I'm Definitely a Madman With a Box discussion
Series 7
>
Nightmare in Silver
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Louie
(new)
May 11, 2013 02:41PM
Fantastic acting by Mr Smith tonight I loved his split personality role, this is why I think he is the perfect doctor, he has the arrogance of Colin baker (prob my fav), the fun of Tom and the sensibility of Peter!! The mystery of Clara is looking great, I'm definitely going for song related, or really hoping anyway!! I've heard rumours of it being to do with tenant and rose's child, this would be terrible worse than tessalecta terrible!! I really hope we revisit the library on 50th anniversary as probably only opportunity to do so!!
reply
|
flag
Mod
Mod
While I loved Matt Smith's performance, the rest of the episode seemed blah. Cybermen episodes are better told in a few episodes than just one, and I did not like how much they resembled the Borg in this one. If they'd have said "Resistance is futile," I would have shut it off.
Mod
Seriously? They did not. They might have said something similar, but that is the Borg's catchphrase. The Cybermen have never been able to adapt that quickly either; however, the Borg could. This episode(excluding Matt's spectacular performance) was a total rip off. I was disappointed.
Mod
In my opinion I loved this episode.
It doesn't matter who came first. We're not talking about that. I don't know how much longer I can stay in this group. You delete my comments when they're not inappropriate, just stating facts, and you can't have a discussion without gushing about how great it was, not acknowledging that there could ever be a flaw with the programme.
Mod
I'm not trying to argue. but there should be some debate in a discussion forum. Otherwise we're all just fangirlling.
