I'm Definitely a Madman With a Box discussion

Just imagine if there was a queen of years on earth. It would seriously suck having to always remember crappy songs & poetry!

It wasn't crappy, it was amazing.

Yes the episode was amazing. I meant that if there was a queen like that here on earth then she have to remember a lot of terrible songs & poetry.

Yeah.

But they weren't that bad.

Oh cmon there have been plenty of crappy music here on earth for the past 20 years!

Just watched it, and I thought the thing took the Doctor's memories. It's been bugging me.

I thought it did too, then realized he was fine.

Yeah, but it went small, then got really big, and he was all collapsing, so what happened then??? It is totally bugging me!

I thought he'd disappeared! Then he was just off to the side. Did I miss something?

IDK, and also, these past episodes had barely any plot. THEY NEED TO GET BETTER!!! I like Tennant way better, and he would have done a better job on this, I think.

It was amazing though.

Yeah... I have to admit to that...

I liked the emotional aspects of this episode, but I felt there was too much sonic-ing and not enough cleverness. I don't feel involved enough to care who/what Clara is. I'd rather see more about the Doctor and River traveling together for a bit.

I loved it though I do want River to come back. (so bad)

I know. I've loved River since she first appeared.

I didn't...I always thought it should be The Doctor and Rose only but over time I learned to love her. And both ships.

Yeah now that I think about it...Why didnt they move from amy n rory straight into river song? It wouldve made more sense, but ill give clara a little more time. Maybe her character mystery is like rose & bad wolf?!

I'm not saying I'm happy he married her instead of Rose, but her character is fantastic. And Joshua, I agree that it would have made more sense to play with that storyline a bit longer, but I'll have to wait and see if I can like Clara in episodes to come.