TWILIGHT FOREVER!!!! discussion
Series Talk
>
Bella's Choice
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Apr 09, 2013 12:19PM
So tell me what you think about Bella's choosing Edward at the Edward Eclipse.
reply
|
flag
The heart wants what the heart wants...too bad she had to string Jacob along
Yeah if only Jacob would have read the sign more carefully then when might not have gotten hurt.
I thought she should've chose Jacob, but her and Edwward have better chemistry so it makes sense. And like Soreonne and Abby I think she shouldn't have kept Jacob's hopes up.
Yeah I think thing would have been really wired if she chose Jacob.
Abby wrote: "Yeah I think thing would have been really wired if she chose Jacob."Ya, but only b/c thats not how we know the story. If it was the other way around this way would be weird (does that even make sense??)
I think it was the correct decision....if you compare both the boys, then Edward's way better. But then, hey! she loves him! And when you love someone, even if he's the worst possible man for you, you are in the end - gonna choose him.
Ruchi wrote: "I think it was the correct decision....if you compare both the boys, then Edward's way better. But then, hey! she loves him! And when you love someone, even if he's the worst possible man for you, ..."
I agree with you completely.
I agree with you completely.
I think it was the right thing to do. I don't really like jake that much
Abby wrote: "I think it was the right thing to do. I don't really like jake that much"
I'm glad I'm not the only one that doesn't like Jacob.
I'm glad I'm not the only one that doesn't like Jacob.
Yeah I think he's a........ Annoying, stubborn and jealous wolf!!! Unlike Seth.... (No offence to anyone) :D
I just hated the way Jacob and Bella acted in New Moon. Jacob was being a jerk and annoying while Bella was just using him and leading him on. I did however like him at the end of Breaking Dawn.
Yeah same. That was the only time I liked him a little.... Only a little...
Yeah I just feel like Stephenie Meyer could have done Jacob a little better. I did however read in the illustrated guide that the only reason she made Jacob was so Edward wouldn't come out and say he's a vampire. Also she wrote New Moon the way she did so that we could see how different Bella's life would be if she chose Jacob. Even after reading this I still don't like Jacob, but I understand why he is a character better.
