YAholics Anonymous! discussion

So, I thought of this game a little while ago and thought it would be fun!

There are many books who have alternate covers and editions. Now, it's time to pit them against each other. For this game, someone posts two different editions of the same book (using the "add book/cover" option) and the person who posts after them will give their opinion on which is better, before posting two more covers of a book.

Do you need help trying to figure out how to post different book covers?
It can be a little tricky if you don't know how. When you search for the book, it usually brings up only one cover, right? Beneath the "add" button, there's a little link that says "other editions." When you click that, it should bring up the other covers of the book and let you add them.

I'm eager to see if you guys like this game!

I'll start:

vs.

I like the artwork on the second one better.

How about Jennifer Scales and the Ancient Furnace?

vs.

I like the artwork on the first better. (Which is sad, cause my copy is the second one. :/)

How about Life of Pi?

vs.

I like the second one. The tiger on the first one looks weird how the head is just floating, lol.

How about Island of the Blue Dolphins?

vs.

I like the second one better. The first is kinda...awkward. XD

How about Throne of Glass?

vs.

This one is a little tough. The first one looks great, but I like how the second one is a drawing instead of an actual person. It shows more originality.

How about Hallowed?

vs.

I actually like the second one better, even though the first seems to be the general cover.

How about The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants?

vs.

I like the first one better...

How about Shatter Me?


vs.

I like the first better. The whole eye thing is weird to me, lol.

What about Keeping the Moon?

vs.

What is up with all the crotch and booty close-ups on books? I pick the second one. I like the purple and the fireworks. Although it's odd how there's not a moon on either one of them.

On a similar note, how about The Silver Moon Elm?

vs.

Lol. The infamous tramp stamp. XD I pick the first.

How about The Help?

vs.

I preffer the second one. The people are closer...

What about Delirium?


1.
2.
3.

First one.

first one

Brittany wrote: "So, I thought of this game a little while ago and thought it would be fun!

There are many books who have alternate covers and editions. Now, it's time to pit them against each other. For this gam..."
Why can't I add more than one cover of the same book? I tried with some examples you guys used too, but only one option of the cover shows up. Help?

Alicia B wrote: "Brittany wrote: "So, I thought of this game a little while ago and thought it would be fun!

There are many books who have alternate covers and editions. Now, it's time to pit them against each ot..."

It can be a little tricky if you don't know how. When you search for the book, it usually brings up only one cover, right? Beneath the "add" button, there's a little link that says "other editions." When you click that, it should bring up the other covers of the book and let you add them. Hope that helps, Alicia! :)

I like the second one best. (Lol, so many cover options! XD)

What about Divergent?

vs.

Brittany wrote: "Alicia B wrote: "Brittany wrote: "So, I thought of this game a little while ago and thought it would be fun!

There are many books who have alternate covers and editions. Now, it's time to pit th..."

Thanks. It wasn't tricky haha. :)

The first one.

What about Wings?

or

No problem! ^.^ I'll probably put it on the first post, in case other people have the same problem.

I like the second one better. More detail.

What about Jennifer Scales and the Messenger of Light?

vs.

The first one

I think the second is cuter....

What about Between Shades of Gray?

vs.

The second one looks better, i think...

vs vs

Aww, I like the first one! It's cute!

What about The Lightning Thief?

vs.

The second one is cooler!!!

vs vs

Hmm, that's hard. I think all of them are nice, but I like the first better.

How about Sisters Red?

vs.

I like the first one better.

How about Unwind?

vs.

The first one definitely would catch my if I was looking for a good novel...

vs.

I really like the second one. :)

vs. vs.

I think either the first or the second one.

How about The Book Thief

vs. vs. vs. vs.

Definitely the first one. That's the copy I have, and it's the one with the powerful symbol.

How about Shade

vs. vs.

I like the second one the best.

What about Birthmarked?

vs.

I prefer the first one.

What about Uglies?

vs. vs.

I like the first one the best.

What about Warm Bodies?

vs.

Hmmm hard to choose since I love both......

well ill choose the first one but I would rather much prefer



How about Angel Burn

vs.

I like the second one better.

What about The Perks of Being a Wallflower?

vs.

Hard to choose! I like this one the best :)

How about vs.

I like the first one. That's the copy I read. :)

What about What Happened to Goodbye?

vs.

I prefer the first one. I like that style of cover of all Sarah Dessen's books.

What about Willow?
vs. vs.
(They're all the same, though one book is under a different name.)

Hmmm, I like them all, but would probably go with the first.

What about Ender's Game?

vs. vs.

(The first one of Willow really connects with the story. I like that one the best too.)

I like the third one of Ender's Game the best.

What about Masquerade?

vs. vs.

They're all pretty, but I suppose I'd go with the second one.

What about Coraline?

vs. vs.

I really like the third one. :)

What about Cinder?

vs. vs. vs. vs.

I really like the second one. Very different.

What about Tiger's Curse?

vs.

I like the first one.

What about Pretties?

vs. vs. vs. vs.

I really like the third one. So pretty. :)

How about Howl's Moving Castle?

vs.

i like the second
how about Goddess
vs vs vs

I think the last one is the prettiest.

How about The Night Circus?

vs.

I like the first one.

How about Divergent?

vs.

First.