Wither (The Chemical Garden, #1) Wither discussion


323 views
Becoming a movie!

Comments Showing 1-34 of 34 (34 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer I can't wait to see will be in the cast.


C.penn ahem.....Josh Hutcherson(if that's you spell it) as Gabriel.........


April C.penn wrote: "ahem.....Josh Hutcherson(if that's you spell it) as Gabriel........."

I totally agree!!! I always pictured Gabriel with dark hair though...


C.penn April wrote: "C.penn wrote: "ahem.....Josh Hutcherson(if that's you spell it) as Gabriel........."

I totally agree!!! I always pictured Gabriel with dark hair though..."


They can dye it. :)


C.penn I'm thinking Emma Watson could probably pull off Rhine actually. I think Linden's the most difficult to cast.


Davey Kirk Wow I can't believe this is going to be a movie! I can't wait for the third book!


Wren Crystal wrote: "Prospect Park and and Violet House Productions have acquired the screen rights. I'm super excited! Dream cast?"

Send me proof( a link) that it is becoming a movie.


Danielle k seriously are they now making every book into a movie...


C.penn Danielle wrote: "k seriously are they now making every book into a movie..."

it would seem so.


Sabrina I actually want to watch the movie. I like reading the books then watching the movies and start comparing the two.


Sarah that's awsome! after i finished the first book kempt on thinking about what would it look like in movie form! kinda angry that the 3rd book is coming out in the febuary of next year(FEB. 12, 2012)


Bobbi wow how cool! fingers crossed its done well :]


Wren Crystal wrote: "http://www.joblo.com/horror-movies/ne..."

Horror movies? How would this be horror?


Sarah Crystal wrote: "Julia wrote: "Crystal wrote: "http://www.joblo.com/horror-movies/ne..."

Horror movies? How would this be horror?"

It's considere..."


i agree, this is a more sci-fi romance than horror


Wren Horror is monsters and grossness. This is just romance dystopia.


Bdalton This should make a great movie!


message 17: by [deleted user] (new)

Ooooooo, I think Emma Watson would make a great Rhine!


message 18: by Sachi (new) - added it

Sachi MOVIE YOU SAY??!! AIIIIIIEEEEEEEE! *JUMPS UP AND DOWN FRANTICALLY WHILE SCREAMING ON TOP OF LUNGS*


Hannah Oh gosh. I'm partly excited and partly terrified that it will get ruined. Fingers crossed they do as good a jod as the Hunger Games directors.


Ariel C.penn wrote: "ahem.....Josh Hutcherson(if that's you spell it) as Gabriel........."

OMG yes!


Wren I need people to update this conversation when there are movie updates!!!


Susie Danielle wrote: "k seriously are they now making every book into a movie..."

Well its better than some of the crap movie directors are making today ^.^ plus its pretty awesome to see a book become a movie in real life not just in our heads


message 23: by Nia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nia Crystal wrote: "Amanda Seyfried as Rhine
Georgie Henley as Cecily
Alexander Ludwig as Rowan
Imogen Poots as Rose"


Totaly exepet gotta make Georgie Henley redhead like the book and no for amanda seyfried and no for Alexander ludwig...And double yes for Imogen Poots!!!


message 24: by Shav (new) - rated it 5 stars

Shav OMG I'm sooo excited!!


Abbigail Isabel wrote: "Ooooooo, I think Emma Watson would make a great Rhine!"

Totally!!! I love Emma Watson that would be amazing!!!


message 26: by Michaela (last edited Oct 18, 2012 11:53AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Michaela April wrote: "C.penn wrote: "ahem.....Josh Hutcherson(if that's you spell it) as Gabriel........."

I totally agree!!! I always pictured Gabriel with dark hair though..."


His hair is naturally dark. -_-


Abbigail What year is the movie coming out?


message 28: by Nia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nia Abbigail wrote: "Isabel wrote: "Ooooooo, I think Emma Watson would make a great Rhine!"

Totally!!! I love Emma Watson that would be amazing!!!"

yeah...(kinda)But wen it comes to casting and the movie i really want them to be like in the book sooo you would have to make Emma, blonde and with hetero-chromatic eyes(please don't mess up the sides of the eye color).


Kristina I don't know how I feel about this being a movie. I feel like Wither itself isn't "movie material". It seems like one of those books that flourishes as a book, but may not translate to screen very well. But, I'm not a screenwriter so who knows. It's just my opinion. I'll wait and see if it's actually turned into one, rather than the rights falling through like with most books. I'm not holding my breath, though.

I love the book, so I would definitely see it if it were to come out.


Alyssa Here we are in 2015 now... Is this ever happening?


fruitlupezzz Crystal wrote: "Julia wrote: "Crystal wrote: "http://www.joblo.com/horror-movies/ne..."

Horror movies? How would this be horror?"

It's considere..."

But they shouldn't because they don't always go together. The Hunger Games and The Maze Runner are both Sci-fi, but the movies to those books were not horror.


Sarah http://fangirlish.com/lauren-destefan...

According to this, the movie is not happening :/


Sarah I guess it's better than the possibility of a horrible movie ruining the book


Jacque that's fine by me. Personally I think it'd make a great tv show, but I'd really have to see how ABC Family does with "Shadowhunters" to know if they would be good with another series. But based on what they have done with "Pretty Little Liars" and how successful that is...


back to top