JPathon discussion

3 views
Songs of the Humpback Whale > SOTHW Chapters 61-65

Comments Showing 1-3 of 3 (3 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Kris (new)

Kris (xokristim) | 114 comments Mod
Here we can post topics up to and including chapter 65 :)


message 2: by Kris (new)

Kris (xokristim) | 114 comments Mod
I feel like Jane seeing the news the night Oliver confesses his love for her was another crazy scenario in this book. Not once did it ever mention her watching the news. I think that Jane was being extremely unreasonable when she needs Sam tell Hadley to leave. Personally I think Sam should have stood up to her and said no he is my best friend and I am not making him leave, he belongs here.


Lilkadykitty :) | 98 comments Mod
I totally get that. I mean there is an age difference between them so what. I feel that Hadley was the best thing that came to Rebecca. No wonder she ran away with him. Now then, Oliver showing up and knowing that he was going to get Jane back was kinda ridiculous. For one she left you why would you think she would want to come back to you with open arms, He was a complete jerk to Sam. I mean I get he was a bit jealous of his wife sleeping with other man but he didn't have to try and kill him. If I could rewrite this part of the book I would have some divorce papers ready to give to him when he got there. I think Jane is a little out of herself but I would say I could see her more with Sam than Oliver.


back to top