SHERlocked discussion

So far of all the Sherlock Holmes novels/stories I've read this has been my favourite. What about you?

Completely the opposite, i didn't care for it at all. It's probably the most famous of all the Sherlock Holmes stories and i had high very expectations for it that it just didn't reach.

That's what happens when you have high expectations. Something has to be absolutely brilliant to meet it. (Look I did not miss spell meet:D)
I try to mostly not expect to much so I won't be disappointed.

That happens when I watch movies about a book that I've already read. Very disappointing :( I haven't read any of the books yet sadly but once I get through my pile from the library now, I will have to read them.

It's good, but i think to me, the short stories are better than the novels. right?

I prefer the short stories to. The first Sherlock Holmes book i read was "The adventures of Sherlock Holmes". It's the one i recommend that people start off with. If i had started with "The Hound of the Baskervilles" i probably wouldn't of continued the series.

I liked it, it was good. It's the only Sherlock Holmes book I've read, but even though it was a short book, it took two months to read it. I just wasn't that into it. But I liked it.

Hasham, you should read 'lock and key' it's a Sherlock story (not by Conan Doyle) about the childhood of Sherlock and moriarty.