RiseUp! discussion
Movies
>
Narnia
message 1:
by
notyourfriend, ~Forgive Me~
(new)
Jun 05, 2013 02:14PM
Mod
reply
|
flag
Mod
I've seen all of them but I don't think I watched all of the voyage of the dawn treador I've seen
Prince caspian
The lion the witch and the wardrobe and the other one.
I like the first one the best
Mod
Mod
Mod
Mod
I heard they were making Silver Chair... Not sure where I heard that, or if it's true.
Mod
What hidden story...... Now I'm curious
Mod
I know that they are definitely making The Silver Chair. I saw on youtube some movie theatre interview guys talking about it. What got me mad was that they said that the 3rd movie was terrible! But they are making another movie. :)
I don't really like the idea of them remaking Silver chair only because Puddleglum won't be played by Tom Baker. Other than that I think that it will be quite good.
Mod
Paige, I think The Silver Chair movie won't be coming out until 2015 (Or at least, that's what I've heard via NarniaFans.com. I am disappointed that Andrew Adamson won't be directing it like he did for the first and second Narnia movie. I might watch it to see how it measures up with a different director and to see which cast members they chose for the characters. For some reason, Andrew lost the directing rights, so he didn't get to direct The Voyage of the Dawn Treader either. My guess is that the C.S Lewis foundation didn't think that he did the books justice (Because the movie characters have changed personalities from what they are in the book, some of the plot lines are changed.) Personally though I thought he did a great job, you have to make some changes from book to movie, because there are some things that can't work on screen like they can on the pages of a book.
Mod
Woah! They're making the Silver Chair?!??! That is so exciting!
The White Witch is the same as the Green Witch right? So I assume Tilda Swinton gets another big role? (lucky you, Mojo)
Dee wrote: "I absolutely loved the first movie. It was perfect! No complaints!!!Woah! They're making the Silver Chair?!??! That is so exciting!
The White Witch is the same as the Green Witch right? So I ass..."
I agree with you Dee. The first movie makes me feel good, it's full of fantasy and adventure
Mod
"
BWahahaha!!!
My dad loves the White Witch lol :p He mainly will only sit down to watch the Narnia films for her.
Dee wrote: "I absolutely loved the first movie. It was perfect! No complaints!!!Woah! They're making the Silver Chair?!??! That is so exciting!
The White Witch is the same as the Green Witch right? So I..."
Nope... Not the same... They might choose to use the same actress (I think the old movies did), but it's definitely not the same character.
Mod
Okay. I was looking it up the other day, and I think some people interpret her to be the same, but I have no idea!
Mojoboy31 wrote:
"
BWahahaha!!!"
LOL, Just for you! ;)
Narnian525♥♪ wrote: "Dee wrote: "I agree with you..
Well, thanks!
Mod
Paigetwo *Caitlyn* wrote: "Is Edmund in that one? That's all I care about ;P"Edmund isn't in the Silver Chair. Sorry to disappoint :/ It's another story with Diggory and Polly.
Mod
Paigetwo *Caitlyn* wrote: "Aw, come on! -_-"I understand. I was disappointed when Susan wasn't in Voyage of the Dawn Treader. She DID have a cameo, but to me that doesn't count all the way.
Mod
Paigetwo *Caitlyn* wrote: "Eh, like I said, I didn't really care that the others weren't in the movie. I loved Voyage of Dawn Treader cause Edmund had such a big part in it."Why do you like him? Just wondering. Any specific reason?
Narnian525♥♪ wrote: "Paigetwo *Caitlyn* wrote: "Is Edmund in that one? That's all I care about ;P"Edmund isn't in the Silver Chair. Sorry to disappoint :/ It's another story with Diggory and Polly."
.... No, it's a different pair. Eustace (who we originally meet in Voyage of the Dawn Treader) and Jill Pole.
My opinion:
They did it wrong.
