Jurassic Park (Jurassic Park, #1) Jurassic Park discussion


451 views
Lex

Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Nazli Djalali Was anyone else wishing Lex would be eaten by something?


Craig Most of Michael Crichton's characters are worthy of such an experience. Typical of Spielberg to make everyone adorable in the film.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgjDSf...


Gerd Nope, don't remember wanting to see her die. :D


Jason Sullivan Yes, she was extremely self-centered and obnoxious. I really was hoping she would be eaten by a dinosaur.


Nazli Djalali Good, glad it's not just me :P


message 6: by Jon (new) - rated it 3 stars

Jon I understand her role to the story, she sets off a lot of events in the book which make it more dramatic, but holy moly is she annoying. She's so annoying that it takes away from the quality of the story, she doesn't do anything right the whole book, her entire effect is negative.


message 7: by Daniel J. (last edited Apr 28, 2014 09:38PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Daniel J. Nickolas Jon wrote: "she doesn't do anything right the whole book, her entire effect is negative.
"


If she was a teenager (like in the movie) I would understand, but isn't she only five in the book.


Benja I don't remember her being annoying at all.


Nazli Djalali Felix J. wrote: "Jon wrote: "she doesn't do anything right the whole book, her entire effect is negative.
"

If she was a teenager (like in the movie) I would understand, but isn't she only five in the book."


There's lots of children in literature that don't serve only to aggravate and bring disaster down on the other characters.


message 10: by Kain (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kain Though the entire book I found her annoying and the amount of times she said she was hungry I just really wished she would be eaten as others here have said.


message 11: by S (new) - rated it 5 stars

S B YES!!! I actually used to work as a computer programmer and database analyst/designer. So in the part where Tim is trying to figure out a machine interface he has never seen or used before and get the power back on and she's just yelling in his ear how he can't do it, I seriously wanted something to eat her. Or at least pop her in the mouth or something. Spielberg certainly tends to make kids lovable, but there's something so tension inducing about a child screaming in your ear as you're trying to save them. I love both movie and book-- differently. But it was things like this that made me love Crichton's characterizations in the book.


message 12: by Kain (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kain I totally agree that both book and movie were both enjoyable in different way's as you've said Samuel R. Though something that amused me was that in the movie Lex seemed to be the older child and also the computer nerd where as in book she was obviously younger and Tim was the computer nerd. Oh and thumb's up about previously being a computer programmer!


message 13: by Suge (new) - rated it 5 stars

Suge I don't think I wanted her to die, but I wish they would have found some way to shut her up and get her to just let the people in charge do what they have to in order to survive. She was the type of character that just grated on your nerves. I guess every book has that type of character.


message 14: by Kain (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kain Yes every book has an annoying character you dislike and wish bad luck on but usually that's the antagonist.


message 15: by Suge (new) - rated it 5 stars

Suge She was no Nedry though lol


message 16: by Kain (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kain No that's true. He got what was coming to him :)


message 17: by S (new) - rated it 5 stars

S B Hammond was a big jerk too. But yeah, Tim being the older computer nerd and Lex being a whiny brat took me a while to get used to since I've seen the movie at least 100 times. No joke, at my house when we get bored, we put on Jurassic Park (or Law & Order: SVU, but that's a different story). I pretty much pictured everyone as their actor.

But as far as Lex, I love that that was her character, as much as I hated her. I think it added much more tension that wasn't in the film. The film was a visual spectacle, but the book was very tense and cerebral. It made me think of all the clients I had to deal with as a programmer or even my spoiled kid cousins. I especially hated the part where she finds the walkie (or sat phone) and won't let Tim use it to call for help because she found it first and wants to have the first turn with it. smh. I almost threw something :\


message 18: by Kain (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kain Oh yeah Hammond definitely got what was coming to him as well. I pictured everyone as their actor too :) you have to if you watch the film first because you have that base knowledge in your head already. I bet you were prepared to throw the book then realized what you were doing right?


message 19: by S (new) - rated it 5 stars

S B Haha, yeah. And to be fair, the film follows the book pretty closely up until stuff starts going wrong in the park. Like I was pretty surprised that the movie Nedry was a bit more fleshed out than the book Nedry.


message 20: by Kain (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kain Oh definitely, there was an explanation that made you understand how he came about to do what he did. Where as in the film it's more along the lines of "what..who what's going on?" you know?


Daniel J. Nickolas Samuel R wrote: "I've seen the movie at least 100 times. No joke, at my house when we get bored, we put on Jurassic Park "

My brother and I had the movie memorized when we were kids. Not to get off topic, but it's like the perfect movie: not too gory (as far as blood goes), it's action packed, there's a moral; et cetera.

I wonder if the decision to make Lex older in the movie was out of not wanting to deal with a too young a child actor. Children are great, but with all the running and fence climbing Grant and the kids did in the movie, I doubt a five year old would have been believable.


Barakiel I thought she was eight?

Yes, she was annoying. It's a good thing I wasn't there, because I would have thrown her overboard.


message 23: by [deleted user] (new)

Yes, there wasn't one thing that was likeable about her character in the book. I love Crichton's books, but as someone who generally doesn't like kids in movies anyway, I'm glad Spielberg changed this to make both the kids more likeable.


