Annika ’s review of The Sweetest Fiend (Played by the Piper, #1) > Likes and Comments

30 likes · 
Comments Showing 1-20 of 20 (20 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by tiff (new)

tiff Enjoy gorgeous 🫶


message 2: by Kate (new)

Kate McMurry Annika, wow! You make so many outstanding points I'm in awe at your analysis. What a ridiculous FMC and what a pointless resolution of the main external conflict. And this is a prime example of poorly done enemies to lovers in which the only conflict the author allows is for the FMC to be a jerk. Ugh. Thanks for the heads up to avoid this story.


message 3: by Jan (new)

Jan Oh dear. This sounds pretty bad. Cliche trope city!


message 4: by Annika (new)

Annika Kate, thank you so much. I wanted to love this, but I couldn’t do it.


message 5: by Annika (new)

Annika Jan yes! Cliche City Galore


message 6: by Karina (new)

Karina Yeah, this book is basically what non-Romantasy readers think Romantasy is LMAO. And I didn’t realize until after finishing it that this was marketed as a slow-burn??😭 They really will label anything a slow-burn these days!


message 7: by Annika (new)

Annika Karina, the worst part is the premise is so good! It could have been really dark.


Laura Jane ♡ (semi ia) fair review love!! this was deffo no a slow burn, which was such a disappointment. i enjoyed the start of this one but it took a nose dive quickly and i agree with most of your points in this!! i feel like so many romantasy books fall into this cringe tropification these days and it is such a shame cause when romantasy is done well, it is amazing!!!


message 9: by tiff (new)

tiff Fair review! Hope the next is better 🧡


message 10: by Liana (new)

Liana Gold Totally fair!


message 11: by gabriela (new)

gabriela lima Sounds terrible, what a bummer!


message 12: by Sarah Mac (new)

Sarah Mac It drives me nuts that we’re not allowed to dislike MMC/heroes anymore. Stop spoon-feeding me, authors! I CAN USE MY OWN BRAIN, THX. 🙄 But it goes hand in hand with your other gripe about the lack of genuine slow burn. Just because a couple is destined to get together (because Romance Novel) doesn’t mean a slow burn is feeling the love instantly but not acting on it. FFS, please start letting your characters breathe & develop feelings that start out negative & grow into neutral, then positive! It’s called an emotional arc, authors. Learn to use it.


message 13: by Annika (new)

Annika Sarah a 1000 % all you said. Let the characters simmer, let us think for a minute, it’s the fun part.


message 14: by Anna (new)

Anna You perfectly articulated your reasons for not liking the book Annika ❤️


message 15: by Annika (new)

Annika Laura Jane, we kind of deserve better Romantasy’s. The tropes are ruining all the fun. Somehow if they are all alike, they think they will hit Booktok and sell. But I miss a really good one.


message 16: by Snafuzled (new)

Snafuzled This type of FMC makes me insane! Thank you for the heads up. Taking this off my TBR list. Feathers so Vicious really was a masterclass on writing the perfect despicable hero!


message 17: by Annika (new)

Annika Snafuzled. No one is worse than Malyr!! 😂 and the character growth was so good, and it took time.


Heather (semi-hiatus) I’ve seen so many good things about this in book groups, but given your review— I would NOT like this one either! Thanks for the heads up, Annika, before I wasted my time on it. 🫶


Heather (semi-hiatus) Annika, I see that you mention Malyr in your review, have you read Liv Zander’s first duet, The Pale Court? You’d probably like Enosh too if you haven’t. 🩷


message 20: by Sarah Mac (new)

Sarah Mac @Annika - We as readers definitely deserve better romantasies. (And better CR, but that’s a gripe we’ve covered before. 🙈) It’s so frustrating how social media & the trope factory have ruined all the fun.


back to top