See, the first movie was phenomenal! I loved it! But. They spent to much time between movies and the actors are growing up to fast! There is no possible way for them to make all the movies. Georgie Henley--little Lucy Pevensie, is EIGHTEEN! Edmund is 22, Susan 25, and Peter 26! How can they make movies about children when they're that old? If they'd filmed each movie in sequence and released them year after year after year like with LOTR, it would've worked.
They did it wrong.
See, the first movie was phenomenal! I loved it! But. They spent to much time between movies and the actors are growing up to fast! There is no possible way for them to make all the movies. Georgie Henley--little Lucy Pevensie, is EIGHTEEN! Edmund is 22, Susan 25, and Peter 26! How can they make movies about children when they're that old? If they'd filmed each movie in sequence and released them year after year after year like with LOTR, it would've worked.
Jennifer wrote: "Narnian525♥♪ wrote: "Paigetwo *Caitlyn* wrote: "Is Edmund in that one? That's all I care about ;P"Edmund isn't in the Silver Chair. Sorry to disappoint :/ It's another story with Diggory and Poll..."
Oh! Ok. Thanks for pointing out my mistake Jennifer. Lol sorry I always get them mixed up :p
Mod
They did it wrong.
See, the first movie was phenomenal! I loved it! But. They spent to much time between movies and the actors are growing up to fast! There is no possible way for the..."
Age always seems to mess everything up.
Mod
Why do you like him? ..."
Cause! He is the best! He is awesome.
A҉b҉b҉y҉ {I want a hippopotamus for Christmas!} wrote: "My opinion:They did it wrong.
See, the first movie was phenomenal! I loved it! But. They spent to much time between movies and the actors are growing up to fast! There is no possible way for the..."
Here's the thing about Narnia: It does not continually focus on the same four children throughout the series. It shifts its focus to different children here and there. My disappointment is not with the length of time between movies or allowing the cast to get older. My disappointment is mainly with the fact that each time the series has been made into film, they've skipped over The Magician's Nephew, The Horse's Boy, and The Last Battle –– all three of which give a completeness to the entire series.
Also, the addition of unnecessary romance to the stories... Really. Just... Ugh. Disney should really keep its hands out of some pies...
Narnian wrote: Oh! Ok. Thanks for pointing out my mistake Jennifer. Lol sorry I always get them mixed up :p S'ok... I actually had to look up who it was, but I knew it wasn't them... ;)
Mod
They did it wrong.
See, the first movie was phenomenal! I loved it! But. They spent to much time between movies and the actors ..."
What did they add?
The mushy moments between Caspian and Susan did not happen in the books... Just... No. I am adamantly against adding romance into tales where it was never intended to be, and Disney has a habit of doing exactly that. Don't get me wrong. I like romance, but I don't like it when it's not part of the original story.
Jennifer wrote: "The mushy moments between Caspian and Susan did not happen in the books... Just... No. I am adamantly against adding romance into tales where it was never intended to be, and Disney has a habit of ..."I agree.
Mod
Princess Dee wrote: "Especially when it's Caspian and Susan. Please, no!"Right?!
Mod
*coughs* Tauriel! *cough, cough*
Mod
I thought it was so awkward. Especially her "It wouldn't have worked out anyway. After all I am 1300 years older than you." What?
Mojoboy31 wrote: "Jennifer wrote: "The mushy moments between Caspian and Susan did not happen in the books... Just... No. I am adamantly against adding romance into tales where it was never intended to be, and Disne..."Oh yeah... I hate it when the movie makers add a character that wasn't even in the original book.
Mod
Mod
Oooh, well, I didn't.like that, and I didn't even read the book.
Mod
I can assure you there was no romance between Susan and Caspian in the book!
Princess Dee wrote: "Paigetwo *Caitlyn* wrote: "Jennifer wrote: "The mushy moments between Caspian and Susan did not happen in the books... Just... No. I am adamantly against adding romance into tales where it was neve..."Yeah, they barely talked to each other in the book.
