Books I Loathed discussion

It's a LOT better than the movie, that's for sure! I liked it well enough when I read it, but that was back in 2005, so don't know if I'd like it as much today.

Hard to say because they are quite different. I think I prefer Northern Lights though... mostly because Patrick Rothfuss' contineous foreshadowing became quite ridiculous after awhile. It put me off enough that I've never read the sequel.