BOOK DEBATE discussion

she is not a great and strong character

She always seems so dependent on everyone else

twilight67 wrote: "yes, in the second book it was jacob, then edward, then both of them, but in the fourth book at the end she was okay"

i agree. in the 4th book, however, the dumbest things happened!
- jacob imprinting on renesmee
- speaking of whom, since when could a vampire and a human have a baby? edward's body's been freezing for almost a century, no sperm could possibly have survived! i don't mind fantasy, but at least make it realistic-ish!
- of course bella doesn't go through the usual blood-addicted stage. that i expected. it annoys me how stephenie meyer makes her so perfect and imperfect, and hopes it balances out somehow
- at the end...bella's shield thing...i mean...come ON!
(i should shut up now, shouldn't i '-_- )