Enchantment question

I find them too hard to compare. I really enjoyed Ender's Game but, due to an overall love of fairy tales, enjoyed Enchantment more. On the other hand, Ender's Game has the series going for it and I enjoyed all the Ender books and the first few Bean ones as well and all that just prolongs the enjoyment.

I did like Enchantment more than Ender's game. It is a more mature work, for example, the machinations of Ender's brother and sister, the age of Ender and the fact that he was in command of a whole fleet strain the credibility of this reader.
I also think the short story was better than the novel; less padding.

I really enjoyed them both very much. Gives me hope that someday I might be able to write a few books of my own. :)

I also liked Enchantment more. Ender's Tale, although a good story, was never really anything special to me. And the fact that the 6-year-olds behave nothing like kids of that age should only strengthens that feeling.

Not even close. Enders Game was much better.