4.09 avg rating — 515,031 ratings

"The movie had none of the book's essence."

4.08 avg rating — 68,670 ratings

"The book is so much better!"

4.15 avg rating — 1,623,268 ratings

"The movie paled in comparison."

4.17 avg rating — 2,480,981 ratings

"The movie was good, the book was amazing."

3.85 avg rating — 735,793 ratings

4.04 avg rating — 253,153 ratings

"Read the book."

3.81 avg rating — 1,026,779 ratings

really liked it 4.00 avg rating — 1,863,435 ratings

3.93 avg rating — 784,124 ratings

3.63 avg rating — 116,487 ratings

"The book was so hilarious!"

4.20 avg rating — 847,199 ratings

3.72 avg rating — 107,408 ratings

"The movie was so awful. Why would two such talented actors agree to appear in it? A plague on both your houses!"

4.21 avg rating — 302,873 ratings

3.97 avg rating — 1,292,623 ratings

"The book was perfect, don't bother with the movie. Really."

4.30 avg rating — 324,415 ratings

3.94 avg rating — 550,268 ratings

"Three words: John Leguizamo's accent. :("

4.28 avg rating — 328,409 ratings

"So much better than the movie. One of my favorite novels."

4.04 avg rating — 212,111 ratings

"Heidi wasn't blonde!"

3.71 avg rating — 167,163 ratings

"The movie is fluffy and insubstantial."

3.81 avg rating — 101,443 ratings

3.65 avg rating — 1,849,984 ratings

"The only redeeming quality: Javier Bardem. Too bad the real Felipe resembles the guy who played Richard From Texas."

4.01 avg rating — 261,641 ratings

"Hardly any Asian actors(?!). There needs to be a remake."

4.06 avg rating — 593,351 ratings

3.65 avg rating — 64,629 ratings

4.30 avg rating — 516,818 ratings

"Choose the book."

3.83 avg rating — 1,204,996 ratings

3.99 avg rating — 320,335 ratings

"Ugh, time for a movie remake!"

3.61 avg rating — 101,378 ratings

4.19 avg rating — 14,966 ratings

4.35 avg rating — 371,327 ratings