Donna’s Comments (group member since Oct 16, 2008)

Donna’s comments from the Fans of Twilight group.

I haven't seen the movie yet but I heard very mixed reviews from my friends - everything from it was great to it was corney. Did you guys like it?

I liked Twilight the best, but I couldn't put down any of them. I wasn't crazy about Jacob's point of view in Breaking Dawn. It was fun to hear his voice and see his perspective but I didn't think it really added to the story at all.

I wish I could be a vampire and be totally beautiful and graceful and smart and perfect. I'm still stuck in the clumsy, un-athletic, Bella-as-a-human stage.

Anyone know a Vampire who can turn me?

I loved them both and felt as if I were being torn in two. I liked Jacob a little better because he was real and Edward was too perfect, he didn't seem real or, well, for lack of a better word, human. I think characters are more real and likeable if they have the occasional flaw. But I loved how honorable Edward was. He would have made a great knight.

I liked the first one the best. The third one was painful and emotional and I felt as if my heart were being ripped in two. but I was satisified with book 4, even though I'd hate it if she didn't end up with Jacob.
Donna