Dumbledore's Army discussion

It was my favorite book! Except when sirius almost died :(

Yeah, this book was pretty awesome..

I think the plot was great and the whole time laps thing worked well.

I loved this book, but it's actually my least favorite of the whole series. The third movie is my favorite of all the movies so far, though.

really?
i loved the book and movie!!

the book is ok...
movie wasn't great.

I though the dementers were cool. Evil but cool(no pun intended)

:P

Although I strongly dislike dementors.

I just think the graphics were great. they are the best monsters.

This book was mmm....maybe fourth on my list?
1. 5th.
2. 7th
3. 3rd
4. 2nd
5. 1st
6. 6th
7. 4th

.........confusing

Mine:

1. 5th
2. 7th
3. 3rd
4. 1st
5. 2nd
6. 4th
7. 6th

Not that I didn't like the 6th, I just didn't like it as much as the rest.

Lol!!

Almost perfect :/

Mine:

7th
5th
4th
6th
1st
2nd
3rd

Yeah, I liked it, but I liked thee rest better.

Out of the five i've read:

5
4
3
2
1

4
7
6
3
2
1
5

all jumbled up!
fifth sucked.

Samiha, why don't you like OotP? I love it so much. I enjoy that it is darker than most of HBP. Harry's anger doesn't bother me at all in the book - it's perfectly natural given the events of GoF.

Courtney, I'm not sure why the PoA is my least favorite. It's so hard to pick a least favorite, since all the books are so good. I know a lot of people love the third one, but I just enjoy the first two more.

Pandy wrote: "Samiha, why don't you like OotP? I love it so much. I enjoy that it is darker than most of HBP. Harry's anger doesn't bother me at all in the book - it's perfectly natural given the events of GoF.
..."

Yeah, I thought it was pretty much natural too. I mean, he just witnessed a friend's death!

no i don't mind about harry's temper. he has one in DH too!! it's just that the book seemed kind of boring, like without enuf action. that's y i luved GOF. it was awesome!!

I thought it had plenty of action, but it's fine that you like GoF better. I liked it too, just not as much as the fifth. GoF actually seemed less exciting to me.

Courtney wrote: "I liked GoF. It was AWESOME!!! "

TOTALLY!!

It was good, but I didn't like it the best.

Oh wow,it took me longer...

Swati wrote: "It was good, but I didn't like it the best."


*gasp*
GO SIRIUS!!
*does a happy dance for him*

SIRIUS IS AWESOME!

SAME HERE!!!!!

Oh, same here. James is high in that list too.

And..Snape?

Me too! VOldy was so cruel to him in the end!

hehe my fav adult was Tonks.....so clumsy!!!

I know! She's always knocking things over!

I know! She is SO FUNNY!
:p
:D
:)

yea same here....
the actress was kinda too pretty for tonks...
in my opinion

Hm, I thought she wasn't bad..too pretty? I dunno about that..

I actually like her (Natalia Tena) for the role. She doesn't look exactly how I imagine Tonks to look, but it's pretty close. She does look a bit like a boy in some of the pictures for HBP movie though.

Yeah, but the thing is, I don't really remeber how I pictured her, so I think she's fine..

I picture her with more spiky hair, but like I said before, I think Natalia Tena is fine.

Pandy wrote: "I picture her with more spiky hair, but like I said before, I think Natalia Tena is fine. "

Hm, I think I pictured her with a little bit of spiky-ness, I think.

I picture her with spiky hair because she's described that way sometimes.

yea i imagined it spiky, too.
but the actress was pretty....that's a good thing.

Samiha wrote: "yea i imagined it spiky, too.
but the actress was pretty....that's a good thing."

I agree. I pictured spiky hair.

I hated the third movie.

You hated it? Why?

Well all of the movie was changed. I liked the way Harry got his Firebolt in the book, but it was totally boring in the way he got it in the movie. Then the quidditch match in which harry used the firebolt was not shown. The way the movie was changed when compared with the book is the main for me hating the sandaime movie

Yeah, but..=(

What??

Lol, nothing. I still like it, even with all of that.

I liked the dementors they were the best monsters type things :)