YA Bookworms discussion
Debate questions
>
Which is the worst ending: mocking jay vs Allegiant?
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Feb 28, 2014 08:35PM
Definitely Allegiant. The ending of mocking jay was still terrible but after finishing allegiant I might as well read mocking jay to cheer myself up. I understand how mrs roth wanted us to learn sacrifice. BUT WHY COULDNT CALEB LEARN SACRIFICE!!!??!?!? Seriously. What did y'all think?
reply
|
flag
I would have to agree! Mainly because I never really liked Prim anyways so I wasn't that upset, but I was so devastated when Tris …nope…can't even acknowledge it…it didn't happen! Anyways! Definitely Allegiant!
I finished it last night and hated the end. At least mockingjay had a somewhat happy ending. While allegient had no happy ending at all.
Allegiant all the way. It just felt totally out of sync with where the series had been going and I remember reading it and being angry. I didn't love Mockinjay but at least it made sense.
Allegiant was worse. I hated the way it ended. I was angry when I first read it. I can't believe she did that.
Mockingjay was worse. Hello stinky epilogue! At lest the main character didn't...you know :p
Hated Mockingjay. I skimmed through it because it got so overwhelming and blehhh. Allegiant over Mockingjay, any day.
Allegiant had an emotionally powerful ending. I had so many emotions going on... Mockingjay fell flat. It just sorta felt like the author just wanted to hurry up and finish the books or something.
DEFINITELY ALLEGIANT! I officially hate Caleb....in the book. Its pretty hard to hate the Caleb in the movie bc the same actor plays Gus.
Yes. I know both character leaves us with mixed feels
Allegiant for SURE!! I was so devastated when I finished Allegiant! I mean WHO kill their main character?!?! I just don;t get it. And it was so emotional, so many different emotional all tangled up into like a few chapters. . . .urgh! Definitely Allegiant!
Freakin Allegiant...what the actual heck?!
Allegiant!! Just.. The feelings.... AAAAH!!!! But mockingjay had a more relaxed ending, everything was well, even if it wasn't well at all
