Harry Potter Fans discussion

J.K. Rowling killed off a lot of our favorite characters I mean Fred, Dumbledore, Sirius, Remus, Tonks, Mad Eye Moody, Dobby the list goes on and on. But what if you could save 1 of them. Who would it be? Let us know!

SO,SO,SO hard!!

This I can't even think of!!! So tough! All of them! I mean it!

Even though it is so hard I would probably save Fred, Dumbledore, Sirius, or Tonks so she could take care of Teddy.

I would probably save and in order Fred, Remus, Dobby, Cedric and Hedwig

Yes Fred would be my first, he'd wig my second, dumbledore my third, actually this is soo wrong.... And tough!

I would save all of them at the same time

Fred, because he had so many more years to live and so many great accomplishments in front of him.. And Lupin, because he's just my favourite character.. He is so genuine and kind. I feel like I can relate to him in many ways.

Fred of course. The first time I read the part he died I had to read it again to make sure it was real. How could you kill off Fred he was awesome and it left George all alone without his partner in crime :( Then I would save Dobby because Dobby always had the best intentions and wanted to help as much as possible

Yes, one of the worst parts of Fred's death was knowing that George was left without him.

Either Fred or Sirius. Dobby's death was terrible and I wish he hadn't died, but I feel like everyone would be happier if they were still alive even if they've accepted the fact that they're dead.

Yeah, I think those two deaths were the hardest on everyone.

Fred, Sirius and Dobby were probably the hardest deaths for me

...

Oh yep tears are coming to my eyes

You've just made me have tears in my eyes!

Me too!

same

Ya, its just so sad...

I would definitely save Fred. Or Snape. Or Dobby. Or Hedwig. Or Tonks. Or Lupin. Or Sirius. Or Lily. Or James. Or MadEye. One of them

How about we just save them all?

That is a fantastic idea

Yes I would save every single person who died cuz like I said, can't get over them!!

I can't and never will.

Ya I know, I will never get over it

I always get teary eyed when I think of Fred

This is soo hard.
I will save everyone!!

Though my favourite characters are Remus and Tonks I think one could not live without the other and so I'd save Fred. Then he and George would be together and could bring a little light in the darkness. :)

I agree with you Elisa!

If it came down to a choice, I think I would most likely save Hedwig, because even if Hedwig didn't die, then the story wouldn't change by much. Also, maybe Harry could have stayed in touch with someone on the outside, such as Ginny. The problem of not seeing her in so long would be solved.

Yeah I actually had tears in my eyes when headwig died!!!!!!

I can save all of them using the time turner

Genius Sadie

Yeah that's brilliant.

That's really smart, Sadie. I never would have thought of that.

That is what I am saying

Wow Sadie! Never thought of that.... Actually I kinda did.... But I didn't think of it that much.

Fred. I thought this decision would be a lot harder but it turns out I found it easy to choose. Fred had his whole life ahead of him and his loss would've affected George so strongly, as well as the rest of the Weasleys. His death hit me the hardest out of everyone else's in the entre series.

Sadie wrote: "This might sound kind of weird at first but there is a lot of logic behind it. I would chose to save Tom Riddle's mother, Merope Gaunt. If Tom had grown up with a mother to love him he might not ha..."

That is brilliant!

Right!

Sadie wrote: "This might sound kind of weird at first but there is a lot of logic behind it. I would chose to save Tom Riddle's mother, Merope Gaunt. If Tom had grown up with a mother to love him he might not ha..."

Hey I was thinking the same thing.

Fred

Ya... Soooooo sad.

what a difficult question, I would have to say Sirius, I think it would of been nice for Harry to have him in his life.

I would save Remus lupin and severus Snape and Lily potter. So that Lily and severus can be togthwr. I ship them

Ryan wrote: "what a difficult question, I would have to say Sirius, I think it would of been nice for Harry to have him in his life."

Yes thank you

i wouldn't save james, lupin, siruis, tonks, or lily because they would be totally heart broken without the others, seeing as we're only saving ONE person...
So i'd probably go with fred, to re-unite the weasleys..

Sadie wrote: "This might sound kind of weird at first but there is a lot of logic behind it. I would chose to save Tom Riddle's mother, Merope Gaunt. If Tom had grown up with a mother to love him he might not ha..."

wow....i'd never have thought of that but thats basically saving like EVERYONE else in the process...cuz then there would be no Voldemort!

Sirius black. Because he's Harry's godfather. And Remus lupin because he should raise teddy.

Freaking all of them. That are good. Duh