After the Woods by Kim  Savage
YA Debuts 2016
255 books — 1,366 voters

Anything Could Happen by Will WaltonNot After Everything by Michelle  Levy
YA Debuts 2015
439 books — 3,094 voters
Eona by Alison Goodman
Diversity in Young Adult and Middle Grade
1,917 books — 1,217 voters

The Master and Margarita by Mikhail BulgakovSandman Slim by Richard Kadrey
Sympathy for the Devil
331 books — 319 voters