Brooklyn Ann I read this book like 5 times when I was 10 (after seeing the movie a zillion times) I do remember the kid being obnoxious. Sometimes I suspect that Chricton didn't like kids, LOL.


message 25: by [deleted user] (new)

Brooklyn wrote: "Sometimes I suspect that Chricton didn't like kids, LOL."

That wouldn't surprise me. Perhaps he modeled that aspect of Dr. Grant on himself.

Or was that only in the movie that Dr. Grant hated kids? It's been a while now....


Brooklyn Ann I think it may have been in the book too...unless they did another switcharoo and it was a different character in the book who disliked children.


message 27: by S (new) - rated it 5 stars

S B No, I think it was just the movie. I think he was indifferent in the book. I don't remember anything specific about him disliking kids.


Nicole Carli In the book he loved kids, he was really great with them. In the movie I read Spielberg made him hate kids so that we could see him grow with Lex and Tim throughout the movie and it was more heartfelt. I actually Liked Lex better in the book than in the movie... Is it just me? I found her annoying in the movie haha! In the book she was just a typical cute kid with no patience.


message 29: by [deleted user] (new)

Hm, that's one way of looking at it. I never saw it that way before, but I guess her character could be interpreted that way.


Emerald Hughes I liked her in the book, but film Lex gave the impression that she was completely in love with Grant and that kind of annoyed me.


B. Marshall I actually read the book, with a rather fresh outlook, as I still havn't seen the movie for a good 10 years, so I was able to take all of the characters, exactly as they appear in the book.

It was a slight annoyance how young the kids were in the book, and yes, especially Lex. It must have been the first time I genuinely felt annoyed with a character in a book, and strangely enough, annoyed in a positive sense that encouraged me to keep reading.

Glad that this was a topic.


message 32: by Matthew (new) - added it

Matthew Tanijiri i thought that Lex played a big part in the movie and i thought she did not have the to die. However in the book she just complained and nearly joined in a river with a t-rex in the end of it


message 33: by S (new) - rated it 5 stars

S B Yes, B. Marshall, you make a very good point. "annoyed in a positive sense..."

Lex was not an annoying character. She was a character who was annoying. I was never truly annoyed at how Crichton wrote the character, I was definitely more annoyed at Lex for being the character she was. It certainly added to the suspense, and (unfortunately) I know many kids like her.

In a way, as shallow as her book character was, there may have been more depth to her than her movie counterpart.


Elizabeth I love that book as well as the movies,only problem is when we moved in 2011 to where we live now a lot of my books got lost or missed placed by the people who helped us move and that was one of the books that got lost,so I have to get a new copy of it .


message 35: by Histolicious (new)

Histolicious Histolicious Oh God.
The scene in the computer room.
Tim tries to figure out how the system is working and she just press some buttons.

Urgh ... i hated her in this moment. Because this books give me gooseflesh. And the Raptors. DAMN. DAAAAAMN ... the damn Raptors. And she knows they´re outside, hunting them, killing the others, and she presses the damn button ... and I was like OMFG ... i hate her!


message 36: by [deleted user] (new)

Pat wrote: "Was anyone else wishing Lex would be eaten by something?"

absolutely!


message 37: by HV (last edited May 10, 2016 06:23PM) (new)

HV Pat wrote: "Was anyone else wishing Lex would be eaten by something?"

Omg yes! Im reading it now and its so annoying that i just have to google to see if anyone's felt the same way. U'd think being a few feet away from a gigantic carnivorous dinosaur would shut her up, but noooo, she has to start wailing to let it know where they are. Somebody shut the brat up!!!


message 38: by Gordon (new)

Gordon Sands Truly sick people wanting a little girl to get eaten ;)


Fire Type Well, I don't think I ever wished for her to get eaten, but I would not have minded if Grant had gotten separated from the kids for a while so we wouldn't have to have her character featured so prominently. I suppose Crichton wanted to show the terror that she would be feeling, but I definitely preferred Tim.

The Jurassic Park movie was a pleasant surprise, as I've grown used to having my expectations unfulfilled when movies are made of my favorite books. However, I thoroughly enjoyed the movie--and especially the portrayal of Nedry--though (view spoiler).


Nicole Lex is one of the reasons why I dislike the book so much, and -- le gasp! -- preferred the film treatment.


message 41: by Nick (new)

Nick When you really think about it, Lex is the epitome of "chaos theory". Her continuous, unpredictable, selfish behavior reminds us that anything can happen. Much like the animals, she can't be controlled! But yes, she should be eaten.


Lindsey I also thought this character displayed some other disturbing personal traits. For example, she cried when the island was being blown up, but earlier in the story when they find what is left of a security guard she detachedly asks something like 'Where's the rest of him?" Psycho.


message 43: by Cathie (new)

Cathie I’m really enjoying the book, it is so suspenseful however, I cannot remember the last time a character annoyed me so much! I’m actually saying out loud ‘shut up stupid brat’ and wishing she’d get eaten by the T rex. Her nagging is constant and she’s a mean spoiled brat. I actually had to stop reading and Google ‘the character Lexi is so annoying’ and found this thread. Reading your comments made me feel better. I’ll keep reading lol knowing I’m not alone.


back to top