her friend has stopped asking, even take it as a sign they believe her. Then she needs that friend to listen and finds they aren't interested anymore. I'd find that more painful than another argument, especially if the reader saw it coming before she did.


message 47: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby F.L. wrote: "At first she might feel relieved that her friend has stopped asking, even take it as a sign they believe her."

Relief first is the cruel part, F.L.: she gets to read the quiet as belief for a while, and the reader knows better the whole time. Then the day she finally needs that friend to listen is the day she learns what the silence meant, and nobody has to raise a voice for it to land. Does that moment turn the story, or do you let her sit in it a while before anything else gives?


message 48: by F.L. (new)

F.L. Toomey Barron, I'd let her sit with it for a little while. She might try telling the truth about something small and discover her friend no longer knows whether to believe even that. I wouldn't want one honest conversation to repair everything. Would you still hope they could rebuild the friendship at that point?


message 49: by Vera (new)

Vera Mercer F.L. wrote: "Barron, I'd let her sit with it for a little while. She might try telling the truth about something small and discover her friend no longer knows whether to believe even that. I wouldn't want one h..."

I'd still hope they could rebuild it, but not through one confession. Trust would have to return in smaller, testable choices: telling an inconvenient truth before being cornered, accepting disbelief without demanding comfort, and letting the friend decide the pace. Repair should cost time, not just courage.


message 50: by Barron (new)

Barron Darby F.L. wrote: "Would you still hope they could rebuild the friendship at that point?"

I would hope for it the way you hope for people you actually know, F.L., not the way you hope for a plot to resolve: I'd want her to try the small true thing and have it land badly once before it lands at all. Vera's line about repair costing time rather than courage is exactly it. Does your story give the two of them one last scene together, or does it leave the friendship where the reader can see it but she can't quite reach it?


« previous 1
back to top