4.03 avg rating — 118,558 ratings

3.95 avg rating — 63,285 ratings

4.11 avg rating — 102,757 ratings

3.68 avg rating — 8,915 ratings

4.03 avg rating — 56,031 ratings

3.91 avg rating — 500 ratings

4.10 avg rating — 29,313 ratings

4.03 avg rating — 5,942 ratings

4.40 avg rating — 300,363 ratings

"I wish people wouldn't put compilations on lists like these, so if I have to pick a single Poe story then I'd go with The Cask of Amontillado"

4.16 avg rating — 15,214 ratings