Go Harry Potter And Twilight! discussion

book one of harry potter and twilight!!

so, which one was better? more detailed? gave more info about the characters?

no one can think of anything to say?!

swati wut exactly is this?

okay, just say which book was better: first book oh HP or Twilight! and also why..

um...hp is the asme as twilight
I am sayin this becuz they both r completely nt relatd and it does nt make sense to compare them...
and also becuz THEY BOTH ROCK!!!

sry swati im a bit stressed out becuz of the resulte 2moro

but you can't just say it's the SAME! well okay i guess..it's your choice..

Well, I didn't read all the books of the Harry Potter series. I watched the movies first.

I'd probably have a difficult choice choosing which book is better.

But if I compare the movies, Harry Potter and the Sorcere Stone(the first one) is better.

Is that because the actors for each character were better in Harry Potter?

Well, I didn't read the first book of Harry Potter, so I didn't have nothing to compare the movie with.

Twilight, I read the book, and when I watched the movie, it was so different from the book.

In Twilight, I'm not saying that the the actors didn't act good.

No, i mean, they way they CHOSE the actors. Like people hated the actress who played Bella. Like that.

Kristen Stuert(sp?) played Bella. Yea, my cousin doesn't like her. I basically only saw her in the movie Twilight. I don't really find what's so bad about her or her acting. I'm not a fan of her, but that doesn't mean I don't like her.

Robert Patterson(i think that's his last name) played Edward. Well, one, I didn't expect his voice to be like that, of course he's from Europe.

Well, let's just compare the book here, i'll make a separate discussion for movies.

I personally enjoyed both books, but I think HP was better written for all ages than Twilight. When I first started the HP book, I was sucked into the story right away. It took me a couple times to start Twilight...mostly because it is written in first person.

Yeah, and HP isn't in first person. And also, Twilight is in a girls point of view, so it's mainly for girls, even if some guys read it. Whereas Harry Potter is for both girls and guys.

THEY BOTH ROCK!!!!!!!!!!!! But, I guess I would say the first book of Harry Potter was better than the first book of Twilight. Cause in the beginning Twilight is kinda boring.

I read Eclipse first, then New Moon, then Twilight, then Breaking dawn. and when I re-read them it was New moon, then twilight I think, and then I alternated between Eclipse and Breaking Dawn.... I think....

wow i always hav 2 read da books in order or else im sooo confused!!

I read the series of Unfortunate Events completely out of order. It was a bit confusing.

Yeah, it had to be!