Crushed discussion

Ok i know I see a lot of people don't this series so I apologize if my fangirl moment irritates you but i'm so what the hell is going on I mean i've known for awhile there are two A's but seriously is it really Ali and Trip? What does she mean Noel is as two faced as they come? Ugh my head is spinning. I just wanted to hear if anyone else has any theories there willing to bounce around.

I think Tripp is Nick (from Ali's Pretty Little Lies). When Emily and Iris go to Tripp's mom's house, the mailbox says "Maxwell" on it. Maxwell is Nick's last name. I'm pretty sure Nick/Tripp helped Real Ali kill Courtney and that he and Real Ali are the two "A"s.

I have no idea why Noel is two-faced; I don't quite understand Noel's involvement in the whole thing. People are always getting killed before we get a chance to find out the truth about them! I do think he was Ali's boyfriend though.

Olivia wrote: "I think Tripp is Nick (from Ali's Pretty Little Lies). When Emily and Iris go to Tripp's mom's house, the mailbox says "Maxwell" on it. Maxwell is Nick's last name. I'm pretty sure Nick/Tripp he..."

I totally agree with you I just wish we could've found out what Graham was going to say before he died. And I wonder if that was Real Ali or if it's two girls as A and not a male and female. Do you think Noel knew that Courtney swapped places with Ali and that's why he kept seeing her in the preserve?

Christine wrote: "Olivia wrote: "I think Tripp is Nick (from Ali's Pretty Little Lies). When Emily and Iris go to Tripp's mom's house, the mailbox says "Maxwell" on it. Maxwell is Nick's last name. I'm pretty sur..."

I think Graham was trying to say "Nick," which wouldn't have been helpful unless he had been able to explain, since the girls never knew about Nick. I do think Noel knew about the switch. I just don't understand how he could love Real Ali, especially if he really did know that she murdered her sister. Maybe he didn't know that, though.

I wonder how he even found out about the twins since it was so hush hush ya know? And what happened to Spencer's dad? they got a divorce right? Another question why was Iris so nice do you think she's trying to set the girls up or was she sincere?

Christine wrote: "I wonder how he even found out about the twins since it was so hush hush ya know? And what happened to Spencer's dad? they got a divorce right? Another question why was Iris so nice do you think sh..."

I think Real Ali told Noel about the switch. Spencer's dad moved out after the divorce. I think Iris was being sincere; I don't know why she would feel any loyalty to Ali. I think Iris is a little crazy but harmless.

Okay i forgot I wonder why he's no longer mentioned in the storyline i thought maybe A would target him a bit more since he is ali courtney and spencer's dad. Do you think Noel believed her? I mean why would he when no one else did I mean if you were locked up in an asylum wouldn't you claim to be the sane twin?

Do you think Noel is dead because yes it basically tells u he is dead with the description of his body when they find him ... but im still curious. i also agree that it could be Nick helping Ali. I also think that Ali had another boyfriend/visitor who visited her and Iris only saw Noel so she assumed he was the only one.

Tripp/Nick might not have visited her at the Preserve after he left; he might have only emailed her. (I think she mentioned them emailing at some point.)

Nick is Tripp really Noel?! I love Noel! I hope he isn't dead hopefully just hurt. Agreed I think Iris is a little crazy I think Ali and Iris were fighting over Tripp. When it came to Graham to I think he was trying to say no it wasn't Noel.

I don't understand why people think Noel could be alive... the description made his death pretty clear to me. I think Graham was trying to say "Nick," but it wouldn't have been helpful because the girls don't know Nick.

It's a cliff hanger though I mean look at Graham he was in a coma who knows what will come of Noel

Katrin (kitkatkathy!) wrote: "Christine wrote: "It's a cliff hanger though I mean look at Graham he was in a coma who knows what will come of Noel"

So true. But I think that was "Kyla's" fault. And who else saw that coming? To..."
lol i had an inkling she was because it would be to big of a coincidence for Iris and Kyla to both appear as good guys in the same book at least to me it did.